lvenger's Superman #702 - Grounded, Part Two review

  • Score:
  • lvenger wrote this review on .
  • 5 out of 6 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
  • lvenger has written a total of 49 reviews. The last one was for Out of Time

Superman #702 - It's the journey that matters not the destination

 

This is my first review and I'm going to do it on a comic I read yesterday. The Grounded storyline has recieved mixed criticism by comic readers. Personally, I liked Superman #700 and 701 so far. It's provided a refreshing change of pace from the usual Superman stories but how does Superman #702 stack up to the previous two issues?
 
Synopsis
 
Superman continues his journey across America, stopping in Detroit, Michigan where he encounters aliens, a run down factory and Detroit's economic problems
 
SPOILERS!!!!

The Good
 

  • JMS has a knack for revitilising and putting new directions on characters he writes. He's already done this for Spider-Man, Fantastic Four, Thor and The Twelve. The decision to have Superman walk across America is a bold move on JMS' part and so far he's carrying the story well.
  • Bringing Superman from facing down Lex Luthor, Brainiac and Bizarro to encountering real issues such as immigration, economy and a life and death scenario is a welcome change of pace for the book.
  • Returning the Golden Age Superman's desire to help the common man back into modern Superman was a nice touch and in this issue, Superman does just that.
  • Mixing a typical Superman problem (aliens on Earth) with more realistic problems (economic issues) worked well for me. Some people may believe that using aliens was unnecessary and that Superman should have solved the problem himself but for me, it deonstrates JMS' new Superman and how he will solve future problems both big and small.
  • The dialogue. This, as with the previous issue is chockablock with words. Here, JMS demonstrates Superman's ability to bring out the best in people whether it be to inspire them or put a smile on their face. It wasn't as good as in Superman #701 but there was interesting dialogue in this issue and I was glued to each page studying the dialogue. 
  • Superman's feel good factor. Some of these scenes may be too cliche but I've always had a soft spot for Big Blue so I liked these scenes even if they were too corny. The basketball scene shows how much of a nice guy Supes is and reminded me of Spectacular Spider -Man #262 where Spidey plays some rough teens at basketball to get the children's basketball back. Touching. And the man who just wanted to see Superman fly? Very nice.
  • The fight scene. Again, some people may find it pointless to insert action in here but I found it to be well executed, perfectly choereographed and a good break from the walking and ordinary problem solving. I mean, if Superman just walked around solving ordinary problems all the time, people might lose interest. The fight scene keeps people on their toes. Reminded me of Thor #5 where Thor fought the Destroyer.
  • Portraying Superman in a new light is an interesting direction for JMS to be taking the Man of Steel in. Heroes are known for staying out of matters such as the ones in the issue and instead fighting big monsters and evil supervillains. Having Superman deal with real situations brings out the true nature of Superman as being the best of humanity and a symbol for good not just for America but for the world.
  • The ending was a real cliffhanger and really makes me want to get Superman #703. My real question is is it Bruce on the last page and if so, what the hell is he doing there? Isn't he supposed to be stuck in time or something?
  • The art. Eddy Barrows' pencils perfectly capture emotion on people's faces and his layouts if they are from actual places in Detroit were brilliant as well. The action scene was dynamically drawn, demonstrating Barrows' strength at these particular scenes. Combined with JP Mayer's inks to highlight the colour in the comic, Barrows and Mayer are an artistic partnership perfect for this story.
  • The cover. It depicts a classic pose of Superman. Great shot, great colouring and a stoic face.

    The Bad

  • The immigration speech. In this, Superman ignores the alien's compelling argument about how he is living here illegally and instead berates them on coming here, despite the fact he knows several other aliens living here illegally e.g Martian Manhunter and Supergirl. And then saying he'll think about whether they can stay?! Not very Superman like. He's tolerant of everyone from wherever they come from.
  • Superman threatening to expose the alien's cover just so they can stop a man from dying. Not on whatsoever.
  • The aliens saying that letting a sentient being die goes against what they believe in which is confusing because I'm sure that robot was trying to kill Superman!
  • Despite the fact JMS is trying to provide Superman with a new direction, there is still the unsolved matter of Lois and Clark sorting out their feelings about New Krypton and the Death of Sam Lane which I feeel ignoring it is not a sensible move.
 
Final Score
 
Story: 8 out of 10
Art: 10 out of 10
Cover: 10 out of 10
Overall: 9 out of 10
3 Comments
Posted by mightiness

great review. check out mine

Posted by Kallarkz
Nice review. 
 
But as far as some point on the "bad" I kind of agree with Superman as far as his indecision with the aliens. When i read your review I thought that he was getting hard on them because they simply immigrated here and didn't come legally (though part of his frustration was due to that). The main reason why he was annoyed was because they were simply existing there and not contributing anything to mankind. 
 
And I'm glad Super Boy Scout is out. I like when Superman said you can either help him or basically I'll expose you all. Showed hes willing to go outside of the old Superman box and do whatever it takes to help people in need.
Posted by Lvenger
@Kallarkz:  True but super boy scout is who he is. He's supposed to be a mainstayer to the ideals of truth, justice and the American Way. That's his mantra for helping others. But yeah the whole illegal immigration and non contribution to society were reasons why Supes was telling off those aliens

Other reviews for Superman #702 - Grounded, Part Two

    Superman, is still just walking. 0

    The Storyline: Superman continue walking down the street as he comes across more situations and moments that would answer our questions about the Man of Steel on how he would interact with certain situations that we naturally go through.  The Good: - The artwork is great and also keeps the flow of this comic moving, helping the audience understand what is going on and most of all is how Supermans expression is shown after certain events and situations in this comic. - The storyline for this comi...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.