Topher Grace, easily. He could have made the character a sympathetic yet menacing badass, and one of the best villains EVER. He couldn't be sympathetic OR menacing. Part of that is due to the script itself, but Grace's acting didn't help. I actually loved Affleck as Daredevil though, and even though I hated the Green Lantern movie, Ryan Reynolds as Hal Jordan was the ONLY good thing about it (Shame he didn't get a better script, he could have been phenomenal)
Who's making all this guild code & rules for Superman? Don't set up here and tell me about what a fictional character would & would not do. Period. Superman can be open for many different iteration to come. If you hate the character then why invest the time to come on his forums and talk shit?
Even if I liked the character, it would make little sense. Pair her up with She Hulk or something.
I imagine it's not so much Clark she be interested in, but more of her attraction to Superman. Why wouldn't a bad girl like Catwoman find comfort in a guy who's like a god?
Also same chemistry worked well for Emma & Cyclops, but I don't expect butt hurt Batfans to understand. You can't deny that there maybe something interested underneath the surface.
"Batman fanboy?" LAWL, I HATE Batman & Superman, but even I know that Catwoman and Batman makes way more sense than Supes and Catwoman. It doesn't matter what Catwoman is attracted too, Superman doesn't date/like bad girls. Period. And Emma & Cyclops was a garbage pairing too.
I think they're could be a cool dynamic between the two. Spidey really has no justification of it being a bad thing!
He's never dated anyone like Catwoman and always goes for good girls, Selina already has great chemistry with Bruce Wayne, Catwoman would probably consider him a big idiot, and she doesn't have too many qualities that would appeal to Clark. Enough justification?