The Ultimate Superman Elimination Bracket Challenge

From the makers of awesome lists like the Comicvine's Ultimate, Greatest Superhero Team, Comicvine's Top 100 Superhero List, and Comicvine's Top 100 Villains List. We bring you... (as Monty Python would say) “Now for something completely different.” Instead of a list we are going to eliminate characters in bracket form until there is only one survivor.


The Concept

  1. There are four brackets.
  2. Each bracket has it's own blog.
  3. Each week we will vote on one tier of the four brackets.
  4. The voting will technically start on Mondays and end on Saturdays. Sunday's will be the tallying.
  5. The list includes heroes, villains and supporting characters.
  6. Each character is seeded loosely by most appearances.


The Rules for voting

  1. You must be awesome.
  2. You can vote on each match-up of the tier. So, week one will have 32 match-up's for each bracket. You can vote on all of them or just one.
  3. You must know both characters in the match-up. Do not vote just because you like one character and yet have no idea who the other is.
  4. The only criteria for voting is your love of the character. It is not based on power of popularity just what character you like better.
  5. In order to vote you must have either a thousand posts or a thousand wiki points. I have to apologies for this rule up front. It is not my desire to leave anyone out but, there are too many users who make multiple accounts to slant the vote. This is an attempt to remedy that. It is unfortunate some people can ruin it for others. Note: I cannot and will not check every user who posts to see if they have a thousand wiki points but if the vote looks suspicious and you don't have either the wiki or post criteria I will just simply not count your vote.


Disclaimer

  1. I am sure there are awesome characters missing from the list. If I skipped your favorite I am sorry. Doing something like this does take a lot of time and work, but no matter what I do it will never be perfect. Someone might have added a character I left off or I might have made a mistake and missed someone. These things happen. Please, don't whine about it in a bunch of posts.

The other brackets are...

  1. The Ultimate Batman Elimination Bracket Challenge
  2. The Ultimate Spider-man Elimination Bracket Challenge
  3. The Ultimate Wolverine Elimination Bracket Challenge

Results

Here is the bracket and the list of the first tier.

  1.  Superman Vs. Gypsy
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers

Here is the second tier.

  1. Superman Vs. Helena Wayne   
  2. Joker Vs. Psylocke
  3. Dr. Strange Vs. Kingpin
  4. Captain Atom Vs. Hal Jordan
  5. Thor Vs. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch           
  6. Bucky Barns Vs. Renee Montoya
  7. Aquaman Vs. Robbie Robertson
  8. Electra Vs. Wonder Woman
  9. Captain America Vs.  Foggy Nelson
  10. Black Panther Vs. Black Widow
  11. Hawkeye Vs. Hippolyta 
  12. John Stewart Vs. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex
  13. Solomon Grundy Vs. Tempest             
  14. Steel Vs. Leonardo                  
  15. Green Arrow Vs. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing
  16. Beast Boy Vs. Colossus

Here is the third tier.

  1. Superman Vs. Joker                                           
  2. Dr. Strange Vs. Hal Jordan                     
  3. Thor Vs. Bucky Barns Vs. Renee Montoya             
  4. Aquaman Vs. Wonder Woman            
  5. Captain America Vs. Black Panther Vs. Black Widow 
  6. Hawkeye Vs. John Stewart                    
  7. Solomon Grundy Vs. Steel          
  8. Green Arrow Vs. Beast Boy Vs. Colossus        
Here is the fourth tier.
 
  1. Superman Vs. Joker Vs. Hal Jordan                               
  2. Thor Vs. Wonder Woman                               
  3. Captain America Vs. Hawkeye            
  4. Steel Vs. Green Arrow Vs. Colossus                 

Here is tier five.

  1. Superman Vs. Joker Vs. Wonder Woman              
  2. Captain America Vs. Hawkeye Vs. Colossus   
Here is tier six.
 
  1. Superman Vs. Captain America
Start the Conversation
208 Comments
Posted by Liberty

Here is my vote. 
 

