lvenger's Superman Unchained #4 - Bullets review

  • Score:
  • lvenger wrote this review on .
  • 7 out of 7 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
  • lvenger has written a total of 49 reviews. The last one was for Out of Time
  • This review received 8 comments

A Soaring Success

After a bitterly disappointing last issue, I was still nonetheless waiting to see how the next issue of Superman Unchained would play out the plot points and story developed over the series. The two month delay from Villain’s Month and Jim Lee having a baby pushed this new issue back a week from its original scheduled arrival. Hopefully, the long wait for issue 4 lives up to the hype and potential Snyder and Lee have been crafting

SPOILERS WILL BE DISCUSSED FROM THIS POINT.

In short, was I impressed? Answer: I was absolutely blown away by the quality Snyder and Lee both brought to the table for this issue. The errors with the last instalment are practically non existent this time around and we get an incredibly well balanced story that gives each character and plot thread introduced some well deserved development. Take Lex Luthor’s depraved plans for Jimmy Olsen for example. These scenes receive some impressive introspection on Lex’s part via the use of the art of paper folding in the first two pages of the book and later on too. Not only is paper folding used to give an inspection over Lex’s outlook in the story, it also signals a transition in the pacing and direction of the story too. Just as paper dolls were passed between friends to carry over into death, so too does this issue transition into the stride of the story that Snyder has promised Unchained would be. And Lex exudes sinister malevolence and an unpredictability to what he’s thinking and how his involvement in this story will tie into the bigger picture. This is exemplified by his use of paper dolls to predict the deaths of Batman and Wonder Woman which also works out well in those character’s overall mythologies. Unlike Johns who drops certain knowledge in the story for the sake of sounding smart, Snyder ties that knowledge into the overall narrative and theme of the story. It makes for a very pleasant change in how one reads into the story. Even though he didn’t get much development in this issue, I am intrigued with what Jimmy’s role will be now that Lex has him pinned as the helpless harbringer of Superman’s doom which he probably won’t see coming. The respect given to Lex as an integral part of the Superman cast is much appreciated by me.

This respect is carried over into Lois’ part in the overall storyline. I was miffed (that’s a British expression for annoyed btw) that Lois’ gutsy and resourceful response to the plane crash in the last issue was nullified by the plot convenience crystal from the Ascension defector. But this is played out in a wonderful fashion by placing Lois slap bang in the centre of unravelling the core mysteries of this storyline. I loved how Snyder executed this move as it isn’t just someone going to Lois because she knows Superman. There’s a personal stake in there too which I’ll go into later but the main reason why this works so well is because it plays to Lois’ strengths as a character. Her determination, passion for the truth mixed in with empathy and concern come to the fore amazingly well with her other shining characteristics and it’s a great reminder of why Lois is such an iconic character alongside Superman. Snyder is giving her the spotlight in solving the mystery behind Ascension and Wraith with this new crystal because of who Lois is, an investigative journalist who’s more than principled and resolute enough to follow the facts of the story through to its very conclusion. Even if it puts her in dire peril and at the villain’s mercy. I’m really ecstatic over how Snyder will have Lois decode the secret hidden in this storyline because of the importance Lois has in the story and her strong characterisation under Snyder’s pen.

Of course, the main bulk of the story is on Superman and Wraith’s fight with the Russian drones in Tokyo since this is principally a Superman book after all, not a Lois Lane or Lex Luthor one. Lex and Jimmy’s scenes give the issue the shocking and thematic moments, Lois’ part plays on the unknown information concealed about Ascension and most likely Wraith. Superman and Wraith’s scene is the action packed fight sequence of the title and that’s all just fine by me. We get a brilliantly written fight scene in this issue coupled with strong characterisation that’s carried through the issue too. Superman’s portrayal was the weakest aspect of the last issue as Snyder reverted two good issues of strong characterisation into the angry, abrasive New 52 Superman we’ve had the misfortune to see in the Superman Family titles. But this is rectified in the latest issue because Superman is back to how Snyder first wrote him. He cares about the destruction the clash with the drones is causing and on using methods which don’t cause any harm to innocent people. He intelligently assesses the combat scenario and comes up with intelligent applications of his powers and the environment. And in one particular scene that I love, after Wraith makes a grim remark about how he’ll have to put Superman down if he steps out of line, Clark remarks “There’s no need to be so grim about it. I’m not quite cynical enough to see things your way.” That is exactly the character I want to see in Superman. Someone who, whilst realistic is always about looking for the best in others and in making himself better as a result.

