Martin Sheen In Negotiations to Play Uncle Ben in Spider-Man

Posted by G-Man (29481 posts) - - Show Bio
It's funny how with all the Spider-Man cast news and rumors, I didn't even think about who would play Uncle Ben. Uncle Ben is perhaps one of the most important characters in Spider-Man's origin. If it wasn't for Uncle Ben getting shot and killed, Peter would have never become a superhero. 
 
For a Spider-Man movie, you should have the right actor to play this important role. The problem is, the actor probably won't get a lot of screen time. 
 
The Hollywood Reporter has announced that Martin Sheen is in "final negotiations" to become the next Uncle Ben. That sounds pretty cool. Sheen is obviously a big name so perhaps it's the small role (and big paycheck) that would make this appealing to him. Then again, since this is a reboot, maybe Uncle Ben will have a bigger role. 
 
The movie is set to begin in December. What are your thoughts on Martin Sheen being Andrew Garfield's uncle? 
 

Update 

Now THR is reporting that Sally Field is in talks to play Aunt May
 
What do you think about this? Do these two look the part? They're both good actors but don't seem old enough to play the comic book versions. Although I suppose you can say Aunt May from the Ultimate comics has a little more spunk.
Staff
#1 Posted by ReverseNegative (2729 posts) - - Show Bio

Not bad.

#2 Posted by johnny_spam (2028 posts) - - Show Bio

This could be some excellent casting.

#3 Edited by difficlus (10678 posts) - - Show Bio
#4 Posted by Grendel (560 posts) - - Show Bio

Spectacular actor with a hot mess of a son.

#5 Posted by ckal (1097 posts) - - Show Bio

Great actor. He should do a great job as Uncle Ben.

#6 Posted by comicbikerscott (152 posts) - - Show Bio

cool martin schhen uncle ben
#7 Posted by Bats (147 posts) - - Show Bio

Good choice - I think he fits the bill.

#8 Posted by MrMiracle77 (1659 posts) - - Show Bio

Ehh, they could do better.

#9 Posted by gordocomics (113 posts) - - Show Bio

i like this a lot. absolutely loved him (and everyone else) in the departed. great pick. i'm pretty excited for this movie.

#10 Edited by FadeToBlackBolt (23334 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm ok with this, not thrilled, not offended. I'll be more than pleased if every other supporting character gets the same reaction from me. 
 
Truthfully though, I just want to know who the other female lead is going to be. Dianna Agron ftw!

#11 Posted by Om1kron (1168 posts) - - Show Bio

amazing what 12 years will do to you.  
 

#12 Posted by G-Man (29481 posts) - - Show Bio

Update! 

Sally Field is apparently in talks to play Aunt May.
Staff
#13 Posted by MrMiracle77 (1659 posts) - - Show Bio
@G-Man said:
"

Update! 

Sally Field is apparently in talks to play Aunt May. "
 
That would be a casting choice that draws a little more interest from me.
#14 Posted by N7_Normandy (2430 posts) - - Show Bio

sounds good

#15 Posted by G'bandit (13689 posts) - - Show Bio

Oh ok, I thjought was the guy who played Topper in Hotshots 
 
I was like WTF NO waaaay! O_O! 
 
I think is his brother or something..

#16 Posted by UpUpAndAway (192 posts) - - Show Bio

Greeeeeaaaaaatt looks like were doing the origin story again.....*sigh* 
 
#17 Posted by Adam Michaels (435 posts) - - Show Bio

Aunt May and Uncle Ben were created in a time when grown-ups were depicted as old folks. At least that's how I see it. 
 
The Spider-Man comics and the Raimi devastation of a film franchise made made me feel like it was Peter Parker and his Gramma May and Grampa Ben. After all, Pete's in his teens. He's still in high school. It makes no sense to me having an aunt and uncle who look anywhere between their 60s and 70s.
 
I think casting actors to depict younger versions of the characters is a plus for me. Which is why I always enjoyed reading Ultimate Aunt May more than regular Aunt May (as lovely as she can be).  
 
And I think that's something Marvel has a great advantage of. They have their Earth-616 universe with all the great stories over the years. But they also have the very successful and awesome Ultimate Universe to work with. They have the opportunity to take bits and pieces from each universe and mesh them together to make one great movie with (as well as TV series). 
 
Only problem I have with this upcoming reboot is that it's still under Sony/Columbia. I don't know if and when and how, but I want Disney to pursue this franchise aggressively to get them under the Marvel Studios banner.