  1.  Gypsy
  2. Lightning Lad
  3. Joker
  4. Stargirl
  5. Grifter
  6. Harvey Bullock
  7. Captain Atom
  8. Timber Wolf
  9. Thor
  10. Dan Ketch
  11. Lizard
  12. Renee Montoya
  13. Aquaman
  14. Robbie Robertson
  15. Saturn Girl
  16. Wonder Woman
  17. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  18. Foggy Nelson
  19. Black Panther
  20. Black Widow
  21. Spawn
  22. Lana Lang
  23. John Stewart
  24. Nick Fury
  25. Solomon Grundy
  26. Gwen Stacy
  27. Steel
  28. Leonardo
  29. Kilowog
  30. Swamp Thing
  31. Beast Boy
  32. Jesse Chambers
Posted by The_Tree
  1. Superman
  2. Lightning Lad
  3. Joker
  4. Stargirl
  5. Grifter
  6. Kingpin
  7. Captain Atom
  8. Hal Jordan
  9. Thor
  10. Dan Ketch
  11. Bucky Barnes
  12. Jimmy Olsen
  13. Aquaman
  14. Robbie Robertson
  15. Saturn Girl
  16. Mera
  17. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  18. Foggy Nelson
  19. Black Panther
  20. Black Widow
  21. Hawkeye
  22. Hippolyta
  23. Red Tornado
  24. Nick Fury
  25. Mr. Fantastic
  26. Tempest
  27. Steel
  28. Leonardo
  29. Green Arrow
  30. Swamp Thing
  31. Beast Boy
  32. Colossus
Posted by The Poet
  1. Superman
  2. Helena Wayne
  3. Joker
  4. Stargirl
  5. Dr. Strange
  6. Harvey Bullock
  7. Captain Atom
  8. Hal Jordan
  9. Thor
  10. Dan Ketch
  11. Bucky Barns
  12. Jimmy Olson
  13. Aquaman
  14. Robbie Robertson
  15. Saturn Girl
  16. Wonder Woman
  17. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  18. Chameleon Boy
  19. Colossal Boy
  20. Black Widow
  21. Hawkeye
  22. Lana Lang
  23. John Stewart
  24. Jonah Hex
  25. Mr. Fantastic
  26. Gwen Stacy
  27. Steel
  28. Leonardo
  29. Green Arrow
  30. Loki
  31. Beast Boy
  32. Jesse Chambers
Moderator
Posted by haydenclaireheroes

1. Superman

2. Helena Wayne

3. Joker

4. Stargirl

5. Dr.Strange

6. Kingpin

7. Spider Woman

8. Hal Jordan

9. Thor

10. Watcher

11.Lizard

12. Jimmy Olsen

13. Aquaman

14. Robbie Robertson

15. Electa

16. Wonder Woman

17. Blue Bettle

18. Foggy Nelson

19. Black Panthor

20. Black Widow

21. Hawkeye

22. Lana Lang

23.John Stewart

24. Nick Fury

25. Mr. Fantastic

26. Gwen Stacy

27. Sabretooth

28. Phantom

29. Green Arrow

30. Loki

31. Beast Boy

32. Colosus

Edited by Liberty

Here is the tally so far

  1.  Superman Vs. Gypsy                           3-1
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne      2-2
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific                              4-0
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl                             0-4
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter                           2-2
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock                 2-2
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom     1-3
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf               3-1
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy                             4-0
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                        1-3
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard                        2-2
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya     3-1
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force                    4-0
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture           4-0
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra                         3-1
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera                   3-1
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)     0-4
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy   3-1
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy       3-1
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo    4-0
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn                            3-1
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta                    3-1
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado         3-1
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex                    3-1
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy   3-1
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest                   3-1
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel                           1-3
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo                      1-3
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog                  3-1
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                      2-2
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad                            4-0
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers     2-2
Posted by Bearded Justice

2. Helena Wayne

3. Joker

4. Stargirl

5. Dr. strange

6. Kingpin

7. Captain Atom

8. Hal Jordan

10. Dan Ketch

11. Bucky Barnes

12. Renee Montoya

13. Aquaman

16. Wonder Woman

17. Captain America

21. Hawkeye

22. Hippolyta

23. Red Tornadno

24. Jonah Hex

25. Solomon Grundy

27. Steel

28. Phantom

29. Green Arrow

30. Swamp Thing

31. Toad

32. Colossus

Posted by Liberty

Here is the tally so far

  1.  Superman Vs. Gypsy                           3-1
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne      2-3
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific                              5-0
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl                             0-5
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter                           3-2
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock                 3-2
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom     1-4
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf               4-1
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy                             4-0
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                        1-4
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard                        3-2
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya     3-2
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force                    5-0
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture           4-0
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra                         3-1
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera                   4-1
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)     1-4
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy   3-1
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy       3-1
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo    4-0
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn                            4-1
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta                    3-2
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado         3-2
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex                    3-2
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy   3-2
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest                   3-1
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel                           1-4
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo                      2-3
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog                  4-1
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                      2-3
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad                            4-1
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers     3-2
Posted by _slim_
  1.  Superman Vs. Gypsy
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers
Posted by Liberty

