People are just going to hate on Catwoman. They have been doing it since issue 1 even though every creative team since then to now have done an absolutely amazing job. If Mr Layman and Lopresti took over, it wouldnt be long before people started to complain about them.
It's not that, I was one of the few people who loved the first 12 issues, despite a heavy dose of sexuality, I felt Judd Winick had inlaid some incredibly deep and emotional storytelling and character work. Ann Nocenti is an absolute hack, the pacing swings about wildly, most of the dialogue is awkward, and the plotting is utterly erratic. The art's perfectly fine, but it can't even come close to fixing such a broken and pathetic script. And some plot points are just stupid! Like, Catwoman is SERIOUSLY stupid enough to think that stealing MORE from the Penguin will send him a message to back off? OF COURSE it started a gang war, THAT WAS PAINFULLY OBVIOUS BECAUSE OF THE PENGUIN'S PERSONALITY. HOW COULD SELINA BE THAT STUPID? HOW COULD ANY WRITER BE STUPID ENOUGH TO MAKE HER THAT STUPID?
I'm 90% certain that the redhead at the table everyone's confused about is Poison Ivy. She fits the profile, she's next to mostly villains at the table; AND there's a bunch of vines on the building directly behind her.