29 Comments
Edited by The Poet

“It’s everything you want, but not what you expect,”
 
Oh! that got me curious! I wondered about them! they couldn't just get rid of those original chracters...wonder what I should not expect?

Moderator
Posted by The_Tree

Good news. I just hope they can get a good writer on the series. 
I wonder if they'll still have ties to WWII.

Posted by RedheadedAtrocitus

They (as in DC) better...is all I have to say about that. You just don't revamp things to the point where you completely discard the grandfather of superhero teams. You just simply do not do it.

Posted by The_Tree
@The Poet said:
“It’s everything you want, but not what you expect,”  Oh! that got me curious! I wondered about them! they couldn't just get rid of those original chracters...wonder what I should not expect?
That makes me think they're going to write stories about the JSA in the past rather than them be old in the present.
Posted by junkmasterzero
@The_Tree:  I would be okay with that, and it would still leave room for all of the legacy characters.
Posted by Dernman

Ug I was hoping the golden aged heroes of the JSA were gone for good or at least retconed.

Posted by The_Tree
@Dernman said:
Ug I was hoping the golden aged heroes of the JSA were gone for good or at least retconed.
:O Blasphemy!
@junkmasterzero said:
@The_Tree:  I would be okay with that, and it would still leave room for all of the legacy characters.

So would I, I'd love to read stories, about when they were the top dogs of the DCU, and all of their members were alive.
Posted by TheRedRobin
@junkmasterzero
@The_Tree: 
Don't want to bring anyone down here but DC talked about making Superman the first hero so I don't think they're going to make JSA in the WW2 setting.
Posted by The_Tree
@TheRedRobin said:
@junkmasterzero: @The_Tree: Don't want to bring anyone down here but DC talked about making Superman the first hero so I don't think they're going to make JSA in the WW2 setting.
Wasn't it stated that Superman was only the first public hero?
Posted by TheRedRobin
@The_Tree
I dont remember the exact wording but then that would mean they weren't known heroes.
Posted by Or35ti
Posted by The_Tree
@TheRedRobin: I'd be fine with them being seen as urban legends/myths.
 
@Or35ti: That's some tricky wording, when I read that, I didn't see it as them saying the JSA will be back on Earth-2, but them saying that the JSA will return, and Earth-2 will also make a return.
Posted by Primmaster64

I hope CM returns.

Edited by Dernman

To me it would be better if they were around but not as Superheroes.
Ted Grant could have been a great Boxing champ and own a gym but wasn't wildcat superhero. Wildcat could have been his ring name.
Jay Garrick could be mayor of the city flash is based in.
Things like that. 
Also one pet peeve that really bugs me.      Active during WW2 yet still walking around like they are only in their 50-60s. Bring them up in time a little.

Posted by ReVamp

I wouldn't be okay with that. At all. I want them back in the present. 
@Dernman said:

To me it would be better if they were around but not as Superheroes. Ted Grant could have been a great Boxing champ and own a gym but wasn't wildcat superhero. Wildcat could have been his ring name. Jay Garrick could be mayor of the city flash is based in. Things like that.  Also one pet peeve that really bugs me.      Active during WW2 yet still walking around like they are only in their 50-60s. Bring them up in time a little.

Blasphemy!
Posted by The_Tree
@Dernman said:
To me it would be better if they were around but not as Superheroes. Ted Grant could have been a great Boxing champ and own a gym but wasn't wildcat superhero. Wildcat could have been his ring name. Jay Garrick could be mayor of the city flash is based in. Things like that.  Also one pet peeve that really bugs me.      Active during WW2 yet still walking around like they are only in their 50-60s. Bring them up in time a little.
Their aging process has slowed down thanks to Ian Karkull.
Posted by Dernman
@ReVamp said:
I wouldn't be okay with that. At all. I want them back in the present. 
@Dernman said:
To me it would be better if they were around but not as Superheroes. Ted Grant could have been a great Boxing champ and own a gym but wasn't wildcat superhero. Wildcat could have been his ring name. Jay Garrick could be mayor of the city flash is based in. Things like that.  Also one pet peeve that really bugs me.      Active during WW2 yet still walking around like they are only in their 50-60s. Bring them up in time a little.
Blasphemy!
You want them as golden aged heroes? Or retconed as heroes of today?
 