Here is the tally so far

  1.  Superman Vs. Gypsy                           4-1
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne      2-4
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific                              6-0
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl                             1-5
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter                           3-3
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock                 4-2
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom     1-5
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf               5-1
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy                             5-0
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                        1-5
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard                        4-2
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya     3-3
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force                    6-0
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture           5-0
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra                         3-2
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera                   5-1
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)     2-4
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy   4-1
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy       4-1
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo    5-0
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn                            5-1
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta                    3-3
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado         4-2
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex                    4-2
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy   3-3
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest                   3-2
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel                           2-4
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo                      2-4
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog                  4-2
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                      3-3
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad                            5-1
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers     4-2
Posted by Liberty

Six voters on the first day.  Not bad considering I was hoping for a minimum of fifteen in a week.

Posted by The Poet

It is your civic duty as members of CV to vote! so vote!

Moderator
Posted by Liberty

This blog is doing the worst and it is my fault I know.  I would however like to get at least twelve more by the end of Saturday.

Posted by The Poet

@Liberty said:

This blog is doing the worst and it is my fault I know. I would however like to get at least twelve more by the end of Saturday.

how can it be your fault?

Moderator
Posted by Liberty
@The Poet: I didn't post it to the General Discussion.
Posted by KINCART

1 Superman

2 Lightning Lad

3 Joker

4 Stargirl

5 Grifter

6 Kingpin

7 Spider Woman

8 Timber Wolf

9

10

11 Bucky Barns

12 Jimmy Olsen

13 Aquaman

14

15 Saturn Girl

16 Wonder Woman

17 Captain America

18

19 Black Panther

20

21 Spawn

22 Lana Lang

23 Red Tornado

24 Jonah Hex

25 Solomon Grundy

26 Tempest

27 Steel

28

29 Kilowog

30 Swamp Thing

31 Beast Boy

32 Jesse Chambers

Posted by Liberty

Here is the tally so far

  1.  Superman Vs. Gypsy                           5-1
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne      3-4
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific                              7-0
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl                             1-6
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter                           3-4
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock                 5-2
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom     2-5
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf               6-1
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy                             5-0
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                        1-5
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard                        5-2
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya     4-3
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force                    7-0
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture           5-0
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra                         4-2
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera                   6-1
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)     3-4
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy   4-1
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy       5-1
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo    5-0
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn                            5-2
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta                    4-3
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado         4-3
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex                    4-3
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy   3-4
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest                   3-3
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel                           2-5
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo                      2-4
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog                  4-3
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                      3-4
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad                            6-1
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers     4-3
Posted by Hawkeye446
  1. Gypsy
  2. Helena Wayne
  3. Joker
  4. Psylocke
  5. Dr. Strange
  6. Kingpin
  7. Spider Woman
  8. Etta Candy
  9. Watcher
  10. Bucky Barns
  11. Renee Montoya
  12. Aquaman
  13. Vulture
  14. Electra
  15. Wonder Woman
  16. Captain America
  17. Phoebe Cuckoo
  18. Hawkeye
  19. Hippolyta
  20. Red Tornado
  21. Jonah Hex
  22. Solomon Grundy
  23. Tempest
  24. Sabretooth
  25. Phantom
  26. Kilowog
  27. Loki
  28. Toad
  29. Colossus
Posted by Gambit1024
  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers
Posted by kfhrfdu_89_76k
  1. Superman
  2. -
  3. Joker
  4. -
  5. -
  6. Kingpin
  7. -
  8. -
  9. -
  10. Watcher
  11. -
  12. -
  13. -
  14. -
  15. -
  16. -
  17. -
  18. -
  19. -
  20. -
  21. -
  22. -
  23. -
  24. -
  25. Mr. Fantastic
  26. -
  27. -
  28. Leonardo
  29. -
  30. -
  31. -
  32. -
Posted by Liberty
@Gambit1024: For Hawkeye Spawn you have both in bold.  Did you not want to vote on that one or was it a mistake.  If it is a mistake please let me know your vote.
Posted by Liberty

Here is the tally so far
 

  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy                           7-2
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne      3-6
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific                              10-0
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl                             3-6
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter                           5-4
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock                 8-2
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom     3-6
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf               7-1
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy                             6-1
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                        3-6
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard                        7-2
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya     4-5
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force                    9-0
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture           5-2
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra                         4-4
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera                   8-1
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)     5-4
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy   5-1
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy       6-1
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo    6-1
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn                            6-2
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta                    4-5
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado         5-4
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex                    5-4
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy   5-5
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest                   4-4
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel                           4-5
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo                      3-6
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog                  5-4
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                      5-4
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad                            7-2
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers     6-3
Posted by Gambit1024

@Liberty: Mistake. I want Spawn.

