Battle for the Cowl had a great storyline the only flaw that we saw is what happened afterward. The comic had everything; a great setup and ending that everyone was satisfied with; we believe that the DC writers were actually planning on bring Bruce back so quickly that they would have had a different ending than the one with Dick winning against Jason Todd. If Jason Todd was to win the Battle for the Cowl I believe that they would have sold a lot more comics; I know we've seen a Batman terrorize Gotham (example: Batman KnightFall) but I think that it would have been a better story line if Bruce actually had a reason to come back to Gotham. Seeing Jason Todd as Batman would have been a treat for all readers and also a chance to eliminate useless villains like Calendar Man.