Swamp Thing #19

Posted by G-Man (39235 posts) - - Show Bio

The Good

Rotworld had some great moments despite parts of the overall story dragging. After a powerful final issue, Alec Holland, as Swamp Thing, is moving in a new direction. Charles Soule swoops in and takes full control over the character as he truly accepts his role as the avatar of the Green.

Holland's narration as he goes about his business is interesting. We see his struggle to retain his humanity despite being a plant. He can feel the draw of the Green and we even get a glimpse at what it is really like.

As seen on the cover, there's going to be a confrontation with Superman. The reasoning does make sense, in a way. It was in the very first issue that Superman paid Holland a visit. Now it's Alec's turn to visit Superman to ask some important questions. This is where Soule's taking a risk in bringing Swamp Thing into the rest of the DCU. The good and bad thing about Scott Snyder's run was the feeling the title took place in a separate corner of the DCU. At times it was perfectly fitting but you do want to see that the characters are part of a larger world.

The choice of Scarecrow is also odd but the explanation too makes sense here. Having a brief mention to JUSTICE LEAGUE OF AMERICA #2 was great.

The art by Kano works here and seeing how Swamp Thing's appearance differs slightly depending on where specifically he is was a nice touch.

The Bad

Some of Holland's narration felt off. We're talking about a guy who was essentially 'dead' for some time (resurrected right before the New 52 began at the end of BRIGHTEST DAY).

Having Swamp Thing go to Metropolis almost feels too sudden after 18 issues (plus the zero issue). The same with his confrontation with Scarecrow. We had a character with pretty much no interactions and now we're seeing him go up against a random Batman villain. It is interesting but it's something we could have been eased into. Also, Superman doesn't quite play the role teased on the cover. At least not yet.

Being the first issue for Soule, we'll have to wait and see where exactly he takes Swamp Thing. There are some questionable moments but that could be in part of Alec's full acceptance into his role.

The Verdict

Change can be a scary thing. This is especially true when it comes to creative changes in comics. What better villain to have Swamp Thing go up against that Scarecrow? Charles Soule takes Swamp Thing on a different route than we've seen in the previous issues. With the Rotworld story finally over, we can see Alec Holland embrace his role as the avatar of the Green and explore the rest of the world, performing the duties the Green needs him to perform. We're off to an interesting beginning but it almost feels a little too sudden to have both Scarecrow and Superman, two non-Swamp Thing characters, show up right away. Soule is setting up things nicely and you can't help but be curious to see where he's going to take the character. Change can be scary but things are looking pretty good.

Staff Online
#1 Edited by broo1232 (1664 posts) - - Show Bio

Looking forward to this.

#3 Posted by soumya (156 posts) - - Show Bio

I think it's too early to judge Soule.It's may be a three issue arc he is working on.In the first issue,he certainly showed a new direction though.I hope big events will be coming soon.

#4 Posted by Ghidoran (74 posts) - - Show Bio

Really? I thought this was quite good, and a breath of fresh air after the overlong Rotworld.

#5 Posted by Batnandez (522 posts) - - Show Bio

@ghidoran: tony loves him some Snyder though

#6 Posted by Booster_Bronze (204 posts) - - Show Bio

I liked the issue as well. Explained alot about the Green and him going to Metropolis made sense from the way it was explained.

#7 Posted by MadeinBangladesh (10151 posts) - - Show Bio

cant wait what the new writer got in store for Alec!

I don't trust G-man's reviews.haha

#8 Posted by Brownghost (47 posts) - - Show Bio

@ghidoran:Really good start, cant wait for more.

#9 Posted by BiteMe-Fanboy (8658 posts) - - Show Bio

It was a real great comic. I was a bit nervous at first, but it looks like Swampy is going to continue being a good comic.

Too sudden to come to Metropolis? Wut?

#10 Posted by Cap10nate (3228 posts) - - Show Bio

Big fan of this issue. I liked the narration and the internal conflict Swampy has in this issue. It's really interesting reading this in conjunction with Animal Man where Buddy is repulsing the Red while ST is embracing the Green. Definitely hope the arcs are shorter after Rotworld took forever.

#11 Posted by -The Renegade- (149 posts) - - Show Bio

Maybe this series will suffer from the fact that Soule has to start his run from where Snyder left off. He might not be comfortable with that direction. Starting a fresh start, with his own ideas, could have been better for him. Obviously, he can't do that, because that wouldn't do justice to Snyder's run.

#12 Posted by The Stegman (29152 posts) - - Show Bio

I actually liked this issue a lot, I love Snyder..but Rotworld lasted way too long.

