@JonSmith said:
@RideASpaceCowboy said:
Yeah, the Quantum powers also brings the whole versatility, but it brings with it such cold detachment and loss of humanity that it really isn't preferable. What's the point of suddenly having superpowers if you're so far removed from what life that you can't enjoy them?
Your question seems to presuppose that pleasure is a higher value than truth, understanding, and enlightenment. I may be in the minority, but I'm more intellectually curious than hedonistic.
I'm afraid you misunderstand. I'm not saying that intellectual understanding is secondary to personal satisfactory use of ones powers of choice, I'm saying that Manhattan's powers would prevent you from enjoying them at all. Even your version of enjoyment, the apparent expansion of knowledge/understanding, etc, is null and void with Manhattan's abilities. You'd know more yes, but you'd have no more desire to know more. You'd gain no satisfaction from this knowledge, and any curiosity you may possess to learn even more than that would be gone.
So there's no point to gaining those greater powers if more knowledge is your goal, because any desire to learn more would eventually vanish once you gained those powers.
Hence why Martian and Kryptonian abilities are considered more satisfactory.
"Thermodynamic miracles... events with odds against so astronomical they're effectively impossible, like oxygen spontaneously becoming gold. I long to observe such a thing." -Dr. Manhattan
As evidenced from the quote above, Dr. Manhattan does retain his intellectual curiosity and desire for expanded knowledge, even with his changed perspective.
I do agree with you though that Martian powers would be more desirable still.
Log in to comment