Posted by etragedy
  1. Superman
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter
  6. Harvey Bullock
  7. Captain Atom
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch
  11. Lizard
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya
  13. Aquaman
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture
  15. Electra
  16. Wonder Woman
  17. Captain America
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo
  21. Hawkeye
  22. Hippolyta
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado
  24. Nick Fury
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest
  27. Sabretooth
  28. Phantom
  29. Kilowog
  30. Swamp Thing
  31. Toad
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers
Posted by Liberty

Here is the tally so far
 

  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy                           8-2
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne      3-6
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific                              10-0
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl                             3-6
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter                           5-4
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock                 8-3
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom     3-7
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf               7-1
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy                             6-1
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                        3-6
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard                        7-3
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya     4-5
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force                    10-0
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture           5-2
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra                         4-5
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera                   9-1
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)     6-4
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy   5-1
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy       6-1
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo    6-1
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn                            7-3
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta                    4-6
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado         5-4
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex                    6-4
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy   5-5
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest                   4-4
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel                           5-5
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo                      4-6
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog                  5-5
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                      5-5
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad                            7-3
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers     6-3
Posted by The Poet

Going to bump this!

Moderator
Posted by chalkshark
  1. Superman
  2. Helena Wayne
  3. Mr. Terrific ( though his series was terrible and deservedly cancelled)
  4. Stargirl
  5. Dr. Strange
  6. Kingpin
  7. Spider Woman ( Pre-Flash Point, I would've said Captain Atom, but his series is so bad that it's retroactively erased all former love I had for the Captain)
  8. Hal Jordan ( My favorite Green Lantern vs. my favorite Legionnaire. Insidious!)
  9. Thor
  10. Dan Ketch
  11. Bucky Barnes
  12. Renee Montoya
  13. Aquaman ( This is absolutely no contest, but I love Geo-Force, too)
  14. Robbie Robertson
  15. Saturn Girl
  16. Mera
  17. Captain America
  18. Chameleon Boy
  19. Black Panther ( A rare upset over a Legionnaire, but Black Panther is just that awesome!)
  20. Black Widow
  21. Hawkeye
  22. Hippolyta
  23. Red Tornado
  24. Jonah Hex
  25. Solomon Grundy
  26. Gwen Stacy ( Aqualad is the Lamest. Sidekick. Ever. If, on the other hand, this is the Tempest from the Doom Patrol, then he gets my vote)
  27. Steel
  28. Phantom
  29. Green Arrow
  30. Loki
  31. Beast Boy
  32. Colossus ( though Jesse Chambers is very likable)
Posted by Liberty

Here is the tally so far
 

  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy                           9-2
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne      3-7
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific                              10-1
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl                             3-7
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter                           6-4
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock                 9-3
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom     4-7
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf               8-1
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy                             7-1
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                        3-7
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard                        8-3
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya     4-6
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force                    11-0
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture           6-2
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra                         5-5
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera                   9-2
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)     7-4
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy   5-2
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy       7-1
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo    7-1
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn                            8-3
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta                    4-7
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado         5-5
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex                    6-5
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy   5-6
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest                   5-4
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel                           5-6
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo                      5-6
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog                  6-5
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                      6-5
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad                            8-3
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers     7-3
Posted by PikminMania
  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy
  2. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific
  3. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock
  4. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom
  5. Thor Vs. Etta Candy
  6. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch
  7. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard
  8. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya
  9. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture
  10. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra
  11. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera
  12. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  13. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy
  14. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo
  15. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn
  16. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta
  17. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado
  18. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex
  19. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy
  20. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest
  21. Sabretooth Vs. Steel
  22. Phantom Vs. Leonardo
  23. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog
  24. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing
  25. Beast Boy Vs. Toad
Posted by batmanbeyond234

1.Superman

2.SKIP

3.Joker

4.Psylocke

5.Dr. Strange

6.Kingpin

7.Captain Atom

8.Hal Jordan

9.SKIP

10.SKIP

11.Lizard

12.Renee Montoya

13.Aquaman(so tough!)

