Interlude
Geoff Johns' arc is over and it left a lot of promise for the coming Superman issues. As both a fan of Superman and Johns' work, I'm disappointed Johns left the book so early. Then again, he has a tight schedule, so we can hardly blame him. Anyway, John Romita, Jr. takes the reigns for this issue, so let's how he fares in the writing duties.
The Good
The issue continues on the plot threads established by The Men of Tomorrow, namely Superman's solar flare power. The Justice League's involvement in this issue was a major plus, because it shows the team's commitment in helping a friend in need. The sarcasm helps alleviate such a serious situation. And yes, Batman makes jokes in this issue. I liked the tests the League makes on Superman, it shows even after all they've faced, this is definitely uncharted territory.
Also, I admit Clark getting drunk was a bit funny. At first, I was opposed to it because I thought getting the most famous superhero of all time drunk was an insult to his dignity. But after seeing it, I guess wasn't as bad as I thought it would be.
Mostly, I feel ambivalent towards John Romita, Jr.'s art style, but he delivers some quality pics in this issue. They remind me of how fun the Silver Age was. And the colors, oh God, the colors, they're so beautiful and vibrant. Color should not be lacking in a Superman story. Romita Jr. might not be in my top ten list of favorite artists, but when he gets his act together, he can deliver.
The Bad
The Justice League in a bar? Seriously? Even if they are in their secret IDs, it comes off as out of character for any of them, especially since Aquaman doesn't have a secret ID, so it might raise suspicions. They come off as characters from a random sitcom, drinking on a table, making jokes about their day, etc. And why does Barry Allen need a hat anyway?
Superman talking out loud is fun, but this issue overdid it. He talks about nearly every little thing happening on the climax. Remember, the inner monologue has benefits.
The Verdict
Overall, this is an entertaining and fun issue, even if it serves as filler in the greater scope of Superman's history. I enjoyed the witty interactions between Superman and the Justice League, although the idea of them bonding in a bar is inappropriate for people like them. The fight against the criminals with the huge laser guns is fun, if a bit forced to establish future drama. Superman talking to himself out loud is unnecessary and could have been used to a minimum. I have serious reservations about the Truth storyline happening after Convergence, but I will keep an open mind until it finally starts.