ectoplasmic's Superman: Secret Origin #1 - The Boy of Steel review

Deja Vu

Remember Superman: Birthright? 
You should read that instead. 
 
The entire time I was reading this issue I kept thinking of Birthright. I thought about Mark Waid's superior writing and Leniel Francis Lu's superior art and just how Waid was able to establish a completely compelling and fresh mythology for Superman.... 
 
And I can't help but feel that this mini series is just completely unnecessary.  
 
I've heard about the Superman lawsuits and I imagine this might be a way for DC to retain their property on some level but regardless you know a character is becoming weak when DC has to re-tell the origin every few years in a fresh way. Superman just isn't interesting anymore.

I'm not sure what the consensus was on John's Green Lantern: Secret Origin storyline... Personally I loved it. I loved seeing the relationship between Hal and Sinestro and it made me really start seeing Sinestro as something more than a typical cereal box comic villain. But that storyline shouldn't give Johns the golden ticket to start writing whatever bullsh*t he wants. He did the same thing after GL:Rebirth when he did the craptacular Flash: Rebirth... It's just not warranted. 
 
In all fairness this issue wasn't bad. 
My problem is set squarely on how pointless this issue is and what an issue like this infers about the title character.
The art is great. I loved Frank's artwork on Supreme Power and I still like it here. Geoff Johns is still an amazing writer and he made this story fun to read.
But this isn't a story that has to be told. It's not a story I care about hearing again. So in the end it was just boring...
Skip it.

0 Comments

Other reviews for Superman: Secret Origin #1 - The Boy of Steel

    Here we go again... 0

    COMICVINE'S TOP 100 SUPERMAN STORIES #22Really, how many times do we need Superman's origin retold? Superman: Secret Origin gives it to us once again with few improvements and and many 'dis-improvements'. To begin with, I'm a fan of the idea that Superman's powers manifested themselves in late-teens / young adulthood as we've seen in stories like George Francis Lowther's original Adventures of Superman novel from 1942, the original Adventures of Superman radio show, or the 1980s Man of Steel min...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.