@bronze_surfer: Well...there are many what if scenarios that lead to endless conjecture.
I think what I mean, is if we are considering this fight, each character doing their absolute best and with no compunction about killing their opponent to get the job done, Surfer is just too fast for most characters to tag. Matter of fact, all PIS off, bloodlusted? Surfer decks Thor before he has a chance to react, then takes a shot at Odin. Thing is, in many scenarios, speed is king. But when you are as powerful as Odin, that same speed is virtually moot. IMHO, Odin is right up there with Galactus in power. Surtur, generally is considered on par with Odin in power. Surfer might be able to tip the scales in favor of Surtur.
SS can fly fast. He can't punch fast. It will take more then one blitz from SS to take down Thor. In fact in their last fight when SS did blitz Thor both of them got hurt. SS has not shown the strength or ability to constantly zip past thor and knock him out with light speed punches. I think Thor has fought Surtur before. I don't think Surtur can take out Thor as quickly as Odin can take out Surtur. Even if it is SS/Surtur vs Odin it's still like a lion and a squirrel vs a lion. I'm giving the slight edge to Team 1
@king_saturn: Odin can 1 shot silver surfer and then he and Thor fight surtur. I don't know who would win betwen Odin with Thor and Surtur.
Odin can't one shot Silver Surfer... because he will be busy fighting his rival known as Surtur. Thor and Silver Surfer will more than likely tussle...
Hmm, well actually Thor can add more to this battle than Surfer, so I will say team 1. Thor has actually hurt Odin before, so I don't see why he can't help take down Surtur mean while Odin one-shots Surfer.
What makes you think Thor can add more to this battle than Silver Surfer ?
Hasn't Thor fought Surtur before? Wasn't it an extended battle? I know that within the last 5 yrs when Odin was in Limbo constantly killing surtur, who would come back to life every day, Thor helped Odin in battle to defeat surtur. I don't remember all the details but i think Thor can last longer against Surtur then SS can against Odin.
@dccomicsrule2011: @king_saturn: @xanni15: @dboyrules2011: I don't like the Hall Of Fame process. They let people in just for being better then average. I personally think you should only get in if you have a career that was unmatched or if you never played then the game would have suffered. So going by your own personal standards, do these people deserve to be in the HOF:
Pretend you have a 17 yr old daughter. Your only child. She lives with you. She has a new friend she is thinking of dating and wants your opinion of him. She brings him home and it's the AVATAR of the user above you. Using your knowledge of the AVATAR do you say Yay or Nay?
If I had first pick to build a team, and I could choose from Kobe,Jordan or Lebron...... I would take Jordan. Even though KB and LBJ have skills that or size that Jordan lacks, his will power( Basketballs Greatest Green Lantern) and basketball IQ were undeniable.