The list can go on and on but truthfully they all stem from a handful of major reasons...
1.) For a show that's supposed to appeal primarily to comic book fans, it has far too much drama and not nearly enough action! Between the self-doubt of all our favorite heroes and the high school love triangles that never existed in any adaption of the characters, the show is just anther soap opera, this time using the names of familiar characters to draw in a broader crowd.
2.) What the show lacks in canonicity, it makes up for with pure, unadulterated originality...wait...nevermind. The show thrives on its far superior DC media predecessors, such as the legendary Nolanverse. They say they were trying to give allusions to the long-expected Dark Knight to be in the series, but truthfully they saw the success of Nolan's vision an decided they couldn't write anything better so instead they just stole his scenes and gave them slight twists and different character names. Along with borderline plagirism the show also suffered from lack of material, whenever the writers had a block (which appeared to be more often than not) they decided to do one of two things, they tended to gorge the show on meaningless fillers (that have nothing to do with DC at all) and close them with an important cliffhanger to make sure that their "fans" walk away saying, "Maybe next week they'll actually get back to the storyline..." to no avail. Either stuff the show like a Thanksgiving turkey, or another fan-favorite...complete suspension of production! Many times I came home to watch the recorded series and found tht it was simply a re-run from some previous season or just the episode from last week (incase some people missed it I guess...).
Now on the upside, the show did introduce a lot of heroes/villains (albeit a very botched and slaughtered variation of the original) that needed some time in the media. Even the long awaited Caped Crusader made an appearance in the Season 11 comic series...which leads me to my next point...
3.) The stubborness of the writers is appauling to say the least, when DC said no o selling them the rights to certain characters, they just molded the same character into their own variation.
- Barry Allen/The Flash who was crudely transformed into the young "impulsive" Bart Allen/???Impulse??? woah woah woah...where'd that come from? Same color scheme, same story, but with the alias of a COMPLETELY different character from the comics!
-Dick Grayson/Nightwing + Barbara Gordon/Batgirl/Oracle =(dramatic pause)......Barbara Gordon/Nightwing! They couldn't get young Master Grayson to make an actual appearance in the show so instead, they mention his city (Bludhaven), mention/display his mentor (Batman [who luckily is still Bruce Wayne]), and then instead of handing the escrima sticks to the Boy Wonder, they are handed over to Barbara Gordon.
-Doomsday turns into Davis Bloome, a dark version of the "Man" of Steel who has a tragic backstory concerning Zod and Faora/Ursa, who falls in....love? Wait? Doomsday loves an earthling?...okay...
Anyway, bringing up Doomsday leads into the next major reason I think we all saw as comic fans.
4.) Everyone knows that Smallville is a show about how Clark became the Red and Blue Boyscout, but can someone please explain why by the time he actually dons the Superman mantle, all of his supervillains are freaking dead or gone in some way shape or form? Lex is the only one still on Earth at the end of the series and the best they could think of was to make him lose his memory. The main list of baddies however has already been taken care of by the aspiring Superman. SO, either this is one heck of a Clark, that he can beat Brainiac, Bizzaro, Zod, Metallo, and even villains from fellow hero rogue galleries, or these villains really suck! They can't beat a farm boy from Kansas who can't even fly! I saved my favorite two villains that had a major downfall to the Boy of Steel, Darkseid (the New God from Apokolips) who doesn't even physically fight "Superman" but rather posesses Lex's father and has a quick ehh 3-5 minute showdown in the Kent farm. The battle against Apokolips is literally, against Apokolips the planet which takes on a somewhat Unicron reminiscent role in the series. And everyone's favorite DOOMSDAY, the monster that "killed" Superman is built up throughout the entire season he's to premiere in and, instead of a Metropolis shattering fight with the beast that should last at least an hour in it of itself, was trimmed to a cute little "I hit you, you hit me, I run you into an elevator to the core and this is over, kay?" and so ends the intergalactic threat that is Doomsday. Looks like Superman really only has to worry about a couple muggers here and there with the occasional Luthor threat, ahh a day in the life...
5.) Last but certainly not least, the cast...Tom Welling, a construction worker with a decent build and the classic Superman jawline is chosen without much thought on the role I guess, and Kristen Kreuk who really can't do anything but look pretty on screen but hey she's only playing Lana Lang who should only appear in like the first few seasons till Clark moves to Metropolis right? :) However these mistakes were made up for with the astonishing performances by Michael Rosenbaum as Lex Luthor, Michael Gough as Lionel Luthor, Justin Hartley as a pretty decent Oliver Queen/Green Arrow, Callum Blue as an interesting Major Zod, and Alan Ritchson who portrayed a picture perfect King of Atlantis AQUAMAN! His performance was so perfect for the role of the least helpful "superhero" ever, I actually completely forgot about his existence in the series! Spot on my friend...spot...on!
These are the core reasons I found most comic fans have with this poorly built TV series, but hey at least Arrow is so far measuring up to be a good show, then again I liked the first few seasons of Smallville too, so we'll see.
Log in to comment