The Debaters Hall of Fame Members

This thread is here simply as a place to honor the Hall of Fame members. Want to see a debate they had that was epic? Look here. This is also just a way to keep track of them without having to search for the threads.

Round 1 Inductees

the creator

Static Shock

Gambler

Buckshot

Vance Astro

Round 2 Inductees

Morpheus_

k4tzm4n

Zoom

AtPhantom

Ferro Vida

Dane

Round 3 Inductees

Erik

Silver2467

Power NeXus/(((Prodigy)))

King Saturn

geraldthesloth

Round 4 Inductees

JediXMan

spidey15

Lance Uppercut

Final Arrow

Matezoide

Round 5 Inductees

vuviper

Lunacyde

god_spawn

Strafe Prower

CosmicSpiral

MrDirector786

Round 6 Inductees

CitizenBane

beatboks1

Floopay

Super_SoliderXII

texasdeathmatch

Disclaimer: I'm not doing this to pat myself or anyone else on the back. I'm only doing this as a reference source for debates that I would like to see again. I'm sure I'm not the only one that wants to revisit Morph vs. k4tz or Static vs. Vance. debates.

Rule: This is not a place to argue about who doesn't deserve to be on the list or who should be on the list.

If you have a thread that I should add under a person's name, please let me know and I will add it! I added the 3 that came to my mind

82 Comments
82 Comments
  • 82 results
  • 1
  • 2
Posted by Frozen

When is the next hall of fame?

Posted by Strafe Prower

@Frozen: It's overdue, the problem is that no one has set up the next round. beatboks started a nomination thread, but it was deleted pretty fast by his request. If I see a lot of requests to do it, I might host the next round. It is a lot of work though.

Posted by Killemall

@Strafe Prower said:

@Frozen: It's overdue, the problem is that no one has set up the next round. beatboks started a nomination thread, but it was deleted pretty fast by his request. If I see a lot of requests to do it, I might host the next round. It is a lot of work though.

By all means go on, do it :)

The favourite at the moment to me appears to be CitizenBane , we gotta give him credit when credit is due, it would be nice to see.

Posted by Baldy

@Strafe Prower said:

@Frozen: It's overdue, the problem is that no one has set up the next round. beatboks started a nomination thread, but it was deleted pretty fast by his request. If I see a lot of requests to do it, I might host the next round. It is a lot of work though.

I knew I'd seen that thread. Just before it was deleted I nominated Klandicar, it was gone a few short moments later. Probably due to logic explosion.

I hope another thread is started at some point, purely because I think it's about time Citizen Bane gets voted in.

Posted by Strafe Prower

@Killemall: If I get a few more requests, I will. I want to give credit to some of the newer debaters for sure, and CitizenBane is one of those.

Posted by comicdude23

@Strafe Prower: Yeah. Do another one, it'd be awesome.

Posted by Strafe Prower

@comicdude23: I guess I will

TO ALL: I will do start the next round today! Please try to keep this thread on topic from here on out!

Edited by beatboks1

@Strafe Prower said:

@Frozen: It's overdue, the problem is that no one has set up the next round. beatboks started a nomination thread, but it was deleted pretty fast by his request. If I see a lot of requests to do it, I might host the next round. It is a lot of work though.

There were some comments to me in PM that I've been running it to often and it degrades what it's about. So I figured I's drop it back to a 12 month instead of 6 month regularity. I still see some benefit in trying to promote the positive activities we'd like to see more of on the vine by rewarding them with the proper recognition, but I don't want to cheapen the whole thing.

It was after that that I asked Mercy to delete

Posted by comicdude23

@beatboks1: I hope the current one isn't deleted.

Posted by Strafe Prower

@beatboks1: I don't think that having it every 6 months is too often. There are plenty of debaters that deserve to be in the HoF, so I see no problem. If they do think it cheapens the HoF, they can come to me about it and we can discuss it.

I honestly think that it is silly to wait a whole year when there are so many on the list. The longer we wait, chances lessen for those who have left CV to get in.

Posted by comicdude23

@Strafe Prower said:

@beatboks1: I don't think that having it every 6 months is too often. There are plenty of debaters that deserve to be in the HoF, so I see no problem. If they do think it cheapens the HoF, they can come to me about it and we can discuss it.

I honestly think that it is silly to wait a whole year when there are so many on the list. The longer we wait, chances lessen for those who have left CV to get in.

This is true. I think yearly is too long IMO.

Posted by Strafe Prower

I have updated the links and such to include more. Please help me out with some debates! I can't remember them all lol.

