Dick-Boring as Robin but awesome as Nightwing/Batman

Jason- More interesting Robin but Badass as Redhood until Morrison ruined him

Tim-Fantastic as Robin & downright incredible as Red Robin

Stephanie-Boring until she became Batgirl

Damien-Best Robin in my opinion,brutal and hilarious.Love his dark humor

Carrie- WHO?!

S'gotta be Grayson

 Tim for robin or red robin 

grayson for nightwing 

Damien is interesting as hell. But I'm torn between Dick and Tim. 

1- tim drake  ( the best robin EVER)
2- damian wayne ( badass kid)
3- dick grayson ( better as nightwing)
4- jason todd
5- stephanie brown
6-carrie kelly

Tim

DAMIAN!!! :D 
 
He's certainly the most fun.

Tim Drake is not only my favorite Robin, but my favorite DC character, period. He's just. that. awesome.

Dick is the better overall crime fighter,   
Tim is the better partner and detective,  
Damien is the funniest and has the most potential,  
Jason is the deadliest,  
Stephanie is the most annoying

My favorite Is Jason but I would have to say Dick was  the best.

Dick is the best Robin. 
Jason is my favorite.

Damian Wayne will end up as the best Robin and could also eventually become the best hero of them all.

Dick is best as Nightwing, so I say Tim is the best Robin overall. Though I like his identity as Red Robin A LOT better. Of course about a year prior I had the idea that, being a great detective, he could bring the identity of The Gray Ghost into the comics. Then Johnny C. Usurped it in Batgirl. Jerk.
I do agree with you about Damian. I've had a long history of Robin hatred, most of it was childish, fueled by the pairing of short-pants wearing silly Dick fighting crime alongside brooding badass Batman. (Alliteration not intended.) And Damian was the key factor in bringing me out of that hatred. Finally, a Robin who was badass. Then I read some of Tim's Robin title, and went, oh, Tim's a cool Robin too. Maybe Robin's not so bad overall. Wait, I think I lost my train of thought. THe moral of the story is, Damian is awesome, and my favorite Robin.

"Dick saw being Robin as a job, that's why he grew out of it. 
Jason saw being Robin as a game, that's what got him killed. 
But Tim sought out the role, he knew the stakes. He wants to be the worlds greatest detective. And based on what we've seen... he will be someday."  -Batman

Drake. He's the lesser fighter of the Batfamily, but he thinks on a scale Batman respects. 
He's the only true detective of the Robins, and he knows how to get things done.

I love me some Tim Drake :)

Dick is the greatest, this is why he got the promotion to Bats.

 
Tim Drake is the best overall.

I prefer Drake, but Damian is becoming more interesting.

Damian is the MAN.
 
Because of this...
 

I won't say anything about The Red Hood but as Robin Jason was horrible he was unskilled, did not listen, and everyone hated him he was clearly the worst Robin since I don't count Stephanie or Carrie

I'm not really a Damian Wayne fan. He's too much of a snotty brat, and while I can appreciate having a variety of characters in a story, he's one I could do without. 
 
Dick Grayson and Jason Todd are my favourite characters here, but not because of their time as Robin. It's their time as Nightwing and the Red Hood that I really like. 
 
I suppose Tim Drake is my favourite actual Robin, but I have no interest in him since he became Red Robin.

Overall all the Robins adds something intersting to the picture in very different ways.
 

• Dick is the most developed character, aside from setting the standard he's also the one who was able to step out of the Bat's shadow and rebuild himself as a new man. I like him best as Nightwing
  
• Jason has the most interesting relationship with Batman, as Robin both Dick and Tim were quite happy to follow Bruce's lead almost all the time, Jason was more independent and
  
• Tim is probably the one who fit better into the Batman-in-training role, while he's not the fighter Dick and Jason are he's probably the smartest and the best detective
  
• Steph was a bad move that didn't last long, but her current role as Batgirl is quite good
• Damian share some similarities to Jason
  
• Carrie... not much of an impact for me
  

You're right about Damian even looking a bit menacing! XD
 
I grew up with Tim, so he's my fav and gets my vote!
Jason really marked the Bat-history by dying..I'd say, had he not died he wouldn't be as popular as he is today! Even with his "resurrection".

Dick Grayson is the best by far. 
 
@Tom Pinchuk: By the way, there are 5 Batgirls, not 3.

Tim is the best Robin. Damian 2nd. I hate Damian so much that I love him, he's a great character.

Tim all the way.  He is the only one to really earn the mantle. Dick Grayson is great now but when he was Robin, not so much. Jason Todd there was a reason fans voted for his death. Steph wasn't even that good as Spoiler. 
Damian seems like Jason Todd revisited angry reckless and won't listen to orders. 

Tim and Damian are the best Robins! 

" No other Robin accomplished half the stuff Tim did as Robin "

" Tim and Damian are the best Robins!  "

" @NightFang said:

" Tim and Damian are the best Robins!  "

co-signed. "

Definitely Tim Drake. He has the intelligence and the heart. Damian has the same fate as Jason.

Tim Drake!!

Tim Drake.  
 
I like Dick Grayson as Nightwing and he's a superb Batman, but I think Tim Drake was a better Robin... for some reason though im not keen on his new status the Red Robin?

Dick was the first and the coolest Robin.

Tim Drake is the best Robin in terms of detective & fighting skills & having a good attitude, but Dick Grayson is the original Robin & more interesting a character.

Tim Drake all the way.

Jason

Tim Drake...Tim Drake...Tim Drake...Tim Drake

IMO, the only good Robins were Dick and Tim. And I slightly prefer Tim.

Tim is more interesting. To me, Dick didn't get interesting until he set out on his own.

you gotta give Dick Grayson his props for being the first robin, but Damian is by far my favorite Robin. Jason Todd comes in at 2nd. Then Tim Drake