circularlogic's Swamp Thing #10 - Arcane's Lullaby review

Return to their Roots

For the new arc of Swamp Thing, Scott Snyder begins with an homage to the classic Alan Moore run, both in it's art and it's writing. The results are in my opinion spectacular, though I'd be lying if I said there wasn't a few hiccups.

It's difficult to talk the story without mentioning the art, and vice versa, since both are so intertwined that if one went without the other, this issue would just fail horribly. Francesco Francavilla really plays to Snyder's strength in crafting a very uncomfortable sort of tale, drawing often disturbing scenes of Anton Arcane giving a villain monologue that feels far more terrifying than it does Bond villain-y, which helps show what kind of twisted creature he really is. These scenes are contrasted nicely with a flashback and some quieter moments with Abigail and Alec returning to their home in the swamps, which works well, though I'd be lying if I said that sometimes the art felt a bit TOO stylistically different from other parts of the same issue at certain points. Some very subtle cues drawn throughout the book, really make this issue a treat to read, and serve as a brilliant example in visual storytelling. Snyder knows when to let the art speak for itself, taking his time to build tension and atmosphere, but also was able to use the dialogue for great effect. Of course, a line or two (such as Swamp Thing's "you should see the other guy" bit) fell flat, and sometimes a panel wasn't as neatly drawn as I would have liked it, but for the most part, the issue still accomplished what it set out to do. The pages where Alec submerged himself in the swamp was a real stand out, and as I said served as a very loving tribute to the original stories told by Len Wein and Alan Moore in the past.

While Francavilla is no Yanick Paquette, this book still has it's own unique feel, compared to past issues, and the classic feeling fits with the idea of Swamp Thing and Abigail returning to their... roots (HYUK HYUK HYUK!). Snyder knows how to revamp old franchises, introducing little twists to old stories that keep to the source material while expanding on it in a way that introduces tons of new possibilities, and the new storyline he has set up is still keeping me as interested as I was back when this book first came out.


Other reviews for Swamp Thing #10 - Arcane's Lullaby

    Anton Arcane here to creep you out! 0

    Now I know I said I started in issue 12 but I saw these in my comic shop and decided what the hell Swamp-thing is one of my favourite DC characters and Anton Arcane is one of the best villains around so I bought issues 10 and 11 (11 I should have a review up tomorrowThe GoodThis issue is really dark Swamp-thing is generally very dark but this is never happy there is not a single shred of happiness in this book it's just Dark. This issue continues from the last with Swamp-thing very badly injured...

    4 out of 4 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.