14.SKIP

15.SKIP

16.Wonder Woman

17.Blue Beetle

18.Chameleon Boy

19.Black Panther

20.SKIP

21.Spawn

22.Hippolyta

23.Red Tornado

24.Jonah Hex

25.Solomon Grundy

26.Tempest

27.Steel

28.Leonardo

29.Green Arrow

30.Swamp Thing

31.Toad

32.SKIP

Posted by Liberty

Here is the tally so far
 

  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy                           11-2
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne      3-7
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific                              12-1
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl                             4-7
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter                           7-4
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock                 11-3
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom     5-8
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf               9-1
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy                             8-1
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                        4-7
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard                        9-4
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya     5-7
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force                    12-0
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture           6-3
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra                         5-6
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera                   11-2
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)     8-5
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy   6-3
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy       8-1
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo    8-1
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn                            8-5
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta                    4-9
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado         6-6
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex                    6-7
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy   6-7
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest                   5-6
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel                           5-8
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo                      5-8
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog                  7-6
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                      6-7
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad                            9-4
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers     7-3
Posted by Liberty

FYI the voting for this tier will go until at least Sunday 2:30pm Eastern Standard time.  After that it gets risky if you want your vote counted.

Posted by Kairan1979
  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers
Posted by Adnan
Posted by Liberty

Here is the tally so far
 

  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy                           13-2
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne      4-8
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific                              13-2
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl                             6-7
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter                           9-4
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock                 13-3
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom     5-10
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf               9-3
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy                             9-2
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                        5-8
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard                        10-5
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya     5-9
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force                    13-1
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture           6-5
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra                         6-7
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera                   13-2
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)     8-7
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy   7-4
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy       9-2
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo    10-1
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn                            8-7
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta                    5-10
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado         6-8
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex                    6-9
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy   6-9
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest                   6-7
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel                           5-10
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo                      6-9
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog                  7-8
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                      6-9
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad                            10-5
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers     7-5
Posted by Liberty

Would like to get nine more voters on this blog.

Posted by Primmaster64
@Kairan1979 said:
  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl
  5. Dr. StrangeVs. Grifter
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers
Posted by Renee
  1. Superman
  2. Lightning Lad
  3. Joker
  4. Psylocke
  5. Dr. Strange
  6. Kingpin
  7. Captain Atom
  8. Hal Jordan
  9. Thor
  10. Watcher
  11. Bucky Barns
  12. Renee Montoya
  13. Aquaman
  14. Robbie Robertson
  15. Electra
  16. Wonder Woman
  17. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  18. Foggy Nelson
  19. Black Panther
  20. Phoebe Cuckoo
  21. Hawkeye
  22. Lana Lang
  23. John Stewart
  24. Nick Fury
  25. Mr. Fantastic
  26. Tempest
  27. Sabretooth
  28. Phantom
  29. Green Arrow
  30. Loki
  31. Beast Boy
  32. Colossus
Posted by GothamRed

1. Superman

2. Lightning Lad

3. Joker

4. Psylocke

5. Dr. Strange

6. Kingpin

7. Spider-Woman

8. Timber Wolf

9. Thor

10. Watcher

11. Bucky

12. Renee Montoya

13. Aquaman

14. Robbie Robertson

15. Saturn Girl

16. Mera

17. Captain America (sorry Jaime)

18. Chameleon Boy

19. Colossal Boy

20. Black Widow

21. Hawkeye

22. Lana Lang

23. John Stewart

24. Nick Fury

25. Solomon Grundy

26. Gwen Stacy

27. Sabretooth

28. Leonardo

29. Green Arrow

30. Loki

31. Beast Boy

32. Colossus

Posted by Jonny_Anonymous
  1.  Superman
  2. Lightning Lad
  3. Joker
  4. Psylocke
  5. Grifter
  6. Harvey Bullock
  7. Captain Atom
  8. Timber Wolf
  9. Etta Candy
  10. Watcher
  11. Bucky Barns
  12. Jimmy Olson
  13. Aquaman
  14. Robbie Robertson
  15. Electra
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera I cant vote on this, it's to hard
  17. Captain America
  18. Foggy Nelson
  19. Black Panther
  20. Black Widow
  21. Spawn
  22. Hippolyta
  23. John Stewart
  24. Jonah Hex
  25. Solomon Grundy
  26. Tempest
  27. Steel
  28. Phantom
  29. Green Arrow
  30. Swamp Thing
  31. Beast Boy
  32. Jesse Chambers
Posted by The Impersonator

