• silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Yoda vs Darth Maul, GG, Ventress, Savage, and Dooku. on the Battles board

    I agree

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Yoda vs Darth Maul, GG, Ventress, Savage, and Dooku. on the Battles board

    @jantjepeterWindu and Sidious were still equal. The fight could have gone forever (as stated in novel) if Anakin didn't come. When Anakin reached, mace got a power boost from his fear and disarmed Sid...

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Yoda vs Darth Maul, GG, Ventress, Savage, and Dooku. on the Battles board

    Anakin has never displayed any resistance to TP as far as I know. Dooku and Windu have sensed fear in Anakin. His potential is much high, higher than even Sidious. But he never reached it.Don't undere...

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic ROTJ Luke Skywalker vs Mace Windu. on the Battles board

    I'm a bit confused right now. Experience is almost useless in Star Wars. Vader was really great and Luke defeated him. They are at least even.

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Yoda vs Darth Maul, GG, Ventress, Savage, and Dooku. on the Battles board

    Why would Sidious strike windu with lightning?I had the same doubt. I think it is to create a mental conflict in anakin and force him to take a quick decision. When Windu won the lightsaber part, he s...

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Yoda vs Darth Maul, GG, Ventress, Savage, and Dooku. on the Battles board

    I don't remember exactly but I think somewhere (maybe in Darth plagueis) I read face of Palpatine was fake, and true face of Sidious was like the scarred one due to immersion in dark side. I am not su...

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Yoda vs Darth Maul, GG, Ventress, Savage, and Dooku. on the Battles board

    It doesn't. But the novel is as reliable as the movie for reference. The duel is well explained in the novel.As for the topic, Yoda can remove GG, ventress and Savage from equation easily. That leaves...

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Yoda vs Darth Maul, GG, Ventress, Savage, and Dooku. on the Battles board

    In attack of the clones, anakin says he has already equalled master Yoda in lightsaber skill. Anakin hasn't seen the best of Yoda. His statement is unreliable.Revenge of the sith novel is G-canon as w...

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic ROTJ Luke Skywalker vs Mace Windu. on the Battles board

    Ah, here begins the debate.

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Anakin Skywalker vs Naga Sadow. on the Battles board

    Is there a source that says anakin was unstable and it hindered him in his fight Obi Wan?

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic ROTJ Luke Skywalker vs Mace Windu. on the Battles board

    luke, of course. He beat vader

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic ROTJ Luke Skywalker vs Mace Windu. on the Battles board

    luke, of course. He beat vaden

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Yoda vs Darth Maul, GG, Ventress, Savage, and Dooku. on the Battles board

    Sidious wasn't faking the duel. But he could have killed Mace with his lightning. Mace even with an amp, could only stalemate Sidious. The novel answers a lot of questions regarding this.

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Yoda vs Darth Maul, GG, Ventress, Savage, and Dooku. on the Battles board

    Windu is not more skilled than Yoda. It is stated several times in different sources. Revenge of the sith novel clearly explains why windu was able to win. If Mace was that much skilled, he could have...

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Yoda vs Darth Maul, GG, Ventress, Savage, and Dooku. on the Battles board

    Yoda seems to have an advantage here. How all of them can target someone like Yoda simultaneously? Especially when their skills are not equal and they have never worked together before. It possible th...

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Darth Maul vs. Darth Tyranus. on the Battles board

    Makashi's weakness against Djem so is clearly explained. However, this doesn't mean advantage in strength gives a majority. Skywalker is more skilled than Maul and physically stronger. Juyo is an offe...

  • silvanus posted
    I am alive
  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Maul & Talzin vs. Sidious - Son of Dathomir #04 Final !. on the Gen. Discussion board

    I beleive this will a really cool and extreme duel. I think Maul may get some amp as without it, he is no match for his old master.

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Mace Windu vs. Maul & Savage. on the Battles board

    Maul and Savage takes this. Both can stomp Mace in physical strength, can beat him in force. Maul can equal him in skill and speed. Windu doesn't have much advantage. I don't know how good Mace is aga...

  • silvanus posted a message in the forum topic Darth Bane Vs. Lord Voldemort. on the Battles board

    Force is better than magic for battles. So Bane