The Ultimate Batman Elimination Bracket Challenge

From the makers of awesome lists like the Comicvine's Ultimate, Greatest Superhero Team, Comicvine's Top 100 Superhero List, and Comicvine's Top 100 Villains List. We bring you (as Monty Python would say) “Now for something completely different.” Instead of a list we are going to eliminate characters in bracket form until there is only one survivor.


The Concept

  1. There are four brackets.
  2. Each bracket has it's own blog.
  3. Each week we will vote on one tier of the four brackets.
  4. The voting will technically start on Mondays and end on Saturdays. Sunday's will be the tallying.
  5. The list includes heroes, villains and supporting characters.
  6. Each character is seeded loosely by most appearances.


The Rules for voting

  1. You must be awesome.
  2. You can vote on each match-up of the tier. So, week one will have 32 match-up's for each bracket. You can vote on all of them or just one.
  3. You must know both characters in the match-up. Do not vote just because you like one character and yet have no idea who the other is.
  4. The only criteria for voting is your love of the character. It is not based on power of popularity just what character you like better.
  5. In order to vote you must have either a thousand posts or a thousand wiki points. I have to apologies for this rule up front. It is not my desire to leave anyone out but, there are too many users who make multiple accounts to slant the vote. This is an attempt to remedy that. It is unfortunate some people can ruin it for others. Note: I cannot and will not check every user who posts to see if they have a thousand wiki points but if the vote looks suspicious and you don't have either the wiki or post criteria I will just simply not count your vote.


Disclaimer

  1. I am sure there are awesome characters missing from the list. If I skipped your favorite I am sorry. Doing something like this does take a lot of time and work, but no matter what I do it will never be perfect. Someone might have added a character I left off or I might have made a mistake and missed someone. These things happen. Please, don't whine about it in a bunch of posts.

The other brackets are...

  1. The Ultimate Superman Elimination Bracket Challenge
  2. The Ultimate Spider-man Elimination Bracket Challenge
  3. The Ultimate Wolverine Elimination Bracket Challenge

Here is the bracket and the list of the first tier.

  1. Batman Vs. Secret
  2. Huntress Vs. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo
  4. Tim Drake Vs. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima
  6. Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man
  7. Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel
  8. Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang
  9. Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain
  10. War Machine Vs. Metamorpho
  11. Donna Troy Vs. Demon
  12. Wally West Vs. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot
  14. Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino
  15. Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen
  16. Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man Vs. Ice
  18. Wonder Girl Vs. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto
  20. Perry White Vs. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen
  22. Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus Vs. X-23
  24. Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian (Jim Harper)
  25. Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku
  26. General Ross Vs. Pyro
  27. Roy Harper Vs. Electro
  28. Punisher Vs. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite
  30. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl
  31. Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel Vs. Abomination

Tier Two

  1. Batman Vs.  Bullseye             
  2. Barry Allen Vs. Tim Drake
  3. Scarlet Witch Vs. Dum Dum Dugan
  4. Power Girl Vs. Emma Frost
  5. Invisible Woman Vs. War Machine 
  6. Donna Troy Vs. Wally West
  7. Dr. Doom Vs. Hawkgirl 
  8. Plastic Man Vs. Lois Lane 
  9. Iron Man Vs. Raven
  10. Norm Osborn Vs. Fire
  11. Kitty Pryde Vs. Starfire 
  12. Galacticus Vs. Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian (Jim Harper)
  13. Human Torch Vs. General Ross
  14. Roy Harper Vs. Punisher
  15. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl
  16. Booster Gold Vs. Archangel

Tier Three

  1. Batman Vs. Tim Drake                                         
  2. Scarlet Witch Vs. Power Girl                               
  3. Invisible Woman Vs. Wally West                         
  4. Dr. Doom Vs. Plastic Man                                 
  5. Iron Man Vs. Raven Vs. Fire                               
  6. Kitty Pryde Vs. Starfire Vs. Galacticus              
  7. Human Torch Vs. Roy Harper                               
  8. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Booster Gold                    

Tier Four

  1. Batman Vs.  Power Girl                          
  2. Wally West Vs. Dr. Doom                         
  3. Iron Man Vs. Kitty Pryde                   
  4. Human Torch Vs. Booster Gold       

Tier Five

  1. Batman Vs.  Wally West                     
  2. Kitty Pryde Vs. Human Torch Vs. Booster Gold       

Tier six.

