slightconfuse's Superman: Earth One #1 - Superman: Earth One review

    Avatar image for slightconfuse

    Superman earth One Review

    Superman earth one is new take on the age old story for a new generation.   JMS decides to give us Clark Kent as a man with unlimited possibilities but trying to find the one that will make him happy.  Trying to give us a fresh take on these characters JMS fails to make any significant improvements but still tells an interesting story.  
     
    The story begins with Clark Kent exploring potential jobs such as scientist  and a football player in order to fit in with society.  All these jobs offer  high salaries(which he wants in order to support Ma Kent) and high acclaim. Clark seems lost in the big city s he seems to care about what everyone wants but him. Clark sees the Daily Planet as potential job but the reasoning behind it is not clearly explained. Clark see the paper in a rack and decides to apply for a job.   
    We are also introduced to Lois Lane and Jimmy Olden both who retain their personalities form the man DCU. Lois is a hard noised journalist who wants to get the story and Olsen is a happy-go-lucky shutter bug.  Perry White is still the old guard editor in cheif as he has ben portrayed in the past. JMS did not stray to far from the formula in developing these characters at all.
    In a secret lab scientist have been working on Clarks ship that he came to earth in. They activate the ship which then summons the main antagonist to earth. Earth is invaded by Tyrell and his ICP look a likes. This invasion forces Clark to choose between being human or giving up a normal life and becoming the protector of earth. The motivation behind Tyrell's  invasion is that his people made a deal with a mysterous figure who destroyed kypton in exchange for genocide of the 
     kryptionians. i feel like this cheapens the destruction of Krypton and this also leads to my biggest complant about the whole book. It reads like there was going to be a sequel to this graphic novel and that how the story read. JMS should have tried to make this a more complete experience to give the reader more closure.  Superman saves the day with an assist from jimmy  and Lois and the world is exposed to superman.  
    Shane Davis  backgrounds are good but i felt his character art was inconsistant. Character facial expression seemed awkward and their faces different form the pages before. The art did not detract from the story at all and i felt the action scenes were well done.  
    This was an enjoyable story overall but the changes made to mythos did not add anything to the experience and it was a good superman story granted it should have been a more complete one. 

    Other reviews for Superman: Earth One #1 - Superman: Earth One

      More Than Just a Man 0

      Since watching the Man of Steel a couple of weeks ago I've been in a big Superman mood, and decided to start my Superman reading with Superman: Earth One. When I first bought this book I was sceptical, as although J. Michael Straczynski is a good writer he wasn't doing that good on the normal Superman series at the time, as Grounded was simply disappointing. I did however decide to buy it, and was very happy to have.PlotHaving arrived in Metropolis Clark Kent looks for a job that will make him e...

      11 out of 11 found this review helpful.

      I don't understand the hype. 0

      I don't get why people like this book. I found myself hoping for the book to just be over when I was about 15 pages in. I swear I wanted to enjoy the book I just couldn't get into it at all. The colors were dull and bored me; the art was nice I feel it didn't really fit this book. The writing had a really slow pace which would of been fine if I cared about any of the stuff it wasted time on. Still, I could've seen why people liked this book if the villain wasn't so lame. I've seen people compla...

      9 out of 9 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.