@nickzambuto: I agree with you there, however he did give a Good fight to Batman, who would go through this Gauntlet with Relative Ease (Maybe not Flash, but he would beat him
Deathstroke was literally the warm up for an amateur Batman. He was nothing in Arkham, a good rival for John Diggle being their both special forces, but that's at best.
Batman wouldn't get passed round 4 either given he's never ever faced an opponent with the skill speed of Bronze Tiger, let alone both at once in conjunction with Captain Boomerang's accuracy. Arkham Batman himself at his absolute prime would get slaughtered in round 4; Arkham Batman might be within the top 5 most overrated characters on the vine. I mean who has he beaten? Featless Ra's al Ghul and featless Deathstroke. Wow, I'm so impressed.
Arsenal did beat Wildcat's sidekick H2H, who had about as many feats as any of Daredevil's opponents did. He also held back Nyssa by himself and even defeated her by catching her with a stun gun, Nyssa being a comparable opponent to Nobu, who Matt didn't even stand a chance against. Roy also matched Matt's feat of defeating three opponents while handcuffed, except Roy was arguably in a more difficult situation. Honestly he wins both rounds, people shouldn't underestimate Roy, he might be a low tier in Arrow, but Matt would be as well. Roy was a very tough kid.