#13 Posted by arnoldoaad (1038 posts) - - Show Bio

I actually thought this issue was pretty good, it is obviously written as an introduction to Swamp Thing hence we get a lot of dialog of ST explaining stuff that a regular reader already knows but it wasnt boring and at the same time it was pretty insightfull this was a pretty good start

#14 Edited by longbowhunter (8524 posts) - - Show Bio

I was very hesitant about this. But found it surprisingly great. Kano does a bang up job. Hope he stays around for a while. I was afraid the story would feel really out of place with Supes and Scarecrow involved but it didn't at all. I agree with Tony, the JLA reference from Crane was cool and only helped pull this title into the bigger DCU picture. Also we get what I assume will be a ongoing mystery in upcoming issues of Swamp Thing with this Seeder character. Very excited for next issue.

#15 Posted by DonFelipe (1691 posts) - - Show Bio

Seems like everyone here likes this issue more than G-Man (3 stars only). Though I don't really appreciate the idea of Swamp Thing going to Metropolis and leaving theseparate corner of the DCU, I'm still curious to see where this title goes now that Soule is the new writer and will pick it up this weekend.

#16 Edited by Nefilim927 (449 posts) - - Show Bio

Really liked this issue, thought Soule had a nice voice for Swamp Thing and gave a god setup for Superman's appearance. Also like how the Greens influence over him is displayed.

#17 Posted by Bogey (1022 posts) - - Show Bio

This was a really good issue, especially if someone wanted to start to get into Swamp Thing. L

#18 Edited by Greggh (19 posts) - - Show Bio

This may be obvious but to me it sounded like a typo... Hopefully someone can clear it up for me but when crane knocked out swamp thing he mentioned how he should have known to use that potion first because it was almost 60 % CO2.... plants breath CO2.... shouldn't he have said oxygen ?

#19 Edited by StretchPants (20 posts) - - Show Bio

"He looks like a male model. I look like a salad." had me laughing.

@Greggh: It makes sense because of the reason you listed it didn't make sense :-). They would absorb more of it.

#20 Edited by jwalser3 (6104 posts) - - Show Bio

@ghidoran said:

Really? I thought this was quite good, and a breath of fresh air after the overlong Rotworld.

Same here I loved this issue. I loved seeing Swamp Thing as a desert plant for the first couple of pages.

#21 Edited by TDK_88 (27 posts) - - Show Bio

@batnandez said:

@ghidoran: tony loves him some Snyder though

Quoted for truth. Its a shame a reviewer can't review things on its own merits.

@biteme_fanboy said:

It was a real great comic. I was a bit nervous at first, but it looks like Swampy is going to continue being a good comic.

Too sudden to come to Metropolis? Wut?

I know right, Too sudden is redundant its been friggin 19 issues of Swamps on his own, how on earth it is "Too soon" is beyond me. But oh well thats @g_man for you.

I think it's saying something about the review when the majority of the commenters do not agree with the review and ACTUALLY have some good points to back it up instead of the usual internet trolling stuff.

#22 Posted by ILLO_29 (159 posts) - - Show Bio

This was a great issue. I do enjoy me some Scott Snyder but I found Rotworld to be very bloated and long, however the ending made up for it. This was a nice change of pace (I do feel it was a little rushed with throwing in both Scarecrow and Superman but I think Solue is just trying to keep momentum up after Rotworld) Swampy's internal monologue was fun and interesting to read and the art was very well done. Cactus skinned swampy was a great image.

#23 Edited by Cap10nate (3228 posts) - - Show Bio

The only thing I missed from the previous creative team in this issue was the panel borders. I loved the use of natural things like vines and flowers as the break between panels. I thought those looked fantastic. The art was still great in this issue, but the clean breaks between panels was a slight downgrade from the prior team. It's not even a complaint, just a preference.

I'm glad there wasn't a three issue journey of him on his way to Metropolis.

#24 Posted by HombreMan (101 posts) - - Show Bio

This new arc is looking good, despite the gore and horror levels are low for a Swamp Thing comic, the angle Soules is giving him, being a part of the whole DC Universe, is fresh and new, let's remember that his old enemy Floronic Man (I prefer his original name Plant Master or just his surname, Woodrue ) used to be an old Atom villain. Also, knowing that The Scarecrow has several strands of fear toxin for any characters is quite clever. The other aspect I love is that Swampy got rid of his "battle armor" and is now using his green teleportation again. I give this issue 4 stars out of 5.

#25 Edited by Jake Fury (21339 posts) - - Show Bio

This was a great first issue for Soule. I WANT characters like Swamp Thing and Animal Man to interact with the rest of the DC Universe. Great art as well and I am SUPREMELY glad Rotworld is over.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.