pspin's Supergirl #12 - Inheritance review

Supergirl #12 Review

Supergirl #12 Review

Overview:

Supergirl meets up with Superman before going deep sea diving.

The Good:

The story is pretty good, particularly the opening scene with Superman where they talk about the differences between them and how even though they are family, neither of them trust each other completely; Kara because she doesn’t really know if they are really family, and Clark because he feels she is not careful with her powers. This dynamic is something that is really interesting because before the New 52, almost all readers just knew that they liked each other and opens a lot of possible stories and cool fights.

The writing by Michael Green and Mike Johnson is really good. Nearly everything that happens is reasonable for the characters and the way that Kara’s thoughts take after she leaves the Fortress of Solitude is really interesting and, for lack of a better term, human.

Mahmud Asrar’s art is once again great he little details that he puts in help bring the art to life, like the bubbles that form when Kara uses her laser vision under water and the underwater backgrounds.

The Bad:

When she is under water, Kara goes from holding her breath to not needing to breathe after taking in a lung full of water and mentions that she doesn’t need to eat or sleep as well. The lack of sleep is understandable but I don’t get the food or breathing, while this isn’t a major detraction, it caused me to reread it and was confusing; maybe it will be explained later.

Two things about the art stuck out. One: Superman looked weird in this issue. It was mostly the hair but he still looked off, but I have not been reading his series so maybe that is how he normally looks but it was odd to look at.

The second was that Superman was drawn with considerable muscle definition and Kara was not. I am not saying that she should look like a body builder but last issue she was consistently drawn with muscles. Since she and Superman are both Kryptonian, they should have similar physiologies and similar musculature this was an annoying development because when Kara was more muscular it gave her a slightly more unique look and now it is gone. This is not a major detraction but it is annoying none the less.

Verdict:

Overall a great issue with only a few trip ups here and there but the story is looking to be a good one, especially the final reveal. The creative team of Green, Johnson, and Asrar consistently deliver one of the best books in the New 52 and any fan of the series will enjoy this issue and it is also a decent place for new readers to join in.

4 out of 5

P.S. Kryptonopolis is the funniest city name ever.

0 Comments

Other reviews for Supergirl #12 - Inheritance

    The Lonely Girl In An Empty Friendly World 0

    Supergirl's been very slowly starting to lose its surprisingly excellent touch touch lately, the Banshee arc had a very awkward and inconsistent balance of plot elements between nice 'becoming an Earthling' touches and so-so flashy action story, and last issue I was pretty bothered by her sudden decision to leave her only Earth friends behind because she's "dangerous." And this generic crowded cover really didn't excite me for this issue.However, with all that said, this issue loops around and g...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    A faint echo 0

    In terms of the series thus far, I have felt that it has maintained a decent amount of momentum and it pacing has been decent enough.  There have been times when this hasn't been the case though, and this issue resembles more one of those times than the others.  The talk with Superman is well handled in a sense, though it felt kind of forced and illogical at times.  As with a lot of moments at DC it seems to assume to dominant position of Superman just because he is Superman.  This is well handl...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.