After the Rikti War, Shallice Tillman's body was damaged to the extent that she was forced to put her mind into the body of another superheroine, Aurora Borealis. Numina was eventually able to restore her to her original body, leaving Aurora Borealis severely weakened. Her husband sought assistance, and eventually both were restored.

When Lord Recluse cast a ritual to remove the superpowers from Paragon City, her mind was split once more between herself and her former host. Upon being exposed to the Flame of Prometheus she was restored to her former self once more.

When Manticore is suspended from the Freedom Phalanx, and approaches Lord Recluse, he is told to kidnap Sister Psyche to prove his worth. She is used to power a giant spider-like robot, and Lord Recluse almost succeeded, until Manticore revealed that he was a double agent. It is hinted during this time that Manticore and Sister Psyche have a strong attachment. However Sister Psyche tells Manticore that his feelings for her cannot be described as love. Unlike the other members of the Freedom Phalanx, Shallice knew the truth about Manticore's plan.

In the end of Issue 20 Manticore fires a arrow with a engagement ring on it telepathicly asking Sister Psyche to marry her in which she accepts. During the wedding an attack which is led by Lord Relcuse takes place. In the end the villains are defeated and Manticore and Sister Psyche are married.