Punisher Forum

Punisher is a comic book character that first appeared in The Amazing Spider-Man #129

who should punisher kill in marvel?

Topic started by Dark King on June 23, 2009. Last post by castleking 3 weeks, 5 days ago.
Post by Vance Astro (51,775 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Dark King said:
" but if you register which is fine, you should also be allowed to leave whenever you want. tony took that option away from peter.i have no problem arresting vigilantes when they are caught b/c lets face it all heroes are just that. but, forcing them to register is wrong. now lets talk about who else punisher can kill, we'll leave tony for the future death column.   :) "
You're saying that something Iron Man did to save everyone makes him a criminal.That's a direct contradiction.


Post by Dark King (2,375 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
saving everyone from what?  if i were to take away  ppl's guns and cars and said it was  to save their lives, they would fight me tooth and nails... just because something is legal doesnt mean its the morally right thing to do.


Post by sifsclub (277 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
punisher should kill osborn. and both hulks. green and red.


Post by Vance Astro (51,775 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Dark King said:
" saving everyone from what?  if i were to take away  ppl's guns and cars and said it was  to save their lives, they would fight me tooth and nails... just because something is legal doesnt mean its the morally right thing to do. "
I explained already. Did you read any of Tony's dialogue in Civil War?
Tony was trying to keep the American Government off the superhero community and keep the people they are trying to save, the American public..believing they are the heroes.Before Stamford,heroes did whatever they wanted.His gripe about that was how are people supposed to trust them when they have people they don't know running around as costumed heroes with no consequence for their actions? There's more too it but you get the gist.Tony explained all of this to Captain America before they fought.


Post by Dark King (2,375 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
tony 's stance was political not morally motivated unlike cap's position, big difference...  also if you read some of my earlier comments you would know that i agree with locking up heroes for vigilantism if caught, for various other reason then simply not registering.


Post by Rothschild (890 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Vance Astro said:
"@Dark King said:
" saving everyone from what?  if i were to take away  ppl's guns and cars and said it was  to save their lives, they would fight me tooth and nails... just because something is legal doesnt mean its the morally right thing to do. "
I explained already. Did you read any of Tony's dialogue in Civil War?
Tony was trying to keep the American Government off the superhero community and keep the people they are trying to save, the American public..believing they are the heroes.Before Stamford,heroes did whatever they wanted.His gripe about that was how are people supposed to trust them when they have people they don't know running around as costumed heroes with no consequence for their actions? There's more too it but you get the gist.Tony explained all of this to Captain America before they fought.
"

and you must not have read any of Caps Rebuttals to Tonys paper thin argument


Post by Vance Astro (51,775 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Rothschild said:
" @Vance Astro said:
"@Dark King said:
" saving everyone from what?  if i were to take away  ppl's guns and cars and said it was  to save their lives, they would fight me tooth and nails... just because something is legal doesnt mean its the morally right thing to do. "
I explained already. Did you read any of Tony's dialogue in Civil War?
Tony was trying to keep the American Government off the superhero community and keep the people they are trying to save, the American public..believing they are the heroes.Before Stamford,heroes did whatever they wanted.His gripe about that was how are people supposed to trust them when they have people they don't know running around as costumed heroes with no consequence for their actions? There's more too it but you get the gist.Tony explained all of this to Captain America before they fought.
"
and you must not have read any of Caps Rebuttals to Tonys paper thin argument "
I read the whole thing.Cap's rebuttals were just as dumb as what Tony was saying.


Post by Dark King (2,375 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
punisher just snipes tony during a board meeting, just to end this debate.


Post by Rothschild (890 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Dark King said:
"punisher just snipes tony during a board meeting, just to end this debate."

While disguised as a memeber of the board... And casually walks out undetected...


Post by castleking (12,600 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Rothschild said:
" @Dark King said:
"punisher just snipes tony during a board meeting, just to end this debate."
While disguised as a memeber of the board... And casually walks out undetected... "
nah.......he would just snipe him out from across the street.


Post by kev17 (102 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
i hope castle blows that idiot modok away pretty soon. the guys essentially a cube with puny limbs. a quick rpg will take him out.


Post by bringdeath (69 posts) See mini bio

Loading...

Well if you look at the dark reign story arc Frank is really pissin osbourne off .......I mean ya never know
Maybe Frank  will end osbourne ...I can see that.



Post by Brit (91 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Punisher should kill Joe Q!!


Post by castleking (12,600 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
@Serpent said:
" Tony Stark.Reed Richards.I'm not even going to go into all the reasons they are dictators, fascists, criminals.  This is a comic book site, and people won't change their opinions, even in the face of overwhelming fact. "
explain it to me pls...


Post by MTS (1,365 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
Someone kill Norman Osbourne please quickly


Post by castleking (12,600 posts) See mini bio

Loading...
 saw a scan of black cat wanting to be a burglar again. it got me wondering why frank hasnt gone after her before. she is a known thief criminal regardless of helping spidey and other heroes from time to time.





kev17
2,675 points

Dead
2,008 points

Anjales
364 points

xerox-kitty
209 points

eganthevile1
182 points


You are in Edit Mode. Make sure to save your work at the end!!
  • Submissions can take 24 hours to be moderated.
  • Please leave a comment to explain why you're making this change.
Save Changes Cancel