Comic Vine Review

11 Comments

Earth 2 #15.2 - Where the River Ran Red Review

3

Solomon Grundy returns to Earth-2 while we learn the tragic origin of this horrific figure.

The Good

An interesting aspect of Villain’s Month is the chance for creators who don’t normally work on a specific title to try their hand at it, thus giving the readers something new for a month. Matt Kindt takes the reins for Earth-2, telling the story of Solomon Grundy’s return to the planet from where Alan Scott previously left him as well as filling in the avatar’s backstory, beginning over a century ago. We get a very similar Grundy to the one we’ve previously seen in this title, which is to say he’s not a hulking, idiotic brute, but neither is he quite as loquacious as he previously was, which serves the character just fine after the trauma of his last appearance. He crashes into a desert outside a major city and slowly makes his way there, destroying all the life he can come across in the process. While this is going on, we cut to Slaughter Swamp in 1898 and see a rural couple struggling to make ends meet working in a slaughterhouse. Events take a turn for the INCREDIBLY grim and we see what appears to be the beginning of Grundy’s rise to power.

Aaron Lopresti handles pencils, with Art Thibert on inks and Michael Atiyeh on colors, and here the book shines. Grundy’s massive frame still somehow looks like it’s barely holding itself together, and his body language gives a great testament to his nature as incredibly powerful, but still in a state of constant decay and renewal. He looks profoundly uncomfortable merely existing and his actions are also gloriously rendered with great fluidity from one panel to the next, particularly as his atrocities intensify.

The Bad

There’s simply not enough meat on this bone to satisfy. Far too much takes place in the present, and what is there jumps forward without rhyme or reason as the flashbacks seemingly fill the time it would take Grundy to complete his various treks on-foot. His power is obviously reduced in the wake of his defeat, but it doesn’t feel like we need to see as much of him in the present as we do, it’s a little too reminiscent of Doomsday’s original emergence, because it cuts the flashback scenes EXTREMELY short. We barely get a feel for the characters, and as such, we don’t really feel for them on anything but the most superficial level when tragedy strikes. Time seems, again, to jump rapidly ahead and things happen at such a breakneck pace that it’s difficult to truly take them in, especially as the events have a tremendous amount of gravity (or at least should). The infamous Grundy poem makes an appearance as well, but what happens on which day seems to vacillate between past and present. This may be intentional, but it’s hard to tell.

The Verdict

I think the book’s main problem is that it could have had half the pages that take place in the present cut and used to increase the pages that take place in the past. If you’re going to explain a villain’s tragic backstory, it helps for the reader to be able to find some kind of sympathy or SOME way to identify with what the characters are going through, but as it is, everything happens too fast to form any kind of meaningful attachment. It’s still an interesting origin story, and the art really deserves to be seen, but it’s far to scattershot to form a truly meaningful narrative.

12 Comments
Posted by Kal'smahboi

This rating is pretty disappointing. I was always a fan of Grundy, and I wasn't too sure about the new version in Earth 2. Probably still pick this up and check it out.

Posted by waezi2
Posted by ThePRez

this was just a boring book also like @waezi2 said too much swamp thing

Edited by Undeadpool

This rating is pretty disappointing. I was always a fan of Grundy, and I wasn't too sure about the new version in Earth 2. Probably still pick this up and check it out.

I think Grundy has been GREAT in Earth-2 as a general thing (the first arc of the title stands as one of my favorites in New 52 so far), this issue just felt like it could've given us more backstory and less returning.

Staff
Posted by Herokiller12344

I can't type out an exasperated sigh. But just know that I'm having one.

Posted by MartianManhunterIsBetterThanCyborg

I thought it was alright. Though I am happy that he's back under Alan Scott's rogues gallery again.

Posted by bennyq

I wonder if his baby will come back into play

Posted by Wilbertus

Born on a Monday.

Edited by danhimself

as much as I like Earth 2 I really don't like this version of Solomon Grundy

Posted by superior_prime_maybe

i didnt really understand his issue.
Can someone help?

Posted by dangermart

Bored on a Monday.

I've just read this and I have to say, Corey, that's a very fair review. I actually found myself laughing, it was so stupidly violent. Not the talented Matt Kindt's finest moment.