Posted by Baldy
Posted by God_Spawn

I'd like to say I have some memorable, quality debates to put up there but I can't honestly think of one other than Daken vs Magneto with Citizenbane against everyone else. It was awesome.

Moderator
Posted by Baldy

@god_spawn said:

I'd like to say I have some memorable, quality debates to put up there but I can't honestly think of one other than Daken vs Magneto with Citizenbane against everyone else. It was awesome.

Yeah that was a great one, I would have posted it in the above but he isn't in the list (yet).

Posted by God_Spawn

@Baldy: I am though lol. I jumped in at a different point but still went on for pages with it.

Moderator
Posted by deadpoolrules

Man,I can't debate evn two comments with someone,I won't appear here by a long time.

Posted by Erik

Where is the nomination thread?

Posted by Strafe Prower

I updated this with the new Hall of Fame members.

Posted by jashro44

Congratulations to the winners!

Posted by ghost_rider1

What is this?

Posted by Strafe Prower

@ghost_rider1: This is show the greatest debates of the Hall of Famers.

Posted by entropy_aegis

Congrats to the new inductees.

Posted by Deranged Midget

Many congrats to the new inductees!

Moderator
Posted by beatboks1
Posted by RoyalDivinity

@entropy_aegis said:

Congrats to the new inductees.

Posted by Killemall

@PunkMastaFlex said:

@entropy_aegis said:

Congrats to the new inductees.

Posted by Lvenger

Congratulations to the new inductees! :)

Posted by Strafe Prower

@beatboks1: Thank you! Nice threads! I will add them shortly

Posted by Strafe Prower

Updated with beatboks1's threads. please help me out here!

Posted by Floopay

@Strafe Prower

I would help out but I only have internet via phone atm. Thanks for the mention though, I'll pop back in next week when I hopefully can log in and type with a real keyboard.

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

Posted by Strafe Prower

@Floopay: Cool! Thanks for checking! I'll see if I can't dig something up for everyone by that time.

Posted by k4tzm4n

Ugh, I hate my tournament debate with Morpheus.  I literally had no counter for Daken's pheromones so I was forced into speculation.

Staff Online
Posted by Strafe Prower

@k4tzm4n: You both didn't have knowledge you now know. Despite that, it was an awesome debate. Probably the best I've seen on the vine.

Posted by k4tzm4n
@Baldy said:

Storm versus Sinister Six (k4tz and rbysjti)

Wolverine vs Magneto (Buckshot vs Assorted)

They arn't what you would call 'great debates', but still required reading.

And that, my friend, is what spawned my Vulture vs Storm thread.
Staff Online
Posted by k4tzm4n
@Strafe Prower said:

@k4tzm4n: You both didn't have knowledge you now know. Despite that, it was an awesome debate. Probably the best I've seen on the vine.

Ehhhhhh.  I stood no chance of winning that one.  I didn't fully understand Daken at the time and my team literally had no counter to the pheromones.  Regardless, always love having a good conversation with Morpheus.  Speaking of him, this is the first thread we made together:  http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/spider-man-vs-punisher-kraven-rules-included/404593/
Staff Online
Posted by Strafe Prower

@k4tzm4n: Nice, I'll add it ASAP

Posted by Mercy_

Does anybody have a link to that epic debate between Gambler and Morph? I think Deathstroke or somebody from that family of characters was involved O_o

Moderator
Posted by Strafe Prower

@Mercy_: I could try to look it up, but that's kind of vague XD

Posted by Strafe Prower

@k4tzm4n: BTW, I can't believe we have only had 1 good debate. it feels like I have debated you more than that.

If I could post from the other site, there is a lot more LOL.

Posted by God_Spawn
Moderator
Posted by Mercy_
Moderator
Posted by Strafe Prower

@god_spawn: Thanks! How did you find that?

Edited by God_Spawn

@Strafe Prower: I remembered the debate caused it was awesome and DH and I asked for more like it.

Moderator
Posted by Strafe Prower

@god_spawn: Nice

TO EVERYONE, MANY OF THESE GUYS DON'T HAVE A SINGLE THREAD. ANY HELP IS APPRECIATED!!

Posted by God_Spawn
Moderator
Posted by Strafe Prower

@god_spawn: Once Again, thank you.

Posted by beatboks1

currently at work on tea. when I get home tonight and look them up expect some creator v forever, Buckshot v forever and other threads. did i mention that I'm going to plug the hell out of forever b4 the next round ;D

Posted by Strafe Prower

@beatboks1: It will be appreciated!

...Don't make me go Klandicar on you. :P

Posted by God_Spawn
Moderator
  • 82 results
  • 1
  • 2