Why do people hate Superman?
That's a tough question to answer since there's a huge number of reasons.
Me? I like Superman. Never been a huge fan, but I've read his comic on a few occasions and I think he's a great character. One of the main problems he has (and this is true of any uber-powerful character) is that stories about him CAN be hard to write. Honestly, folks like Superman, Thor, and Hulk can be the hardest to write for simply because of how powerful they are. Batman doesn't have this problem. Sure, he's kinda overpowered in his own way with his super-planning ability and deus ex machina gadgets; but if you shoot him, he'll still die. If you hit him it still hurts. Batman villains don't have to be particularly powerful because even a normal person has a chance of killing him.
With Superman it's a little harder. The "hero in peril" form of dramatic tension is harder to have since guys who can kill Supes are few and far between. Sure there's kryptonite, but that can cause it's own problem of every villain having a chunk of green rock hidden in their back pocket. So much more imagination has to be used to write exciting stories. Other forms of peril must be explored. Maybe the success/fail rate of Superman stories are too low for some people. And if they don't take the time to root out the really great stories, then it can lead to an overall dislike of the character.
I'll admit, I'm guilty of this myself. I've become something of a Hulk-hater simply because of how much I hated the "World War Hulk" storyline. Though I'll still admit that the Hulk is a good character in and of himself. Some people can't do that though. It's the same people who off-handedly label Cyclops as "bland" and write him off as a character.
Has he been bland?
Sure.
Has Superman been overpowered?
Sure.
But not all the time. Everyone has been written horribly from time to time, including fanboy darlings like Batman. That doesn't mean that the character is bad. Superman is an iconic character and stands for all the best of the DC universe. He's the one other heroes look to for inspiration. The flaws of people like Superman and Captain America aren't the flaws people usually associate with comic book heroes. Cap and Supes are just good guys. Plain and simple.
And that can be another reason people don't like Superman. Today's comic books are much darker and more violent than the comics of the past. The inherent good of people is no longer a given thing, and heroes like Superman and Cap have become more and more outnumbered by people like the Punisher and Wolverine. The "gray area" of morality so often referred to in comics has become the rule more than the exception. This shift in tastes have left some people feeling that Superman and his ideals are out-of-date and dumb.
In a strange way, it's kinda made Superman the rebellious character. Fighting not only against villains, but against society itself to prove that pure heroism is still a relevant and important thing.
Log in to comment