I heard that the new Zach Snyder Superman movie would be yet another Superman origin story, and I ask why? I know people who've never picked up a comic or watched any superman movies or tv shows that know superman is from krypton and that the planet blew up. What could possibly be left to get out of his origin? wouldn't it be better to just do an original story instead of spending half a movie showing an origin that tops 12 people don't know?
Superman
Character » Superman appears in 18942 issues.
Sent to Earth as an infant from the dying planet Krypton, Kal-El was adopted by the loving Kent family and raised in America's heartland as Clark Kent. Using his immense solar-fueled powers, he became Superman to defend mankind against all manner of threats while championing truth, justice, and the American way!
Is there anyone alive who doesn't know superman's origin?
It's one of those origins you literally tell in less than 2 minutes over the opening credits for the 3 people who are actually watching a Superman movie and have never heard of Superman.
Completely ignoring the OP here and addressing the titular question. Yes, there are many people who don't know Supes origins, millions even. Impoverish third world country citizens, the elderly who lived life in a bubble, the senses impaired(unless it's been converted to braille), the regular joe who doesn't give two craps about comics, etc. The list goes on.
Now to address the OP. Origins have been done to a fault. Take Supes on a new story or something. Couldn't hurt much.
You're not being fair. Everyone knows the outlines of Superman's origin. Baby from a doomed world, raised by a kindly couple, has great power, wants to help people. That is just the basic concept. The foundation on which the actual story comes. So no. No one knows Superman's story, because while the basics are all the same, the actual story changes with every version. Man of Steel, Birthright, Secret Origins and Earth One are all Superman's origin stories, and they couldn't be more apart in plot and characterization. The movie will have its own story, which may be related to the comics mentioned, or it may make its own twists, but it has to be there, because that is what establishes Superman as a character.
Ask yourself this: Isn't the same applicable to Batman? Everyone knows how Batman became Batman, why he does what he does and how he does it. Yet Begins devoted more than half of the movie to showing the journey from the boy in the alley to the Caped Crusader, and manages to throw in its own twists into the tale while being completely true to the material. Superman will do the same.
" You're not being fair. Everyone knows the outlines of Superman's origin. Baby from a doomed world, raised by a kindly couple, has great power, wants to help people. That is just the basic concept. The foundation on which the actual story comes. So no. No one knows Superman's story, because while the basics are all the same, the actual story changes with every version. Man of Steel, Birthright, Secret Origins and Earth One are all Superman's origin stories, and they couldn't be more apart in plot and characterization. The movie will have its own story, which may be related to the comics mentioned, or it may make its own twists, but it has to be there, because that is what establishes Superman as a character.Ask yourself this: Isn't the same applicable to Batman? Everyone knows how Batman became Batman, why he does what he does and how he does it. Yet Begins devoted more than half of the movie to showing the journey from the boy in the alley to the Caped Crusader, and manages to throw in its own twists into the tale while being completely true to the material. Superman will do the same. "
" Completely ignoring the OP here and addressing the titular question. Yes, there are many people who don't know Supes origins, millions even. Impoverish third world country citizens, the elderly who lived life in a bubble, the senses impaired(unless it's been converted to braille), the regular joe who doesn't give two craps about comics, etc. The list goes on.Now to address the OP. Origins have been done to a fault. Take Supes on a new story or something. Couldn't hurt much. "Those people won't be going to see the movie.
Yep they are, I actually made a thread about it." @joshmightbe: I would like to think so. Him, Batman and Spider-Man are definitely the big three as far as comics are concerned. "
" You're not being fair. Everyone knows the outlines of Superman's origin. Baby from a doomed world, raised by a kindly couple, has great power, wants to help people. That is just the basic concept. The foundation on which the actual story comes. So no. No one knows Superman's story, because while the basics are all the same, the actual story changes with every version. Man of Steel, Birthright, Secret Origins and Earth One are all Superman's origin stories, and they couldn't be more apart in plot and characterization. The movie will have its own story, which may be related to the comics mentioned, or it may make its own twists, but it has to be there, because that is what establishes Superman as a character.Ask yourself this: Isn't the same applicable to Batman? Everyone knows how Batman became Batman, why he does what he does and how he does it. Yet Begins devoted more than half of the movie to showing the journey from the boy in the alley to the Caped Crusader, and manages to throw in its own twists into the tale while being completely true to the material. Superman will do the same. "This
" You're not being fair. Everyone knows the outlines of Superman's origin. Baby from a doomed world, raised by a kindly couple, has great power, wants to help people. That is just the basic concept. The foundation on which the actual story comes. So no. No one knows Superman's story, because while the basics are all the same, the actual story changes with every version. Man of Steel, Birthright, Secret Origins and Earth One are all Superman's origin stories, and they couldn't be more apart in plot and characterization. The movie will have its own story, which may be related to the comics mentioned, or it may make its own twists, but it has to be there, because that is what establishes Superman as a character.Ask yourself this: Isn't the same applicable to Batman? Everyone knows how Batman became Batman, why he does what he does and how he does it. Yet Begins devoted more than half of the movie to showing the journey from the boy in the alley to the Caped Crusader, and manages to throw in its own twists into the tale while being completely true to the material. Superman will do the same. "
According to this at about 7:20, 94% of the people in Thailand who own a TV set know who Superman is.
" You're not being fair. Everyone knows the outlines of Superman's origin. Baby from a doomed world, raised by a kindly couple, has great power, wants to help people. That is just the basic concept. The foundation on which the actual story comes. So no. No one knows Superman's story, because while the basics are all the same, the actual story changes with every version. Man of Steel, Birthright, Secret Origins and Earth One are all Superman's origin stories, and they couldn't be more apart in plot and characterization. The movie will have its own story, which may be related to the comics mentioned, or it may make its own twists, but it has to be there, because that is what establishes Superman as a character.Ask yourself this: Isn't the same applicable to Batman? Everyone knows how Batman became Batman, why he does what he does and how he does it. Yet Begins devoted more than half of the movie to showing the journey from the boy in the alley to the Caped Crusader, and manages to throw in its own twists into the tale while being completely true to the material. Superman will do the same. "This.
Also, Superman's origin story is far more entertaining that most heroes. The first time he appears, no matter which iteration of the origin, is always the best part of the book.
I thought they couldn't do an Origin story anyway because of that ridiculous court ruling regarding the Siegels?
" @extremeradical: I can use the wolverine solo movie as evidence against that "That was a prequel. Wolverine was already introduced (in fact already overused) by the time that film was released.
What made the first film so endearing was his origin and life in Smallville. I'd like to see them devote a few moments to that at least.
Please Log In to post.
This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:
Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.Comment and Save
Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.
Log in to comment