Comic Vine Review

8 Comments

Justice League Dark #23.2 - Soul Shadows Review

3

Where does Eclipso come from and where will he go?

The Good

Eclipso finds a new host in Gordon Jacobs. Will he and Gordon be the perfect fit or will Eclipso have to find a new vessel?

The driving force of this book is the ridiculously awesome page layouts. This book is worth the $2.99 just to see how these scenes are set-up. Phillip Tan experiments with these beautiful layouts that are very non-traditional. As soon as Eclipso enters the picture, the world around Gordon is distorted. This is why the reader is treated to things like a splash page with a black diamond border, with a panel in the negative space, of Eclispo walking out of the shadows. The book is filled with some awesomely set-up pages like this. However, this isn't a style of story telling that would work for any book, but it fits perfectly into this Villains Month issue.

Again, on the artistic side of things, artist Philip Tan, inker Jason Paz, and colorist Nathan Eyring do some really interesting things here. It feels like this book was put together by two very different artists where it switches depending on the tone of that particular panel or page. The colors switch from a more traditional style to what seems like water colors. It's a really cool effect that brings some extra emotion to the story.

The Bad

There's a few times, in this issue, where the art is a bit inconsistent. Now, as mentioned earlier, there's two very distinct styles going on here, but that's not the problem. The main character, Gordon Jacobs, face changes a bit in length and width. There’s one panel in particular where he gets a case of "horse face," on page four.

The story is ok.The first half of the book, where the reader is introduced to Gordon is a bit dry. This is a case where the art really outshines the story. Eclipso doesn't really feel like a threatening villain because readers haven't seen a lot of him, unless they were reading TEAM 7, SWORD OF SORCERY, DEMONS KNIGHTS, or CATWOMAN, and three of those books are no more. What it really boils down to is that this book wasn't that interesting.

The Verdict

Overall, JUSTICE LEAGUE DARK ECLIPSO was an ok issue. Storywise, it's ok. Gordon isn't the most thrilling character and his backstory was so-so; however, the art here, minus one problematic area, was stellar. The way this team executed these pages was brilliant and it really spiced this issue up. I'm curious to see how Eclipso will work as a Justice League Dark villain, but we'll have to wait and see. Overall, I give this issue a mild recommendation, mainly because these page layouts are incredibly cool.

9 Comments
Posted by HeckTate

I wish the JLD villains issues had some villains we've actually seen during the run of JLD. I was very disappointed with the Creeper issue, but I'll probably pick this one up for the artwork at least.

Posted by Icarusflies

SURPRISE, the art's better than Dan Didio's writing. >EXTREME EYE ROLL<

Moderator
Posted by inferiorego

@hecktate said:

I wish the JLD villains issues had some villains we've actually seen during the run of JLD. I was very disappointed with the Creeper issue, but I'll probably pick this one up for the artwork at least.

I was really hoping for a Nick Nekro issue.

Staff
Edited by Superbat420

@hecktate: why doesn't anyone like the creeper issue? I've always been a fan and I thought it was a great issue, am I missing something?

Posted by HeckTate
Edited by Superbat420

@hecktate: yea that makes perfect sense if your a jld fan me personally am not a fan and just a fan of the creeper, I like that they turned him into a villian even though I think the host will fight it and gain control and he will be a hero again.

Edited by mightyrearranger

@hecktate: Agreed, I was really hoping for a Doc Destiny issue since I loved his redesign.

Posted by Herokiller12344

Eclipso? Of all the villains, they pick him?