#18 Posted by Icon (2044 posts) - - Show Bio

The casting for this film just keeps getting better. 

#19 Posted by Icarusflies (12248 posts) - - Show Bio
@difficlus said:
" "
This has nothing to do with the thread, but that is adorable.
Moderator Online
#20 Posted by PumpkinBomb (493 posts) - - Show Bio
He'll probably do just fine, but Cliff Robertson was pitch-perfect in the role. Did you know he won an Academy Award for Best Actor back in the eighties?
#21 Posted by Fuloqwam (60 posts) - - Show Bio

 Starting over with the whole origin story again is a really bad idea.  Seriously, if there's anybody who doesn't know the basic origin story by now, the person sitting next to them in the theatre is bound to.  

 Hopefully, it'll just be a quick flashback.  Peter's nightmare or something.  

 Nice pick on the actor.  I like it.      

#22 Posted by ComicCrazy (1537 posts) - - Show Bio

sure fine. As long as J.k. simmons still plays JJJ
#23 Posted by TheMess1428 (2176 posts) - - Show Bio

Martin Sheen seems perfect but I don't know about Sally Field.

#24 Posted by Luthorcrow (178 posts) - - Show Bio
@Adam Michaels said:
" Aunt May and Uncle Ben were created in a time when grown-ups were depicted as old folks. At least that's how I see it.  The Spider-Man comics and the Raimi devastation of a film franchise made made me feel like it was Peter Parker and his Gramma May and Grampa Ben. After all, Pete's in his teens. He's still in high school. It makes no sense to me having an aunt and uncle who look anywhere between their 60s and 70s... "
I find it really comical how trendy it is to bash Sam Rami's run on Spiderman.  It's really unjustified and just smells of fanboyism going a little too far.  There plenty of problems with the last film but first two were gems.  
 
Aunt May has been right around 60-70 since I was buying Spiderman for $.20 an issue in the early 70's. Let's face Jessica Tandy missed her calling because she would have been a perfect Aunt May.
 
As for Martin Sheen as Uncle Ben, this first really bad casting for this film.  Hopefully they end up picking someone else.  First off Sheen is not Uncle Ben by a long mile.  Let's face it he is too much of a pretty boy and for the since Wall Street Sheen has not turned a none hammy performance.  I can't think of the last time Sheen was either good in a film or watchable (keep in mind you can be plenty watchable and still bad, i.e. Michael Cain in a bad film).  Since that travesty called "Spawn" I just can't take him seriously as an actor anymore.  The man has been coasting his name and former glory longer than anyone. 
 
Sally Field on the other hand would do a fine job.  Again, it is definitely glaming the character up because the original Aunt May never looked that good but she has the acting skills and great comedic timing. 
 
The more I think about Uncle Ben being in the film meaning it is going to be another origin story really depresses me.  By this time everyone knows that story already. It's one thing to reboot and rewind but do we really have to retell that again?  Please keep Ben to a flashback.  
#25 Posted by Gothic Storm (842 posts) - - Show Bio

The original actor and actress (Rosemary Harris and Cliff Robertson) playing those two roles were perfect. I'm going to laugh and probably shout out a line from 'Forest Gump' during the movie if Sally Field plays Aunt May. On the other hand, I might enjoy watching Martin Sheen get shot and... oh wait, you said MARTIN Sheen. Damn... I was hoping for Charlie Sheen!  ;)

#26 Posted by Joeybagad0nutz (1378 posts) - - Show Bio
@difficlus said:
" "

This. 
 
Martian Sheen did awesome in Mass Effect 2.
#27 Posted by Adam Michaels (435 posts) - - Show Bio
@Luthorcrow said:
I find it really comical how trendy it is to bash Sam Rami's run on Spiderman.  It's really unjustified and just smells of fanboyism going a little too far.  There plenty of problems with the last film but first two were gems.   Aunt May has been right around 60-70 since I was buying Spiderman for $.20 an issue in the early 70's.

Just because a whole lot of people bash Raimi's films doesn't make those reactions trendy. It's fine if you think the first two were gems. I'm of the opinion that all three were horrible.  
 
