Superman:Doomsay..how accurate is it too the comics?

#1 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio

I don't read Superman..but I am watching Superman:Doomsday right now and I was just wondering..how accurate is it to the Death of Superman comics?

#2 Posted by warlock360 (28063 posts) - - Show Bio

errr kinda the same I'd say

#3 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio

Anyone got scans from the Death of Superman?

#4 Posted by T.J. Magnum (27685 posts) - - Show Bio

yeah what void said

#5 Posted by Vance Astro (91287 posts) - - Show Bio
Queen Kong said:
"Anyone got scans from the Death of Superman?
"
Sadly I can't post scans...
Moderator
#6 Posted by brainiac 1.0 (4150 posts) - - Show Bio

Scans from the movie or comicbook.

#7 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio
brainiac 1.0 said:
"Scans from the movie or comicbook."
Comics.
#8 Posted by zee crusher (8997 posts) - - Show Bio
Queen Kong said:
"I don't read Superman..but I am watching Superman:Doomsday right now and I was just wondering..how accurate is it to the Death of Superman comics?
"

Do you read anything?
#9 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio
zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"I don't read Superman..but I am watching Superman:Doomsday right now and I was just wondering..how accurate is it to the Death of Superman comics?
"

Do you read anything?"
Please leave.
#10 Posted by brainiac 1.0 (4150 posts) - - Show Bio
Queen Kong said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Scans from the movie or comicbook."
Comics.
"

Oh.
#11 Posted by zee crusher (8997 posts) - - Show Bio
Queen Kong said:
"zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"I don't read Superman..but I am watching Superman:Doomsday right now and I was just wondering..how accurate is it to the Death of Superman comics?
"

Do you read anything?"
Please leave.
"
So I guess that means you don't. That was pretty obvious.
#12 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio
zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"I don't read Superman..but I am watching Superman:Doomsday right now and I was just wondering..how accurate is it to the Death of Superman comics?
"

Do you read anything?"
Please leave.
"
So I guess that means you don't. That was pretty obvious.
"
I asked you nicely.I'm don't feel obligated to answer that question because even if I say yes,you'll say I don't.
#13 Posted by warlock360 (28063 posts) - - Show Bio
brainiac 1.0 said:
"Queen Kong said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Scans from the movie or comicbook."
Comics.
"

Oh."
xD dude unless you hold your scanner against the screen i doubt you'd be able to get a "scan" of the movie xDD
#14 Posted by brainiac 1.0 (4150 posts) - - Show Bio
Voidheart said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Queen Kong said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Scans from the movie or comicbook."
Comics.
"

Oh."
xD dude unless you hold your scanner against the screen i doubt you'd be able to get a "scan" of the movie xDD
"
I can get pics from the movie.
#15 Posted by zee crusher (8997 posts) - - Show Bio
Queen Kong said:
"zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"I don't read Superman..but I am watching Superman:Doomsday right now and I was just wondering..how accurate is it to the Death of Superman comics?
"

Do you read anything?"
Please leave.
"
So I guess that means you don't. That was pretty obvious.
"
I asked you nicely.I'm don't feel obligated to answer that question because even if I say yes,you'll say I don't.
"

You wanna ask like and a$$hole towards me in my own thread that makes sense why can't I do it to you??

#16 Posted by T.J. Magnum (27685 posts) - - Show Bio
caption

#17 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio
zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"I don't read Superman..but I am watching Superman:Doomsday right now and I was just wondering..how accurate is it to the Death of Superman comics?
"

Do you read anything?"
Please leave.
"
So I guess that means you don't. That was pretty obvious.
"
I asked you nicely.I'm don't feel obligated to answer that question because even if I say yes,you'll say I don't.
"

You wanna ask like and a$$hole towards me in my own thread that makes sense why can't I do it to you??

"
I don't know what your talking about but your childish attitude is disgusting.
#18 Posted by zee crusher (8997 posts) - - Show Bio
Queen Kong said:
"zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"zee crusher said:
"Queen Kong said:
"I don't read Superman..but I am watching Superman:Doomsday right now and I was just wondering..how accurate is it to the Death of Superman comics?
"

Do you read anything?"
Please leave.
"
So I guess that means you don't. That was pretty obvious.
"
I asked you nicely.I'm don't feel obligated to answer that question because even if I say yes,you'll say I don't.
"

You wanna ask like and a$$hole towards me in my own thread that makes sense why can't I do it to you??

