Which issues arcs etc. etc. ?
He's one of my favorite writers and i haven't read his run on sm
Character » Spider-Man appears in 17246 issues.
I definitely recommend his work on Spider-Man. The only bad story from him I can think of at the moment was One More Day (thoroughly disappointing). Oddly, my favourite arc of his is Back in Black which directly preceded One More Day.
If you can; I would recommend you go for it! I loved the JMS run, it's really enjoyable, since JMS is able to write the characters really well. Heck, he even made Aunt May an interesting character again. OMD isn't a JMS story, it's a Joe Q. story, and was overall forgettable. I would also AVOIDSINS PAST, because Joe Q. got all up in JMS's story and messed it up. Those two stories were the ones JMS himself didn't like. Other than those, JMS is probably one of the best runs ever!
JMS's run is different. It's alot of mysticism. It's definitely an awesome run you should totally read it. 2 things you should know One More Day(OMD) isn't as bad as people make it out to be and everyone pretends the Grey Goblin arc never happened so they can complain more about OMD
@Phaedrusgr said:
One of the best writers...
Idd, he shoudl come back to write Spidey, starting to find Slott tiresome..
I'll be the minority on this thread and say with all honesty that JMS's run was horrible imo...adding supernatural aspects to Spider-man's origin was DUMB...I really do believe that his arc along with the unmasking is what painted Spider-man into a corner and Marvel felt the only way out was to retcon it and thus OMD
@danhimself said:
I'll be the minority on this thread and say with all honesty that JMS's run was horrible imo...adding supernatural aspects to Spider-man's origin was DUMB...I really do believe that his arc along with the unmasking is what painted Spider-man into a corner and Marvel felt the only way out was to retcon it and thus OMD
The other was weird. I mean peter being watched over by some spider god creature
@consolemaster001 said:
@danhimself said:
I'll be the minority on this thread and say with all honesty that JMS's run was horrible imo...adding supernatural aspects to Spider-man's origin was DUMB...I really do believe that his arc along with the unmasking is what painted Spider-man into a corner and Marvel felt the only way out was to retcon it and thus OMD
The other was weird. I mean peter being watched over by some spider god creature
yeah...that stuff has no place inside a Spider-man comic
I'm actually reading it currently, so it's fresh on my mind (Yea... Last time I read it was 5 minutes ago) and I can give a honest review. The thing, that made it awesome IMO are:
1. Good portrayal of characters. Every character is portrayed just the way it should be. For the first time in a very long time I don't have a wish for aunt May to be dead, and I'm telling you - that means something. Spider-man was funny, MJ felt something more than your stereothypical comic book hero's gf etc.
2. Chemistry between Pete and MJ. Previousy Peter's and MJ's marriage somehow felt bland. Like they've been married for years and didn't had the feelings to eachother like previously. Since JMS took over it's changed. He REALLY good shows the chemistry between P and MJ, and I actually had a feel, that they were in love and not long ago married.
3. Ezekiel. I liked Ezekiel's character alot. He's something like uncle Ben with spider powers.
4. Good story arcs. JMS had some really good story arcs. Back in Black, Sin's Past (besides creepy fact, that Norman and Gwen... Y'know... I actually enjoyed it...), Book of Ezekiel etc.
5. Good Storytelling. JMS had some really good storytelling. He gave us a good insight of Peter's personal life 'n stuff... Yea, I don't know, what to say here. I just really loved the way JMS wrote comics.
UPDATE:
When i bought comics i didn't pay atention to the writer. I went over my stash the other day and look what i found:
JMS is very good IMO.
OMD was as much down to Joe Quesada as it was him, if not more so.
His run during the Other, Civil War and Black in Black (man that was good) is what got me into reading Spider-Man regularly.
Even Sins Past and Sins Remembered wasn't too bad IMO- I understood the concept and his idea, it was a bold attempt, but just wasn't done with enough polish. Even so, as others had said, the chemistry he created with Peter and Mary-Jane was such that spoiling the reputation of Gwen Stacy wasn't that disastrous. And it was retconned in any case :P
One of the best Spider-Man runs, though I disliked OMD and that Spider totum crap. His wrote the best MJ/Peter relationship I ever read.
@laflux said:
JMS is very good IMO.
OMD was as much down to Joe Quesada as it was him, if not more so.
His run during the Other, Civil War and Black in Black (man that was good) is what got me into reading Spider-Man regularly.
Even Sins Past and Sins Remembered wasn't too bad IMO- I understood the concept and his idea, it was a bold attempt, but just wasn't done with enough polish. Even so, as others had said, the chemistry he created with Peter and Mary-Jane was such that spoiling the reputation of Gwen Stacy wasn't that disastrous. And it was retconned in any case :P
no it wasn't...Gabriel Stacy has shown up post OMD
Please Log In to post.
This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:
Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.
Log in to comment