theshame's Secret Avengers #12.1 - Fear Itself, Pt. 1: The Captain review

    Avatar image for theshame

    Thirty pieces of Silver?

    By far one of the most interesting .1 issues released by Marvel, Secret Avengers 12.1 presents a thought provoking self-contained tale of espionage and morals that deals with many lingering discrepancies between Steve Rogers' political stance before and after the Civil War.  In crafting this tale guest writer Nick Spencer also provides a rare insight into the impacts of espionage that are often glossed over by writers, whereby every action has definite ramifications for the civilian population. 
     
    The Good: Spencer's concise, (yet detailed), writing combined with Eaton's clean, well defined pencils combine to create an atmosphere which is sufficiently gritty whilst also retaining the more visceral elements of a comic.  The 'Captain' provides an interesting and multi-faceted antagonist for the Secret Avengers, whereas  Spencer presents A.I.M and Hydra in a suitably menacing light; they should be depicted as ruthless organisations instead of bumbling foils for the protagonists. 
     
    The Bad: Steve Rogers' justifications for his actions as America's new 'Top Cop' were lacking and failed to convince me regarding his political U-turn post rebirth. Particularly notable was Roger's insistence that surrounding events conspired to ensure that he 'fell into' his current role , a statement that seemed more in line with Iron Man's monologue in Civil War: The Confession.  I personally would have liked to have seen a more protracted fight between the 'Captain' and the Secret Avengers (I Guess the kid in me wants to see a few more punches to balance out the level of plot development).  
     
    Overall Conclusion: An entertaining one off issue that melds great writing and art together for aplomb. The quality of this issue bodes well for Nick Spencer's future with Marvel and i am eagerly awaiting his run on the upcoming Ultimate Comics: X Men.

    Other reviews for Secret Avengers #12.1 - Fear Itself, Pt. 1: The Captain

      It'll have to do 0

      In terms of this series thus far, this issue really stands above the rest of them and by a substantial margin.  A top secret list of informants has been leaked and they are starting to turn up dead in an awfully fast hurry.  Knowing that he can't save them all, Steve makes the decision to save one.  The planning and execution of this mission is perfect save for one small (yet fatal) flaw.  In itself this issue would have had a lot of weight except for what came next.  In an indeterminate amount ...

      5 out of 5 found this review helpful.

      Shades of Gray 0

      I had dubious feelings as reading this issue, because what concerns the fact of this Point One initiative I think this issue really did well, introducing the new creative team, delivering a self contained story that truly captures what this team should be about, but in the other hand I really didn´t like the execution of the story too much, regarding the dialogues (Ant Man explaining the old joke to War Machine was a horrible line), the motives of the characters - this is especially about U.S. A...

      2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.