And that's exactly what I'm saying about May and Ben being aunt and uncle in their 60s-70s to a teenage boy. Sure it's been that way since Spidey's inception, but we're not in the 1960s anymore. Making them younger won't take away from their roles in Peter's life. All it will do is not make them look like grandparents. I think their Ultimate versions are perfect. They're not too young nor too old, but in between. They're "hip" and with the times.
#28 Posted by Toastalchemist (168 posts) - - Show Bio
@UpUpAndAway said:
"
Greeeeeaaaaaatt looks like were doing the origin story again.....*sigh* 
"
My thoughts exactly. Spider-man has decades of great stories and they choose to do the **** origin again. What's the point of this reboot if they are going to make it so much like the original? 
#29 Posted by RedSox8933 (2 posts) - - Show Bio

FUCK YES. I love Martin Sheen with every ounce of my being.

#30 Posted by Squigiman (2 posts) - - Show Bio

Just one question.  What are negotians? 
 
 
   -Squigiman

#31 Edited by Big (330 posts) - - Show Bio

Martin Sheen would be a great presence to play a supporting role in the story. A lot like Michael Caine being a terrifiic star to play Alfred in the latest Batman adaptation. Caine gives Alfred more of a role model feel than just a loyal servant. Bruce has to answer to Alfred sometimes to justify his actions. In other words, Bruce can't B.S. Alfred, and Michael Caine makes you believe that. I think Martin Sheen's presence will carry the same fatherly weight in the Uncle Ben character, much like he did as Charlie Sheen's father in "Wall Street." I hope he is actually cast in the film.

#32 Posted by DrKellogg (68 posts) - - Show Bio

They could nearlyu get stan the man to do it.

#33 Posted by difficlus (10678 posts) - - Show Bio
@Icarusflies said:
" @difficlus said:
" "
This has nothing to do with the thread, but that is adorable. "
its also a pun, as in i approve of this decision...:p
#34 Posted by Eyz (3095 posts) - - Show Bio

Well, with great powers come great responsabili- OUCH! Sorry! I had to say it! Put that hammer down!

#35 Posted by xerox_kitty (15760 posts) - - Show Bio

Nuts, that makes it tempting to see something I didn't care about...

Moderator
#36 Edited by FoxxFireArt (3536 posts) - - Show Bio

I would prefer it if they had Cliff Robertson again. He was perfect in the role, and he looked a LOT like my own grandfather who passed away when I was little. What's even weirder. My grandfather's last name was Robertson as well. No relation as far as I know. 

@xerox-kitty said:

" Nuts, that makes it tempting to see something I didn't care about... "

I'm still far more interested in this than in X-Men First Class. After they cast their Emma. That movie is dead to me.
#37 Posted by NXH (1031 posts) - - Show Bio

I could see that happening.

#38 Posted by They Killed Cap! (2243 posts) - - Show Bio

 
 
I guess this is good.
#39 Posted by kungnima (180 posts) - - Show Bio

Sally Field would be awesome!
Charlie Sheen to for that matter.

#40 Posted by Miltos (77 posts) - - Show Bio

Good choice

#41 Posted by Video_Martian (5631 posts) - - Show Bio
@UpUpAndAway said:
"
Greeeeeaaaaaatt looks like were doing the origin story again.....*sigh* 
 
"
#42 Posted by Moomin123 (2205 posts) - - Show Bio

Good choice, just so as long as there isn't Charlie Sheen and the other two guys from Two and a Half Men to make unfunny jokes whilst having obnoxious laugh tracks in the background.
#43 Posted by djames216 (18 posts) - - Show Bio
@Luthorcrow said:
" @Adam Michaels said:
" Aunt May and Uncle Ben were created in a time when grown-ups were depicted as old folks. At least that's how I see it.  The Spider-Man comics and the Raimi devastation of a film franchise made made me feel like it was Peter Parker and his Gramma May and Grampa Ben. After all, Pete's in his teens. He's still in high school. It makes no sense to me having an aunt and uncle who look anywhere between their 60s and 70s... "
I find it really comical how trendy it is to bash Sam Rami's run on Spiderman.  It's really unjustified and just smells of fanboyism going a little too far.  There plenty of problems with the last film but first two were gems.   Aunt May has been right around 60-70 since I was buying Spiderman for $.20 an issue in the early 70's. Let's face Jessica Tandy missed her calling because she would have been a perfect Aunt May. As for Martin Sheen as Uncle Ben, this first really bad casting for this film.  Hopefully they end up picking someone else.  First off Sheen is not Uncle Ben by a long mile.  Let's face it he is too much of a pretty boy and for the since Wall Street Sheen has not turned a none hammy performance.  I can't think of the last time Sheen was either good in a film or watchable (keep in mind you can be plenty watchable and still bad, i.e. Michael Cain in a bad film).  Since that travesty called "Spawn" I just can't take him seriously as an actor anymore.  The man has been coasting his name and former glory longer than anyone.  Sally Field on the other hand would do a fine job.  Again, it is definitely glaming the character up because the original Aunt May never looked that good but she has the acting skills and great comedic timing.  The more I think about Uncle Ben being in the film meaning it is going to be another origin story really depresses me.  By this time everyone knows that story already. It's one thing to reboot and rewind but do we really have to retell that again?  Please keep Ben to a flashback.   "
I completely agree.  I feel that Martin Sheen would be miscast in this role.  It's far too distracting to have a big name playing such a role.  Don't get me wrong, I like Martin Sheen, he's a good actor, but this role does not suit him.  I will also echo the groans others have made about the fact of featuring Uncle Ben again in the first place.  There is a VAST back catalogue of stories to look at with Spider-Man.  Uncle Ben had his time in the previous movies.  Move on Hollywood and try something different, stop going over old ground. 
 
