@theincrediblesuperhulk8642 said:
@squalleon: I enjoyed DOS but Funeral for a Freind was the shining point of that Trilogy. I respectfully disagree if he was so unsuccessful they wouldn't habe kept him on the book so long and leave him coming back time and time again.
Millar is great as is Busiek, Rucka, Simonson (Louis not Walter) and Pak and I would place them as honerable mentions.
FfaF was a collaborative effort with Stern and Ordway that's why it is better.
Allow me to disagree. He stayed in the 90s because he was an okay writer for his time and because DC had a no A-list writers on popular characters policy until the mid-00s (its true, I am not kidding). The reason he constantly returns to Superman is firstly because he is a loyal DC writer, meaning he will do any fill in job DC wants him too. And more importantly because he is known as the writer who killed Superman. And that's how DC markets him, always and in everything he does Superman related or not (look at Didio's video about Convergence for the most recent of examples). He is a sure pick up, because his name is a synonimous with one of DC's biggest sellers despite its quality. Its like bringing Miller back for a Batman book(the only difference being the quality of the original book that generated the hype, but Jurgens has an historical advantage over Miller because...he is the guy who killed Superman!), despite its quality it will sell, why? Because it is Miller and Batman. TDKSB was awful yet sold like hot-cakes.
The first half of Busiek's run, Up Up and Away, Back in Action, Camelot Falls was magnificent. The rest was so bad. I remember some issues from the Queen Bee story line...*dread*. Pak is overhyped. Sorry but its true. Its too early to tell because his run is still going and people have it fresh in their minds. But Pak's run has many faults imo, from dropped plots, plot-holes,returning elements that don't work for a character like Superman and cliches. And it still hasn't generated anything mind-blowing for me. Recent example issue 40 of AC, I wonder how an issue like that, so sloppy could get so high ratings. The best arc is still the first. Horrorville was filler and the Doomed issues were forgettable.
Log in to comment