@GManFromHeck I'm reading comics for over 20 years by now and i kinda enjoying what Brian Azzarello is doing with her, i think it's to have some diferent stuff from time to time and this also make me move from book to book following what looks nice to read by the time.
5 points will be consider here: Storytelling - Expressions - Body Language - Background - Overall look.
Storytelling: Ivan 5 stars Vs Jim 5 stars - both are great, very complex but also easy to understand, it's a draw!
Expressions: Ivan 5 stars Vs Jim 4 stars - Jim needs a better variety of expressions, hes faces looks almost always the same. Ivan gets this one!
Body Language:Ivan 4 stars Vs Jim 4 stars - both are very good, but not amazing, as many times they fight moves don't make much sense and it gets a lot of repetition over the years, always drawing the same pose at similar moments.
Background: Ivan 5 stars Vs Jim 4 stars - I think Ivan does less BG than Jim, but many time this is better as Jim sometimes put so many things inside a pane that makes it a little bit over.
Overall Look: Ivan 5 stars Vs Jim 5 stars - Well this is more like taste, and to me they are both amazing and i love to see them on any action book.
So to me even i like both the same it seems like Ivan wins 2 Vs 0 and 3 draws, what makes Ivan better than Jim!
Log in to comment