I loved the early part of Carey's run that got collected as "Supernovas", all the way through Messiah CompleX. She's out of the action by the beginning of Blinded By The Light, but I really loved her there. Conversely, I haven't care for the writing of her at all in the more recent issues of Legacy. She lacks the edge I love about her, the attempts to write her as a more mature and responsible leader figure have dried out the character, making her a more talkative version of why I always found Cyclops boring.
Conversely, while AVX was kind of wretched, I like the position it's put the characters in. For the first time, I'm actually loving Cyclops, rather than hating him or just loving to hate him. Making him an antihero with Magneto and Emma is just fantastic, and reflects the desperation of the Mutant community.
I'd enjoy seeing Rogue as a leader, but I want her to be a leader who makes mistakes. Though she gets the job done in Children of the Vault, and the subsequent stories, she makes mistakes, and in the end, her team turns out to be every bit as untrustworthy as one might fear. It made for a great story. I recently bought some trades of Storm's early tenure as leader, and she makes mistakes there too. Once she gets enough experience under he belt that she's less prone to this, she loses her powers for a while, making her more vulnerable in another manner.
I've always liked the X-men best when they find themselves making desperate moves in desperate situations. The stage is set for some great writing in that vein, and i'm hoping to see it here. If Rogue is going to be leader, let's cut the fluffed up competence of Legacy's writing. I want to see mistakes, and I want to see perseverance.
Log in to comment