I would rather have them on another earth then as heroes of the golden age.
Posted by ReVamp
@Dernman said:
@ReVamp said:
I wouldn't be okay with that. At all. I want them back in the present. 
@Dernman said:
To me it would be better if they were around but not as Superheroes. Ted Grant could have been a great Boxing champ and own a gym but wasn't wildcat superhero. Wildcat could have been his ring name. Jay Garrick could be mayor of the city flash is based in. Things like that.  Also one pet peeve that really bugs me.      Active during WW2 yet still walking around like they are only in their 50-60s. Bring them up in time a little.
Blasphemy!
You want them as golden aged heroes? Or retconed as heroes of today?  I would rather have them on another earth then as heroes of the golden age.
I want them as heroes who fought in the second World War and are still alive today, kinda like we had in New Earth.
Posted by Dernman
@ReVamp said:
@Dernman said:
@ReVamp said:
I wouldn't be okay with that. At all. I want them back in the present. 
@Dernman said:
To me it would be better if they were around but not as Superheroes. Ted Grant could have been a great Boxing champ and own a gym but wasn't wildcat superhero. Wildcat could have been his ring name. Jay Garrick could be mayor of the city flash is based in. Things like that.  Also one pet peeve that really bugs me.      Active during WW2 yet still walking around like they are only in their 50-60s. Bring them up in time a little.
Blasphemy!
You want them as golden aged heroes? Or retconed as heroes of today?  I would rather have them on another earth then as heroes of the golden age.
I want them as heroes who fought in the second World War and are still alive today, kinda like we had in New Earth.
I can see why you like them but I was hoping to close that chapter more of a change,
A good compromise would be putting them on another earth. They can even take Captain Marvel with them.
Make them the heroes of that world instead of the JLA..
Posted by ReVamp
@Dernman: Maybe it would work.
Posted by JLAsuperdude
@Dernman
They are on a another earth...
Posted by Dernman
@JLAsuperdude: Sweet It's like having your cake and eating it too.
Posted by DEGRAAF

while i have never been a huge fan of JSA i am happy to hear that they are being redone on Earth-2. I was originally hoping yo keep it down to 1 earth for a couple of years but as long as they better coordinate and organize whats going on where and at what point in time with minimal multi-verse cross overs then i am ok with it.

That will also allow for Powergirl to be herself and for the Supergirl we all have come to know to stay her same peppy self.

I'm curious if they will have Earth-2 Superman and Lois.

Posted by batflasharrow96

@Dernman: Ugh, why?

Posted by Dernman

@batflasharrow96 said:

@Dernman: Ugh, why?

Why what.

Posted by Billy Batson

Good to know.
BB

Posted by Kairan1979
@Dernman said:
Ted Grant could have been a great Boxing champ and own a gym but wasn't wildcat superhero. Wildcat could have been his ring name.
I guess you've read DC : New Frontier.
Posted by Dernman
@Kairan1979 said:
@Dernman said:
Ted Grant could have been a great Boxing champ and own a gym but wasn't wildcat superhero. Wildcat could have been his ring name.
I guess you've read DC : New Frontier.
Nope never and I keep putting off watching the movie.
Posted by Kairan1979
@Dernman said:
@Kairan1979 said:
@Dernman said:
Ted Grant could have been a great Boxing champ and own a gym but wasn't wildcat superhero. Wildcat could have been his ring name.
I guess you've read DC : New Frontier.
Nope never and I keep putting off watching the movie.
If you want to see Ted Grant as heavyweight boxing champ, you should check New Frontier (only the comic book, not the movie).