@cameron83: WIS is tough to overcome. One of my gripes with comics is inconsistency with super-powers. How can Superman be fast enough to travel to the sun in 30 seconds in one story, than too slow to stop a shooting 3 blocks away in the next? Maybe your "Olympic Judging" is the best way. (In some Olympic events, they throw out the high score and the low score, than average the rest.)
Marshall Rogers for Batman. Going to sound like an old codger..(and that's okay) I think much of the art was better in the 70's and 80's than it is now. Crappy paper, no computers, etc. Not saying none of the recent art is good, but to me, guys like Adams and Rogers did more with less.