Maladicta

@Lvenger:

First, those are the scans from when Supergirl has been aware of her powers for all of five minutes, and as your scans show, she can't control them; even freaking out when X-ray vision kicks in, and accidentally finding out that she can fly... Those scans, really, don't say much, considering she's shown great development in using her pwoers since then...

And you bring up the nanite clone, neglecting that 1) it was using mind control techniques when fighting Kara and 2) when Superman fought it HE was controlling the nanites, it was essentially broken and couldn't fight back. Anybody who tries to use THAT fight to show Superman is stronger than Supergirl either hasn't read it, or only seen a few out of context scans, or is deliberately trying to mislead and lie.

As for the WW fight, all that was stated was that Kara's fighting technique was crap, especially compared to WW. Far more hits in? Hmm, not really, Kara got in more hits, and stronger ones, from the loks of it. Diana was shown using style and technique in that fight, not raw power, which was what Kara used, and not entirely ineffectively.

So as for clarifying... First using scans from when Kara couldn't control her powers basically at all. Second using the extremely bad nanite clone example... Well, you've clarified that you're extremely biased, heh. You REALLY think those two examples made your point?

@matchesmalone21 said:

@Maladicta: so what your point,Dc already stated she isn't more powerful than both..get over it. You have something that can confirm what you said or contradict the above scan? not because it is only your personal opinion

Not sure where DC stated that, but I'm sure you wouldn't say that without having a link? And contradict the above scans? The above scans said nothing about Superman's strength relative to Supergirl... No need to contradict anything. Essentially, the scans you picked were completely useless when debating who is the more powerful of the two, unless you have scans showing how much Supergirl can lift (there aren't any, so far).

@matchesmalone21:

Those scans were supposed to show... what? That was in complete isolation, without comparing to Kara. So... Your point?

@marvel123 said:

@matchesmalone21 said:

@Lvenger: I post in both :)

Supergirl 17

Gallery

after looking at some of WW's recent threads, supergirl holding her own...........thats not how the WW fans see it. to them, WW just knocked out supergirl with very low effort...............i know WW is good but i was kinda disapointed that the writers didn't show supergirl putting up more of a fight.

They (WW fans) conveniently "forget" the side effect of Kara's solar blast - that she loses most of her stored solar energy. Of course WW would win after that... Also, some people are really obsessed with saying WW and Superman are more powerful than Kara, for some odd reason. There's so far been nothing in the n52 to show this to be the case; all examples that gets brought up are pretty much intentional misreadings. Especially some Superman fans go ballistic if anyone insinuates that Superman isn't at least ten times as powerful, heh. Funny that this was never a problem in the Silver Age, when Kara consistently was portrayed as equally powerful (and her best feats back then were arguably better than his; especially her speed feats).

@isaac_clarke said:

@AnyWhichWayButUp said:

@isaac_clarke:

I was trying to say they only get those powers that i listed for the fight

You should include that in the OP.

Pretty clear that's what he said and meant... Anyway. Lantern power, speed, Superman strength and invulnerability + heat vision? Hmm...

@Clark_EL:

She's older, but was in suspended animation the pod.

@isaac_clarke said:

@Maladicta said:

@isaac_clarke said:

@Clark_EL said:

One would expect that to be a case, simply by longer exposure the sun / muscle size - but it was a younger Superman who gave Hal Jordan a thrashing / humiliated him. Hell given his recent machine bench of planetary weight he is stronger than he was before the 52 reboot.

He's not had more exposure to the sun. Kara's pod had been circling the sun for a loooong time.

How long is long? I'm running under the assumption he's had the chance to run about developing that power for years under the sun from near his childbirth.

Decades. Assuming her pod was as fast as Kal's, they've been exposed for sunlight an equal ammount of time.

If the frog is human-sized, it'd collapse under its own weight and not be able to move at all. Physics, yo. Can't just scale things up and expect them to... work.

@Clark_EL said:

@Maladicta: It was in Superman #6 a clone alien thing of Superman beat her down hard, were as Superman beat him quite easily.

Already replied to that. The clone used Mind Control when fighting Kara, and when Kal took over it was breaking down. So, Kara fought it fully functional, Kal fought it while it was already broken. Hardly comparable, wouldn't you say?

@Clark_EL said:

@Maladicta: Well considering Superman beat down an enemy Kara lost to easily, we could make the case that he's more powerful, not to mention he has better feats.

Where did he beat down Kara? They've fought once, in issue 2 of Supergirl. About 10 minutes after she first got her powers, and couldn't control any of them. She, like, discovered flying and X-ray vision mid-fight. Hardly representative.