"
I don't know what your talking about but your childish attitude is disgusting.
"
No your disgusting. You should Mandarin vs batman thread. You couldn't think for yourself so you asked why the battle was even made. If you don't know anything about the characters don't ask why I made the thread shut the hell up and don't post.
#19 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio
brainiac 1.0 said:
"Voidheart said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Queen Kong said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Scans from the movie or comicbook."
Comics.
"

Oh."
xD dude unless you hold your scanner against the screen i doubt you'd be able to get a "scan" of the movie xDD
"
I can get pics from the movie.
"
That won't do any good..i'm watching the movie.I want to see the comic so I can see how they match up.
#20 Posted by T.J. Magnum (27685 posts) - - Show Bio
caption
caption

#21 Posted by warlock360 (28063 posts) - - Show Bio
brainiac 1.0 said:
"Voidheart said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Queen Kong said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Scans from the movie or comicbook."
Comics.
"

Oh."
xD dude unless you hold your scanner against the screen i doubt you'd be able to get a "scan" of the movie xDD
"
I can get pics from the movie.
"
ya, but scans are referred to pictures that were run through the scanner

Pictures from the movie are more like Screenshots if thats what you ment.
#22 Posted by brainiac 1.0 (4150 posts) - - Show Bio
Queen Kong said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Voidheart said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Queen Kong said:
"brainiac 1.0 said:
"Scans from the movie or comicbook."
Comics.
"

Oh."
xD dude unless you hold your scanner against the screen i doubt you'd be able to get a "scan" of the movie xDD
"
I can get pics from the movie.
"
That won't do any good..i'm watching the movie.I want to see the comic so I can see how they match up.
"
Oh I have the fight when superman was amped up by the mother box and waverider was helping him. You are watching it on cartoon network 9:00-10:30.

Brainiac 1.0 is watching you.
#23 Posted by Nighthunter (28582 posts) - - Show Bio

The main differences were that in the movie you do not see the justice league appear, neither the rest of the superhero community.


Another one is that we do not see the three "supermen" that appear after the death of Superman 
#24 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio
Nighthunter said:
"The main differences were that in the movie you do not see the justice league appear, neither the rest of the superhero community.

Another one is that we do not see the three "supermen" that appear after the death of Superman 
"
Thank You.
#25 Posted by Methos (40103 posts) - - Show Bio
Queen Kong said:
"I don't read Superman..but I am watching Superman:Doomsday right now and I was just wondering..how accurate is it to the Death of Superman comics?
"

nowhere near accurate

the original comics are a truly epic series with so many far reaching events like the destruction of coast city and the subjugation of Mongul...

none of these happened in Superman: Doomsday

don't get me wrong, i enjoyed it for a simple cartoon, but it's not even a pale shadow of the original comics

M
#26 Posted by warlock360 (28063 posts) - - Show Bio

... tis why it's entitled the death of superman and not DoomsDAY

Death = A moment

Day = a time  period

:D

#27 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio
Methos said:
"Queen Kong said:
"I don't read Superman..but I am watching Superman:Doomsday right now and I was just wondering..how accurate is it to the Death of Superman comics?
"

nowhere near accurate

the original comics are a truly epic series with so many far reaching events like the destruction of coast city and the subjugation of Mongul...

none of these happened in Superman: Doomsday

don't get me wrong, i enjoyed it for a simple cartoon, but it's not even a pale shadow of the original comics

M
"
Really wow.I'm going to have to find these comics.I know some comic shop has them.
#28 Posted by Methos (40103 posts) - - Show Bio
Queen Kong said:
Really wow.I'm going to have to find these comics.I know some comic shop has them.
"

let me put it simply...

in Superman: Doomsday you are missing all of these...

the entire JLA

Booster Gold

Guy Garder using the Sinestro Corps (Quardian) Yellow ring

Bloodwynd using Martian Manhunter as a host

Supergirl being engaged to Lex Luthor

The origins of Steel (John Henry Irons)

The origins of Superboy (Clone)

Eradicator's eventual mental breakdown

The distruction of Coast City (Which led to Hal's mental breakdown, Parallax and Zero Hour before he came back during Final Night and saved the entire planet single handedly)

there's more, tons more, but those are the major bits from the Death of Superman comic that you are missing from the cartoon

M
#29 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio
Methos said:
"Queen Kong said:
Really wow.I'm going to have to find these comics.I know some comic shop has them.
"

let me put it simply...

in Superman: Doomsday you are missing all of these...

the entire JLA

Booster Gold

Guy Garder using the Sinestro Corps (Quardian) Yellow ring

Bloodwynd using Martian Manhunter as a host

Supergirl being engaged to Lex Luthor

The origins of Steel (John Henry Irons)

The origins of Superboy (Clone)

Eradicator's eventual mental breakdown

The distruction of Coast City (Which led to Hal's mental breakdown, Parallax and Zero Hour before he came back during Final Night and saved the entire planet single handedly)

there's more, tons more, but those are the major bits from the Death of Superman comic that you are missing from the cartoon

M
"
WOW....lol.I really have to pick them up now.
#30 Posted by Methos (40103 posts) - - Show Bio

you can get the entire set in TPB form from most places...

they're about 10 to 15 bucks each i think...

well worth getting

M

#31 Posted by Queen Kong (1603 posts) - - Show Bio
Methos said:
"you can get the entire set in TPB form from most places...

they're about 10 to 15 bucks each i think...

well worth getting

M
"
Thanks Methos.
#32 Posted by Methos (40103 posts) - - Show Bio

anytime...

try Amazon.com for US or .co.uk for Uk... or whereever you are

M

#33 Posted by King Saturn (224462 posts) - - Show Bio
Superman : Doomsday film seemed rather accurate to the Comics...

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.