Superman Forum

Superman is a comic book character that first appeared in Action Comics #1

Brandon Routh Is No Longer Superman

Topic started by G-Man on July 3, 2009. Last post by kore 4 weeks ago.
Post by xxCellPhoneGirlxx (5,883 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
I would rather have Tom Welling!!

but they are already making a Metropolis movie :]


Post by Gambler (66,172 posts) See mini bio

Loading...

Moderator

@Incredible Hulk-Prime said:
" Hate Brandon Routh as Superman.  I hope who ever is Superman will do better than what Brandon did. "
Couldn't agree more. This is great news in my opinion. Someone throw some serious cash at Tom Welling already and lets get on with it.


Post by danhimself (7,254 posts) See mini bio

Loading...

Online Now

Brandon Routh's best role was when he played the gay pornstar's boyfriend in Zack and Miri make a Porno


Post by Retnex (198 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
I kinda enjoyed the movie. Then again, I dont complain much about movies.


Post by RedK (513 posts) See mini bio

Loading...

Online Now

only thing i didn't like was the kid but i was watching it on t.v yesterday and thought what if lex had some of supes DNA left over after the nuclear man and combined it with his but he implanted into lois and though that it failed thats why he asked whos the kids dad and then we can have superboy


Post by #1ElderScrollsFan (1,495 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Reboot maybe try to find a different actor but the only if the next person is better not a downgrade.


Post by SuperXAsh (64 posts) See mini bio

Loading...

How Warner Bros has been handling Superman for the last decade or so has made me very mad. Sure Bryan Singer's movie wasn't the best, but compared to what the WB had in mind for Supes before he came in were infinitely WORSE. Routh did a pretty good job as Superman, and it's a shame that he may not get the chance to shine as the Man of Steel.



Post by goldenkey (755 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
If they don't mind doing going the older route I'd still like to see Jim Cavizel do Superman.


Post by Emperor Gonzo Noir (3,923 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Re-Reboot time, again


Post by copymanrules (23 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
the movie was to me was like an ending of the story that connected superman movie and superman 2 then this return movie.  I think they should do a reboot of the series but do the John Byrne story i think this would look cool.


Post by SUNMAN (4,810 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
no big shocker here. I feel Routh was chosen partially because he slightly resembled Christopher Reeve, besides that he was just a tall model. His acting could of been stronger. No way he would of held his own with the likes of Bale.

But he was also unlucky that the script was not amazing. It wasn't awful but it wasn't great either


Post by J-PRIME (32 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Routh was a great choice for supeman. It actually worked in his favor being hired as an unknown. I would see him again.


Post by xxCellPhoneGirlxx (5,883 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Routh was a really hot superman.


Post by goosehorn (729 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
i hope tom welling gets the job of being the next superman


Post by geraldthesloth (21,943 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
No more Lex Luthor PLEASE.


Post by Methos (41,324 posts) See mini bio

Loading...

Moderator

@G-Man said:
" Brandon Routh Is No Longer Superman "

Well thank god for that...

M


Post by Gambler (66,172 posts) See mini bio

Loading...

Moderator

@Methos said:
" @G-Man said:
" Brandon Routh Is No Longer Superman "
Well thank god for that...M "
hahaha


Post by Chaos Agent (2,160 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Now the question is....who can or should be the man of steel


Post by Emerald Warrior (55 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
THANK GOD! Routh is the WORST superman ever! The only thing he did was imitate what Reeve did in his films and added nothing to the character!!!

SUPERMAN NEEDS A REBOOT! PLAIN AND SIMPLE! and that includes who plays him!

Oh and for the record...SUPERMAN RETURNS SUCKS!


Post by Emerald Warrior (55 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Incredible Hulk-Prime said:
" Hate Brandon Routh as Superman.  I hope who ever is Superman will do better than what Brandon did. "
AMEN BROTHER, AMEN!


Post by Sidney (1,290 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Who should be the next Superman I know drum roll........................



Post by Media_Master (1,714 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
I have a feeling that if they do a reboot then it will be more action-packed like the Incredible Hulk movie.


Post by Sidney (1,290 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Emerald Warrior said:
"@Incredible Hulk-Prime said:
" Hate Brandon Routh as Superman.  I hope who ever is Superman will do better than what Brandon did. "
AMEN BROTHER, AMEN!"

Yeah babay boy!


Post by whirlwind6 (143 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
My cousin hated that movie so much that he left in the middle.  His favorite move is Super Babies 2.  That really says something about how awful that movie was.


Post by Shatterstar (1,989 posts) See mini bio

Loading...

Moderator

I don't think it was his fault the movie fell flat, it had more to do with the story, the pacing, and little things like Lois having his kid etc. When I think back on the movie, its pretty forgettable, the thing that sticks out in my mind the most is the Pomeranian eating the other Pomeranian. Put a big name in that movie and it'd have been the same.




Post by The Messanger (51 posts) See mini bio

Loading...

I'ts so weird how weak they made this movie cuz come on it's superman. Sure he's got to be dorky as clark kent, but the whole movie was weak sauce nothing  was in it that grabed my attention. The only parts I liked was when Jor-el would be talking in Superman's head. Routh did a pretty good job, but Kevin Spacey as Lex Luthor UUHUH! bad choice.



Post by NightFang (3,237 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Now they can get someone who look like Superman.


Post by Vanndytron (1 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
The problem with this movie is that it SHOULD have been a reboot. The decision to continue from the last film ruined it. No one remembered the last film (was it superman 4?), and the newer audience was turned off by an aged, poorly scripted sequel to a movie they've never seen. Routh was what WB wanted, a young inexpensive actor with possible potential. Not perfect, but last time I checked Christopher Reeves was unavailable. Kevin Spacey was a great Lex Luthor, I'll give you that. It just sucks that Lex was comic relief in the previous films and this one was no different (at least they toned it down some). For all of the people saying Lex shouldn't be in the next Superman film, you'll be disappointed. Lex is the ying to Superman's yang (Lex also practically owns Metropolis). A superpowered villian to rival superman in there would help out alot though, maybe Parasite or Brainiac. DC should make a reboot if they want to keep up with marvel and ride the wave of blockbuster superhero movies, but if they do.... put the movies into the hands of people that will stay faithful to the way the characters were and most importantly, who they are today.


Post by King Saturn (72,909 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Lets worry about the Green Lantern and Wonder Woman films before we get back around to Superman...


Post by skaarason (69 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
i actually really like him as superman !!!!

also i think tom welling could actually work   to !!!!





The Man of Yesteryear
1,627 points

Lady L
1,210 points

zero edge
1,037 points

Supreme Marvel
1,003 points

Riezner
891 points


You are in Edit Mode. Make sure to save your work at the end!!
  • Submissions can take 24 hours to be moderated.
  • Please leave a comment to explain why you're making this change.
Save Changes Cancel