But onto the action scene. It’s intelligently portrayed by Snyder and Lee for numerous reasons. The stakes are meaningful with the Russian Drones utilising red solar radiation bullets and missiles, making every hit against Superman and Wraith seem tense. The odds stacked against these two powerhouses force them to be resourceful in their attacks and this is something lacking from a lot of comic book battles today. Straight up brawls and epic hits can be really awesome but ingenuity in how the fights are constructed can go a long way too. By forcing Superman and Wraith to tactically use their powers like armoured doors as shields, sonic attacks and a glorious rapid fire heat vision panel, this shakes things up very well. And Wraith is growing on me I must say. He’s evidently more experienced than Superman and even tutors him on how to use his powers and what he may eventually become over time. Yet Snyder keeps an air of enigma about him. It’s still unclear who he really is, where he came from and what his ultimate agenda is. This keeps Wraith from wholly being an ally to Superman and underscores their team up with a foreshadowing of what conflict is to come.

I admit that Lee hasn’t always been at his best in this series but for me, that changed with this issue. Jim reminds the reader why he’s one of the best and most marketable artists in the business even with the delays. His painstaking attention to detail is a master craft in itself making every panel something to keep their eyes on at all times to spot certain things. From the shards of debris left over from the action packed clash to the brushstrokes emphasising Lex’s facial expressions and posture, Lee renders every page exquisitely. The dynamic pencils of the action sequence such as the glorious rapid fire heat vision panel where each burst is evident to see are balanced effectively with close up shots of Lois talking to the Ascension defector where you can see the water drops dripping down Lois’ face giving a vivid interpretation of the scene. This is contrasted excellently with Williams’ bold and bright inking which makes the colours for the comic appear even more beautiful on panel.

As for the backup, it wasn’t anything too special once again. Lois was written well but the backup traded more on the anonymity of Ascension agents along with the shock reveal that General Lane seems to have played a role in Ascension’s origin. Nguyen’s art suits the tone Snyder’s going for.

Overall, I have given the first two issues of the series 5s when they’re more deserving of 4.5 or even 4s. And the second issue should have been given a 3 in hindsight. However, I have no qualms with giving this issue a 5 as for me, that’s what it deserves because it’s my favourite issue of the series to date and one of my favourite New 52 Superman issues. Snyder hits his stride in this issue of his arc with strong characterisation, a well paced plot, balanced introspections on each story thread and an inventive action sequence rendered in exquisite artwork by Lee. This series really makes me pleased to be a Superman fan as it’s a new tale that is played out in an interesting fashion and is always respectful of the legacy Snyder and Lee are adding to.

Final Scores:

  • · Story: 10/10
  • · Art: 10/10
  • · Overall: 10/10
8 Comments
Edited by AllStarSuperman

I wouldnt quite give it a perfect score.

Didn't you hate the presentation of anti-superman weapons? The fact that everyone and their grandma has bb guns with red sun/black hole bullets is driving me insane. Also the fact that the red sun bullets got through the "indestructible" armour makes no sense. I can see it blooding his face and fingers but whats the purpose of armour? to stop bullets!

Arts okay, but the colors are what makes it beautiful IMO.

Edited by Lvenger

I wouldnt quite give it a perfect score.

Didn't you hate the presentation of anti-superman weapons? The fact that everyone and their grandma has bb guns with red sun/black hole bullets is driving me insane. Also the fact that the red sun bullets got through the "indestructible" armour makes no sense. I can see it blooding his face and fingers but whats the purpose of armour? to stop bullets!

Arts okay, but the colors are what makes it beautiful IMO.

You're picking petty, meaningless and pointless holes in it I'm afraid. To repost what I said on another thread

"The whole amping Earth's military government criticism doesn't make sense because it's clear comic book universes have more advanced technology at their disposal than we do. We have Bruce Wayne and Lex Luthor making anti Superman weapons and yet when the government, who are richer than those two and have access to greater resources make anti Superman weapons, there's complaints about it? It wasn't as if they were firing normal weapons at him. They were red solar radiation emitting weapons along with sonic weapons to hurt Superman or throw him off balance. These are things Superman is weak against. You can't deny that the governments of the world wouldn't make counter measures to deal with Superman and there's nothing wrong with plausible explanations for them."

It's a usual plot point for heroes to face the government weapons against them. No one complains about the Hulkbusters giving Hulk trouble yet here you think Superman having trouble with red sun Russian Drones is bad? A bit petty in all honesty. It's not as if Superman is being cut by titanium like in Azzarello's run. These are weapons that can genuinely hurt and kill him. It's a weak basis to dislike an issue on. Story and writing>>>>>>power levels of a character anyway. Your analysis is fatally flawed as you can see.

Posted by AllStarSuperman

@lvenger: well you dont have to be rude. But Indestructible armour should stop the bullets. In the Last Action comics issue Lobdell even says the armour helps hold in yellow sun light. even if your hate lobdells run, you thinkthey'd try for better consistancy.

