Comic Vine Review


Green Lantern: New Guardians #23 - Keep Hope Alive Review


Relic begins to strike at each spectrum's champions, starting with the most underestimated: the Blue Light of Hope.

The Good

Justin Jordan’s tale of the massive, cosmic entity Relic’s quest to rid the universe of it’s ostensible protectors plows on without resting as the Blue Lanterns are targeted. We learn a little bit more about Relic’s motives, but more questions are asked than answered and we get a taste of his incredible power. Jordan has a lot to juggle here and he does so with aplomb and vigor, writing each of the primary characters with just the right amount of focus while paying service to the over-arching Lantern storyline of the spectrum entities’ illness. Relic is stoic without being dispassionate or detached, Kyle remains as snarky and headstrong as ever without being arrogant, Carol is focused and quick-thinking without being reckless and the Blue Lanterns are serene without being boring, it’s a fascinating thing to watch all the players get so much attention and characterization when there are SO many of them in a given panel and page.

Speaking of that, Brad Walker’s pencils are absolutely stunning. Every character is distinct and every panel is dynamic and clear. This is one of those issues that could have been a silent one and still had it crystal clear what’s happening from moment to moment and overall. Andrew Hennessey’s inks bring that sharp focus home, keeping order and pace strong and cutting as well as highlighting Wil Quintana’s gorgeous colors. When you have a title that focuses on something called “spectrum warriors,” you’d best have a good colorist and Quintana has been incredible over his run on this title. The colors practically leap off the page and they do an amazing job of highlighting the action and communicating the tone.

The Bad

As interesting as Relic has the potential to be, I’m feeling a lot of redundancy from the First Lantern. He’s either immune to, or can channel, the spectrum’s powers, he wants to destroy them for reasons they don’t understand, but he certainly does (and he isn’t sharing), and a great deal of his tone and presentation echos the previous event. There are occasional panels that don’t flow particularly well from one into the next and whose characters react strangely based on what happened in a previous one.

The Verdict

The final page of this book is absolutely devastating and has me salivating over what the next issue (well the issue AFTER Villain’s Month) will bring. This issue continues the greatness that has been brought to this book and I continue to recommend it month after month. I’ve always been a huge fan of Kyle Rayner and, even though Johns gave him plenty of credit in Rebirth, always thought he was overshadowed by more serious-minded Green Lanterns (yes, even Guy Gardner), so to see him get not only his own title, but royal treatment like he hasn’t seen since he had the Ion power is an absolute joy. Minor quibbles aside, this is a great book for anyone interested in a little sci-fi mixed with their superhero story, and with a very different, more fantastical, tone from the other Lantern books.

9 Comments Refresh
Edited by darknightspideyfanboy

last page was sad

Posted by joyita1413

the last page... NOOOOOOOOO :(

Posted by Zeeguy91

That last page makes me want to see them take down Relic....hard.

Posted by 34g3f3ert3t43

What happened??? Please don't tell me Walker died...?

Posted by darknightspideyfanboy

@n1colaspr1me: let just say this,Supergirl,and Wonder Woman are competing for OMFG moment in there book

Edited by stevencarver_


Relic completely destroyed the Blue Lantern's world. Like, Napalm proportions. It was epic and extremely upsetting. As for if Walker is dead, you'll have to find out for yourself :)

Posted by The Stegman

My goodness...that ending.

Posted by Chronicjihad

Loved this one. The last page few pages were especially well done. Poor elephant blue lantern. :(

Anyway, I bet they're temporarily killing off the blue lantern corps (sans Saint Walker) in order to make them more effective. They might even bring Ganthet and Sayd back to help Walker rebuild.

If I remember correctly, Parallax wasn't with the other entities in Green Lantern #23 when the white entity said they were dying. I bet Sinestro shows up and saves everyone's asses next issue. Here's to hoping, anyway.

Posted by Ando123

pretty awesome