i hate to agree with this, simply because its not the main Superman title, but I have to admit that the writing and direction of Smallville is much better than what is being put out in Action Comics and Superman to me. I would put Superman Beyond as a very close second. the only thing i wish Superman Beyond had done was use Conner instead of Clark. Clark could still be alive and kicking just as he is in the series now, but i would have been interested in seeing the Beyond team use an adult, pre-52 Conner as the Man of Steel and have Clark be a supporting character. we saw an adult Conner multiple times as an evil Superman, it would have been nice to see what could have been done with him as Superman's true successor as we saw in the single issue of Superman/Batman (of course, in that issue Damian was Batman so that future is gone now i guess). then the arcs could have moved between the two.
i realize that's not the popular opinion but as a Superman reader of 26 years the writing and storylines of AC and Superman up to this point have been hugely disappointing. i've been a fan of Morrison in the past, but his Action Comics run was far too much Morrison trying to be clever with the character's history than providing a good story. i think he got too full of himself following a great run with Batman prior to Final Crisis because he did such a good job using Batman's history. unfortunately, lightning doesn't always strike twice on an idea and to me that's the case with what he did on Action Comics. it tried to be ultra-old school and ultra-historical knowledge and failed.
as for the Superman series, i give it sympathy because for some reason DC couldn't give Superman that same level of respect as Batman and decided to change his history far more dramatically. so the writers have been trying to establish the new Superman and unfortunately its left the book feeling a bit underwhelming than it really should be. H'El could have been an awesome villain and story arc but was an immense let-down in execution. also think the idea of the bio-tech suit (which i'll actually okay with aside from wanting the belt to go back to yellow and not look so much like a Batman utility belt) has caused the book to go too far into the science fiction direction. Superman should represent the science fiction aspect of the Trinity, but what we are getting is to much Syfy channel saturday movie science fiction and not Orson Scott Card science fiction.
Smallville, despite continuing from a disappointing tv ending and being a bit slow in the first few issues, has really come on strong and its nice to see a "new" Superman that is actually progressing nicely through the series. when you compare the "new" Superman of Superman to the "new" Superman of Smallville its a little sad that the side series is doing a better job of giving readers a "new" Superman than the main series is. also like the Smallville suit more, overall, than the bio-tech suit because it melds the concept of old and new far better (and much better than reusing the Superman Returns suit like the final episode of the tv series did) than the clunky, unnecessarily lined and shield pattern emblazed version.
it will be interesting to see how Smallville handles the Monitors and its version of Crisis. still wish though that the series would find a way to retcon season 10 and give Darkseid and Apokolips the justice it deserves.
Log in to comment