Posted by Lvenger

@lvenger: well you dont have to be rude. But Indestructible armour should stop the bullets. In the Last Action comics issue Lobdell even says the armour helps hold in yellow sun light. even if your hate lobdells run, you thinkthey'd try for better consistancy.

As if I'd trust Lobdell for consistency. That man can't be trusted to be reliable if his life depended on it. The suit hasn't shown to hold in yellow sunlight either so I fail to see how you're criticising Snyder for Superman's armour being pierced by red sun weaponry and not Lobdell for mistaking the suit's capabilities.

Edited by SOG7dc

@lvenger said:

@allstarsuperman said:

I wouldnt quite give it a perfect score.

Didn't you hate the presentation of anti-superman weapons? The fact that everyone and their grandma has bb guns with red sun/black hole bullets is driving me insane. Also the fact that the red sun bullets got through the "indestructible" armour makes no sense. I can see it blooding his face and fingers but whats the purpose of armour? to stop bullets!

Arts okay, but the colors are what makes it beautiful IMO.

You're picking petty, meaningless and pointless holes in it I'm afraid. To repost what I said on another thread

"The whole amping Earth's military government criticism doesn't make sense because it's clear comic book universes have more advanced technology at their disposal than we do. We have Bruce Wayne and Lex Luthor making anti Superman weapons and yet when the government, who are richer than those two and have access to greater resources make anti Superman weapons, there's complaints about it? It wasn't as if they were firing normal weapons at him. They were red solar radiation emitting weapons along with sonic weapons to hurt Superman or throw him off balance. These are things Superman is weak against. You can't deny that the governments of the world wouldn't make counter measures to deal with Superman and there's nothing wrong with plausible explanations for them."

It's a usual plot point for heroes to face the government weapons against them. No one complains about the Hulkbusters giving Hulk trouble yet here you think Superman having trouble with red sun Russian Drones is bad? A bit petty in all honesty. It's not as if Superman is being cut by titanium like in Azzarello's run. These are weapons that can genuinely hurt and kill him. It's a weak basis to dislike an issue on. Story and writing>>>>>>power levels of a character anyway. Your analysis is fatally flawed as you can see.

i think this is the problem with giving superman ny armor in the first place. id rather it have just been a kryptonian garb from his father or something

Posted by AllStarSuperman

@lvenger said:

@allstarsuperman said:

@lvenger: well you dont have to be rude. But Indestructible armour should stop the bullets. In the Last Action comics issue Lobdell even says the armour helps hold in yellow sun light. even if your hate lobdells run, you thinkthey'd try for better consistancy.

As if I'd trust Lobdell for consistency. That man can't be trusted to be reliable if his life depended on it. The suit hasn't shown to hold in yellow sunlight either so I fail to see how you're criticising Snyder for Superman's armour being pierced by red sun weaponry and not Lobdell for mistaking the suit's capabilities.

In Action Comics annual the start of "Return to Krypton" they go to krypton under a red sun, and Superman says he must not use his powers but he is also thankful the the suit will contain his powers longer. Not saying he is right, but editor/writer wise Synder shouldn't be contradicting Lobdell. On the other hand though, who cares about continuity, just enjoy the storys.

@sog7dc Same, I wish it was just formal wear that Lara put in the ship with Kal-El.

Edited by Lvenger

@allstarsuperman: Agreed, arguing over semantics gets us nowhere in this case.

Posted by Lvenger

For the record, when I gave this issue a full score, I don't mean that it's a perfect, faultless masterpiece like All Star Superman. I mean it in a similar way to how the staff write the official Comicvine reviews. 5 stars equals a really good book where the positives massively outweigh the negative connotations of the issue.

Other reviews for Superman Unchained #4 - Bullets

    Superman is probably gonna die, Lois is in trouble, and Wraith wants an apprentice. 0

    Lex Luthor says Superman is going to die sooner than we think, is that true? Only Scott Snyder and Jim Lee know! Join this Unchained creative team on another adventure with the Man of Steel! The GoodJim Lee art. YES.This was a good story! Superman is bleeding, Lois is in trouble, Jimmy is being held captive by Lex, and the usual super crazy destructive environment that Superman fights in! If you've missed out on prior issues, you'll like this one. Writer Scott Snyder did a good job with this is...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

    Superman Unchained #4 Rating 0

    Cover & Solicit - 3/5Would I pick-up or buy the comic based on the solicit or cover alone?Are the alternate covers appealing?Does the solicit and cover portray what happens in the issue?Do I like the artist's style on the cover?Art, Colors & Inking - 4/5- Weighted DoubleDo I personally like this artist's style?Does the artist stay true to the characters appearance?If there are multiple artists do they blend well and not disturb the reading experience?Does the coloring/inking blend well w...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.