marmendymill's The Amazing Spider-Man #3 - Spider-Man Versus Doctor Octopus review

The First "Heavyweight" Villain

The cover: 4 stars

A good cover spoiled by my pet hate in comic books, the dreaded word balloon. They disappeared around the end of 1963 and didn’t really re-appear until early 1970. I always felt that they diminished the artist’s power to entice the reader into buying the comic based on pure imagery. Spidey is being held helpless by 4 mechanical arms attached to a shadowy, menacing figure so why do we need a word balloon stating exactly what we can see for ourselves. It’s nowhere near as good as the issue #2 cover, but it’s still one of the iconic images from Spider-Man’s history because it’s the first sight of one of Spidey’s greatest villains.

The Strangest Foe Of All Time … Doctor Octopus (21 pages)

The first full length story for our new hero, guest starring the Human Torch and the most powerful foe he has faced yet, but it’s still early days for our idol. We’re only up to issue #3, Spidey’s sixth adventure and already he’s getting cocky thinking he’s unbeatable and a few pages later he gets beaten, loses his confidence, is inspired to try again, fights back against the odds and, of course, eventually wins. Yes, this story sets the trend for many, many future story-lines.

Stan’s dialogue is a bit stilted, lacking some the humour we usually associate with our hero and Steve’s artwork isn’t quite as good as the previous issue, but it’s still a brilliant comic, after all Spidey/Peter’s character is still in it’s formative stages.


Exactly how Peter’s Spider sense works still seems to be undecided at this point. He senses danger … yes, but he also uses his spider sense to locate the Human Torch in his hotel room, which sort of negates the need to develop his spider tracer later on. Also in issue #2 he locates the Tinkerer by sensing the radio waves in the doctored radios.

We have the first appearance of the letters page, the Spider’s Web.

There’s also a bonus pin-up page.     

Posted by CM_Cameron

 Spidey is being held helpless by 4 mechanical arms attached to a shadowy, menacing figure so why do we need a word balloon stating exactly what we can see for ourselves. 

The early Spider-Man comics are full of this type of writing, and I too never saw the need for it. Stan got better about it as time went on, though. If I remember correctly, by the end of Ditko's run on the comic, it wasn't much of an issue, if one at all. Or perhaps it was and it just took me almost forty issues to get used to the style. Who knows?
Now that I think about it, the style is bad in a sort of endearing way. I actually miss it a bit now.

Other reviews for The Amazing Spider-Man #3 - Spider-Man Versus Doctor Octopus

    The First Really Good Spider-Man Story 0

    Part of CV's Top 100 Spider-Man Universe Stories - reviewed!Prior to this, Spider-Man appeared in Amazing Fantasy, Fantastic Four Annual, and two previous isssues of The Amazing Spider-Man. The trouble was, he still hadn't fought a villain worth his salt. The Chameleon? The Vulture? The Tinkerer?That changed with this issue. Instead of two short stories, we get an entire comic book length tale that introduces Spider-Man's first real challenge - Doctor Octopus. And Doc Ock really does feel like a...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.