My Opinion
Spider-Man 1 = Above average.
Spider-Man 2 = Pretty good.
Spider-Man 3 = Not so good.
#44 Posted by The Impersonator (4317 posts) - - Show Bio

I hope this time Sandman is not involved in killing Uncle Ben. Even though he didn't actually killed him.

#45 Posted by Marshal Victory (677 posts) - - Show Bio

Lossing more intrest in this .If this trend keeps up ill be hopeing it bombs at the box office.An that would be a long shot. 
 
No one else thing their throwing on "stars" for apeal to mask somthing? 
 
like retelling origin again ( can be done in the intro ) .It looks like sony has more control this time .Thats not always a good thing.
#46 Posted by -Vigil- (379 posts) - - Show Bio
@Icarusflies said:
" @difficlus said:
" "
This has nothing to do with the thread, but that is adorable. "
Yeah, I totally saved it to my hard drive for later use.
#47 Posted by Luthorcrow (178 posts) - - Show Bio
@Adam Michaels said:
" @Luthorcrow said:
I find it really comical how trendy it is to bash Sam Rami's run on Spiderman.  It's really unjustified and just smells of fanboyism going a little too far.  There plenty of problems with the last film but first two were gems.   Aunt May has been right around 60-70 since I was buying Spiderman for $.20 an issue in the early 70's.
Just because a whole lot of people bash Raimi's films doesn't make those reactions trendy. It's fine if you think the first two were gems. I'm of the opinion that all three were horrible.   And that's exactly what I'm saying about May and Ben being aunt and uncle in their 60s-70s to a teenage boy. Sure it's been that way since Spidey's inception, but we're not in the 1960s anymore. Making them younger won't take away from their roles in Peter's life. All it will do is not make them look like grandparents. I think their Ultimate versions are perfect. They're not too young nor too old, but in between. They're "hip" and with the times. "
 
Fair enough.  I could leave with a younger Uncle Ben and Aunt May.  I still think Martin Sheen is real miss note.  The man lost his passion for the craft a very long time ago. 
 
I say "trendy" because people tend to folk to fit in any social scene.  Comic book fans and geeks in general are no exception.  It's also because I think it is really unjustified given the tenor and the quality of the films we are talking about (excluding the third one).  It's like we are talking about the prequel Star Wars films which are a crime against humanity, story telling, acting and anyone that was a fan.  Sam Rami is a solid director with an excellent eye for scenes, passing and story telling.  I am not saying you have to like the but "horrible" that's just  hyperbole.
#48 Posted by Adam Michaels (435 posts) - - Show Bio
@Luthorcrow:
Not hyperbole... my genuine opinion on the trilogy. And I can definitely list all the things I didn't like about Raimi's take on Spidey that justify my personal dislikes. It's all subjective, right? But the truth is, we'd be going way off topic here since this is about the rumor having Sheen cast as Uncle Ben. 
 
We can argue all day about Raimi's trilogy, but that's a tired old debate that's played out. We'd be wasting our energy. We're better off agreeing to disagree. 
 
As for Sheen as Uncle Ben: I can't really comment because I don't remember watching anything with Sheen in it.  
#49 Posted by goldenkey (2927 posts) - - Show Bio
@Adam Michaels: if you're gonna watch something with him in it then you gotta see Apocalypse Now.  The Vietnam movie that's just loaded with big actors. 
#50 Posted by Chibi-Iroh (388 posts) - - Show Bio

Yes Yes a million and one times yes.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.