Artist Vs Artist: Spider-man

#1 Edited by Strider92 (11286 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

Thought i'd do a sort of faceoff between the Spider-man artists as there's been some stunning pencil art recently. Simply say who your favorite out of the two are (the pictures are just for reference. You are not basing your choice on the images I posted but the whole issues they've done) and it will continue with two more after this one.

Round 1:

Giuseppe Camuncoli:

Vs

Stefano Caselli:

#2 Posted by TDK_1997 (9673 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

I love them both and I like how Camuncoli is doing every character he has done so far but Caselli for me.

#3 Posted by ShirEPanjshir (581 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

Love both, but Caselli's art has a more vibrant & dynamic feel to it. Therefore I vote Caselli!

#4 Posted by theTimeStreamer (1342 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

camuncolli STOMPS

#5 Posted by TheGoldenOne (38599 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

Caselli.

#6 Posted by Gambit1024 (9878 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

What they said

#7 Posted by VeganDiet (478 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

Casselli. Camuncoli's art is great as well, but very, very occasionally, a few of his characters will end up look a little off. Plus, Casselli is one of my favorite comic artists period. Everything looks so vibrant and flashy.

#8 Posted by WaveMotionCannon (2523 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

Casselli FTW. He's that dude.

#9 Posted by spidey 15 (17756 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

Both are awesome but i prefer Caselli! Much more unique art imo.

Also you could later add Checchetto and Siqueira. They have done their work on ASM and i do believe they're great.

:)

#10 Posted by Strafe Prower (11535 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

Giuseppe Camuncoli

#11 Posted by ChaosMarvel (871 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

I love them both but i'm going to vote for Giuseppe Camuncoli because I love how he does action scenes!

#12 Posted by danhimself (18745 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

Caselli

#13 Posted by kingjoeg (662 posts) - 8 months, 4 days ago - Show Bio

Caselli

#14 Edited by Strider92 (11286 posts) - 8 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Caselli seems to be leading at the moment. I'll give it another few hours and then put the next 2 up.

#15 Posted by Galactic_Man (158 posts) - 8 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

I. Hate. Caselli.

#16 Posted by Strider92 (11286 posts) - 8 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Caselli wins Round 1. Honestly I thought that would have been closer O.O.

Round 2:

Terry Dodson:

Vs

Mike Deodato Jr

#17 Posted by VeganDiet (478 posts) - 8 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Dodson. Deodato's Spidey is too bulky looking.

#18 Posted by VeganDiet (478 posts) - 8 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

I want this thread to not be dead

#19 Posted by guttridgeb (4346 posts) - 8 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

Mike Deodato Jr

#20 Posted by spidey 15 (17756 posts) - 8 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

I love both but maybe i'll go for Dodson. I prefer his shading, slightly a bit more and that is the only reason.

:)

#21 Posted by Gonzo33 (111 posts) - 8 months, 1 day ago - Show Bio

Dodson. Ftw.

#22 Posted by deadpoolspidey877 (113 posts) - 8 months, 1 day ago - Show Bio

deodato wins easily

#23 Posted by InfamousFish (352 posts) - 8 months, 21 hours ago - Show Bio

Terry Dodson

#24 Posted by SoA (3527 posts) - 8 months, 21 hours ago - Show Bio

deodato

#25 Posted by TDK_1997 (9673 posts) - 8 months, 13 hours ago - Show Bio

Mike Deodato Jr.

#26 Posted by Strider92 (11286 posts) - 8 months, 11 hours ago - Show Bio

We have a tie thus far.

#27 Edited by Death Certificate (5439 posts) - 8 months, 10 hours ago - Show Bio

Too hard for me to pick

#28 Posted by PaperDemon (242 posts) - 8 months, 4 hours ago - Show Bio

deodato jr.

#29 Edited by DarkKnightDetective (6732 posts) - 8 months, 4 hours ago - Show Bio

Dodson

#30 Edited by Strider92 (11286 posts) - 7 months, 28 days ago - Show Bio

Well looks like i'll have to call that round a draw Dodson and Deodato got equal votes.

Gonna go for 2 of the big guns this time!

Round 3:

Mark Bagley:

Vs

Todd McFarlane

(seeing this pic makes me miss Spider-man's big eyes T.T)

#31 Posted by spidey 15 (17756 posts) - 7 months, 28 days ago - Show Bio

Todd is a pretty good artist( even though his faces kinda suck ) and he had a revolutionized style to how spidey is made, but i'll have to vote for Mark. He is by far the better artist imo and he makes a great spidey.

:)