1. Superman

2. Helena Wayne

3. Joker

4. Psylocke

5. Dr. Strange

6. Kingpin

7. Spider Woman

8. Hal Jordan

9. Thor

10. Watcher

11. Lizard

12. Jimmy Olson

13. Aquaman

14. Vulture

15. Electra

16. Wonder Woman

17. Captain America

18. Foggy Nelson

19. Black Panther

20. Black Widow

21. Hawkeye

22. Lana Lang

23. Red Tornado

24. Nick Fury

25. Mr. Fantastic

26. Gwen Stacy

27. Sabretooth

28. Phantom

29. Green Arrow

30. Loki

31. Toad

32. Colossus

Edited by Outside_85
  1. Superman
  2. Lightning Lad
  3. Joker
  4. Psylocke
  5. Dr. Strange
  6. Harvey Bullock
  7. Captain Atom
  8. Timber Wolf
  9. Thor
  10. Dan Ketch
  11. Lizard
  12. Renee Montoya
  13. Geo-Force
  14. Vulture
  15. Electra
  16. Wonder Woman
  17. Blue Beetle
  18. Foggy
  19. Black Panther
  20. Black Widow
  21. Spawn
  22. Hippolyta
  23. John Steward
  24. Nick Fury
  25. Solomon Lumpy/Grundy
  26. Tempest
  27. Steel
  28. Leonardo
  29. Kilowog
  30. Loki
  31. Beast Boy
  32. Colossus
Online
Posted by Liberty

Here is the tally so far
 

  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy                           18-2
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne      8-9
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Terrific                              18-2
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl                             11-7
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter                           13-5
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock                 16-5
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom     7-13
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf               11-6
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy                             13-3
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                        9-9
  11. Bucky Barns Vs. Lizard                        13-7
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya     7-12
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force                    17-2
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture           9-7
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra                         7-11
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera                   16-3
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)     11-9
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy   11-5
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy       13-3
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo    14-2
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn                            11-9
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta                    8-12
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado         10-9
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex                    10-10
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy   8-12
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest                   8-10
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel                           8-12
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo                      9-11
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog                  11-9
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                      10-10
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad                            14-6
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers     11-6
Edited by Liberty

Here is the new tier plus my added votes.
 

  1. Superman Vs. Helena Wayne                               1-0
  2. Joker Vs. Psylocke                                                  1-0
  3. Dr. Strange Vs. Kingpin                                            0-1
  4. Captain Atom Vs. Hal Jordan                                 1-0
  5. Thor Vs. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                            0-0-1         
  6. Bucky Barns Vs. Renee Montoya                           0-1
  7. Aquaman Vs. Robbie Robertson                          1-0
  8. Electra Vs. Wonder Woman                                   0-1
  9. Captain America Vs.  Foggy Nelson                      1-0
  10. Black Panther Vs. Black Widow                              0-1
  11. Hawkeye Vs. Hippolyta                                             1-0
  12. John Stewart Vs. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex            1-0-0
  13. Solomon Grundy Vs. Tempest                                 1-0
  14. Steel Vs. Leonardo                                                     0-1
  15. Green Arrow Vs. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                 1-0-0
  16. Beast Boy Vs. Colossus                                            1-0
Posted by The Poet

thought you were going to delete this...and recreate it...

  1. Superman
  2. Joker
  3. Dr. Strange
  4. Hal Jordan
  5. Thor
  6. Bucky Barns
  7. Aquaman
  8. Wonder Woman
  9. Captain America
  10. Black Widow
  11. Hippolyta
  12. John Stewart
  13. Solomon Grundy
  14. Leonardo
  15. Green Arrow
  16. Beast Boy
Moderator
Posted by Zeraphyne

Here it goes:

  1. Superman Vs. Gypsy
  2. Lightning Lad Vs. Helena Wayne
  3. Joker Vs. Mr. Teriffic
  4. Psylocke Vs. Stargirl
  5. Dr. Strange Vs. Grifter
  6. Kingpin Vs. Harvey Bullock
  7. Spider Woman Vs. Captain Atom
  8. Hal Jordan Vs. Timber Wolf
  9. Thor Vs. Etta Candy
  10. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch
  11. Bucky Barnes Vs. Lizard
  12. Jimmy Olson Vs. Renee Montoya
  13. Aquaman Vs. Geo-Force
  14. Robbie Robertson Vs. Vulture
  15. Saturn Girl Vs. Electra
  16. Wonder Woman Vs. Mera
  17. Captain America Vs. Blue Beetle (Reyes)
  18. Foggy Nelson Vs Chameleon Boy
  19. Black Panther Vs. Colossal Boy
  20. Black Widow Vs. Phoebe Cuckoo
  21. Hawkeye Vs. Spawn
  22. Lana Lang Vs. Hippolyta
  23. John Stewart Vs. Red Tornado
  24. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex
  25. Mr. Fantastic Vs. Solomon Grundy
  26. Gwen Stacy Vs. Tempest
  27. Sabretooth Vs. Steel
  28. Phantom Vs. Leonardo
  29. Green Arrow Vs. Kilowog
  30. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing
  31. Beast Boy Vs. Toad
  32. Colossus Vs. Jesse Chambers

Here is the second tier.

  1. Superman Vs. Helena Wayne
  2. Joker Vs. Psylocke
  3. Dr. Strange Vs. Kingpin
  4. Captain Atom Vs. Hal Jordan
  5. Thor Vs. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch
  6. Bucky Barns Vs. Renee Montoya
  7. Aquaman Vs. Robbie Robertson
  8. Electra Vs. Wonder Woman
  9. Captain America Vs. Foggy Nelson
  10. Black Panther Vs. Black Widow
  11. Hawkeye Vs. Hippolyta
  12. John Stewart Vs. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex
  13. Solomon Grundy Vs. Tempest
  14. Steel Vs. Leonardo
  15. Green Arrow Vs. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing
  16. Beast Boy Vs. Colossus
Posted by Liberty
@Zeraphyne: Just for clarification the first tier voting has ended but, the this week is the second tier so I will count your second tier votes.  Also, just so you know we have three other blogs that will determine the final four.  thank you for your vote!
Posted by Liberty
@The Poet: It was very late when I got to it.
Posted by humanfly26
  1. Superman
  2. Joker

  3. Hal Jordan
  4. Thor          
  5. Renee Montoya
  6. Aquaman
  7. Wonder Woman
  8. Captain America


  9. John Stewart
  10. Tempest             
  11. Steel              
  12. Green Arrow
  13. Beast Boy
Posted by Gambit1024

Here is the second tier.

  1. Superman Vs. Helena Wayne
  2. Joker Vs. Psylocke
  3. Dr. Strange Vs. Kingpin
  4. Captain Atom Vs. Hal Jordan
  5. Thor Vs. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch
  6. Bucky Barns Vs. Renee Montoya
  7. Aquaman Vs. Robbie Robertson
  8. Electra Vs. Wonder Woman
  9. Captain America Vs. Foggy Nelson
  10. Black Panther Vs. Black Widow
  11. Hawkeye Vs. Hippolyta
  12. John Stewart Vs. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex
  13. Solomon Grundy Vs. Tempest
  14. Steel Vs. Leonardo
  15. Green Arrow Vs. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing
  16. Beast Boy Vs. Colossus
Edited by Liberty

Tally so far.

  1. Superman Vs. Helena Wayne                               5-0
  2. Joker Vs. Psylocke                                                  4-1
  3. Dr. Strange Vs. Kingpin                                            3-1
  4. Captain Atom Vs. Hal Jordan                                 1-4
  5. Thor Vs. Watcher Vs. Dan Ketch                            3-1-1         
  6. Bucky Barns Vs. Renee Montoya                           2-3
  7. Aquaman Vs. Robbie Robertson                          4-1
  8. Electra Vs. Wonder Woman                                   0-5
  9. Captain America Vs.  Foggy Nelson                      5-0
  10. Black Panther Vs. Black Widow                              2-1
  11. Hawkeye Vs. Hippolyta                                             3-1
  12. John Stewart Vs. Nick Fury Vs. Jonah Hex            4-1-0
  13. Solomon Grundy Vs. Tempest                                 3-2
  14. Steel Vs. Leonardo                                                     2-3
  15. Green Arrow Vs. Loki Vs. Swamp Thing                 4-0-1
  16. Beast Boy Vs. Colossus                                            3-2