Saw the movie last night. Still very torn about this. Was the movie worth going to see? Absolutely.
Is it my favorite Superman movie? No.
Don't flame me (huge Supes fan here), but I really did not care for the characterization of this Superman. He was too thin and I had no real sense of why he was protecting Earth. I mean yeah it is where he grew up and is his home, but I always feel Supes needs a strong moral grounding. This Supes has, what I felt, were some pretty vague reasons for doing what he was doing.
For me, what really gets me going about Superman, is this tremendous desire he has to serve and protect others. Yes he has strong moral fiber, but he is always concerned with others before himself. Hence why when the action gets too hairy, he has to get away city to protect the innocent people around who will inevitably get caught in the crossfire. You could argue that if he had done that here, Zod would just have leveled the city (granted this is after the gravity well was destroyed: during that Supes was doing his best to take it out to save lives). But Zod was so upset at Kal for basically removing any chance he had to rebuild Krypton, I do not think it would have been too big a logical leap for Supes to lure him away somewhere safe to finish him off.
I guess I never really cared what happened to this Superman and I did not get the goose bumps or feel very triumphant when he saved the day like I did in past movies (yes even in Superman Returns).Superman here is not noble. That is the product of trying to make him more realistic I guess, but Superman is an archetype and if I want reality, then I won’t go see a movie with a guy who flies in it.
Again, don’t flame me. I want to love this movie so bad, but I just can’t. And I am rambling a bit because I am so disappointed still (my hopes for this movie were BIG, probably too big). I am not trying to compare it to Chris Reeve, but it is hard not to when his portrayal in Superman the Movie was so classic and iconic. I will always have those movies, so nothing really changes for me. I appreciate everyone else’s opinions and am glad a lot of you guys love this movie. Here is hoping the movie does great so we can have another go around with the Man of Steel.
Log in to comment