Batman Vs Captain America is one of the most even battles possible in fiction, and I've always been adamant that the only possible conclusion is a stalemate. But now this punk with his fancy scans has ruined that perfect result and convinced me Batman would actually win.
Not to say wolverine08 didn't do just as good a job with his arguments, but I just feel like from the way each debater presented their posts, comicstooge was more convincing. The feats he posted for Batman just seem better than those posted for Cap IMO, his arguments were fresh and he had a lot of scans that I'd never seen before, whereas wolverine08 didn't really surprise me, he just followed the same formula usually used in Cap debates. Don't get me wrong, said formula is very solid, and if this were any other debate I'd have voted for wolverine, but comicstooge REALLY surprised me with how spectacular of a job he did.