my favorites are Storm, X-23, Dani Moonstar (how dare you forget her, lol) Rachel grey, Psylocke, Rogue, Siryn, Kitty, Emma, and Magik
I also like Boom-Boom, Polaris, Dazzler, Sage, Frenzy, Monet, Domino,Surge, Dust, Mercury, Armor, Pixie, Wolfsbane, Magma, Karma
Hope needs a better story. I really want to like her but she's got to be made into a clone or reborn, reincarnated as Maddie or Jean Grey.
As far as villains: I love Mystique, Maddie Pryor, Selene, Lady Deathstrike, Candra
I didn't include Dani Moonstar, cause I don't think she is as popular as some of the ladies above. She maybe more popular than Sage or Hope, but none of the others.
I also think characters like
Frenzy, Monet, ,Surge, Dust, Mercury, Armor, Pixie, Wolfsbane, Magma, Karma. Are all great characters, but I don't think some are as popular as the others.
Storm,Rogue, Emma Frost, Jean Grey, Psylocke, Kitty, Jubilee and Mstique are consider as the most popular X-ladies. Most of these ladies will appear in most X-Men fans top 10.
How about these Ladies,
Dazzler, Sage, X-23, Domino, Boom Boom, Magik, Polaris, Hope Summers and Rachel Grey.
How popular are they. Can please put the ladies in order that you like them.
from the first Group
From the 2nd Group
Polaris (i missed her when she was gone... but i realised i didn't need her when she returned)
Rachel Grey (Didn't miss her when she was gone... annoyed they brought her back from oblivion - TWICE)
My Top 10
7. Madelyne Pryor (she was an X-Man, however briefly)
8. Monet (have always loved her attitude... and always agreed it was valid - she is practically perfect in every way)
9. The Stepford Cuckoos (They're Emma clones... what's not to like?)
10. Jubilee (would love to see her with her own powers back, but Vamp Jubes is pretty cool.. and her accessory: Shogo is kinda cute)
I think what you are doing is spot on, I want to know how popular the other x-ladies are. Who after people top 10 x-ladies. You know the next top 10.