  1. Batman Vs. Kitty Pryde
340 Comments
340 Comments
Posted by Liberty

Here is my vote

  1. Batman
  2. Huntress
  3. Barry Allen
  4. Tim Drake
  5. Maxima
  6. Dum Dum Dugan
  7. Mary Marvel
  8. Captain Boomerang
  9. Cassandra Cain
  10. War Machine
  11. Donna Troy
  12. Wally West
  13. Deadshot
  14. Hawkgirl
  15. Bart Allen
  16. Lone Ranger
  17. Ice
  18. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn
  20. Fire
  21. Vixen
  22. Starfire
  23. X-23
  24. Guardian
  25. Human Torch
  26. General Ross
  27. Roy Harper
  28. Michelangelo
  29.  Dr. Midnite
  30. Duplicate Girl
  31. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel
Posted by The Poet

@Liberty: ok, so I vote for who I want to win and number it 1 through 32, correct?

Moderator
Posted by Liberty
@The Poet: You can vote for as many or as few of the 32 match-ups that you want.
Posted by The_Tree

Hope I'm doing it right.

  1. Batman
  2. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen
  4. Tim Drake
  5. Scarlet Witch
  6. Dum Dum Dugan
  7. Mary Marvel
  8. Captain Boomerang
  9. Cassandra Cain
  10. Metamorpho
  11. Donna Troy
  12. Sinestro
  13. Deadshot
  14. Rhino
  15. Bart Allen
  16. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man
  18. Raven
  19. Norman Osborn
  20. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde
  22. Starfire
  23. Galactus
  24. Guardian
  25. Human Torch
  26. General Ross
  27. Roy Harper
  28. Michelangelo
  29. Dr. Midnite
  30. Jarvis
  31. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel
Posted by The Poet

@Liberty: alright. I'll vote in the morning...

Moderator
Posted by Liberty
@The_Tree: Perfect.
 
@The Poet: Sweet
Posted by jhazzroucher

No Storm? : (

Anyway,

  1. Batman Vs. Secret
  2. Huntress Vs. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo
  4. Tim Drake Vs. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima
  6. Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man
  7. Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel
  8. Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang
  9. Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain
  10. War Machine Vs. Metamorpho
  11. Donna Troy Vs. Demon
  12. Wally West Vs. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot
  14. Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino
  15. Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen
  16. Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man Vs. Ice
  18. Wonder Girl Vs. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto
  20. Perry White Vs. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen
  22. Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus Vs. X-23
  24. Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian
  25. Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku
  26. General Ross Vs. Pyro
  27. Roy Harper Vs. Electro
  28. Punisher Vs. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite
  30. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl
  31. Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel Vs. Abomination
Posted by Liberty
@jhazzroucher: She is on one of the other blogs.  There are four.   256 characters.  You can vote on as many or as few as you like.
Posted by jhazzroucher

@Liberty said:

@jhazzroucher: She is on one of the other blogs. There are four. 256 characters. You can vote on as many or as few as you like.

I only found Strom but not Storm. : (

Posted by Liberty
@jhazzroucher: Oops.... I'll have to fix that after work.
 
Here is the tally so far 

Batman Vs. Secret                           3-0
Huntress Vs. Bullseye                    2-1
Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo      3-0
Tim Drake Vs. Lobo                         2-1
Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima                2-1
Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man     3-1
Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel               1-2
Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang   1-2
Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain  1-2
War Machine Vs. Metamorpho        1-2
Donna Troy Vs. Demon                    2-1
Wally West Vs. Sinestro                   1-2
Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot                    1-2
Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino                            2-1
Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen                 1-2
Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger             0-3
Iron Man Vs. Ice                                   2-1
Wonder Girl Vs. Raven                       0-3
Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto               1-2
Perry White Vs. Fire                            0-3
Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen                           2-1
Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris                    3-0
Galacticus Vs. X-23                           2-1
Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian              0-3
Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku     3-0
General Ross Vs. Pyro                     3-0
Roy Harper Vs. Electro                     3-0
Punisher Vs. Michelangelo             0-3
J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite  0-3
Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl                  1-2
Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold        0-3
Archangel Vs. Abomination             2-1
Posted by The Poet
  1. Batman
  2. Huntress
  3. Barry Allen
  4. Tim Drake
  5. Scarlet Witch
  6. Mole Man
  7. Mary Marvel
  8. Captain Boomerang
  9. Invisible Woman
  10. Metamorpho
  11. Donna Troy
  12. Sinestro
  13. Deadshot
  14. Hawkgirl
  15. Plastic Man
  16. Lois Lane
  17. Ice
  18. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn
  20. Perry White
  21. Vixen
  22. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus
  24. Judge Dredd
  25. Human Torch
  26. General Ross
  27. Electro
  28. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson
  30. Jarvis
  31. Martha Kent
  32. Archangel
Moderator
Posted by Renee
  1. Batman
  2. Bullseye
  3. Mindee Cuckoo
  4. Tim Drake
  5. Maxima
  6. Mole Man
  7. Power Girl
  8. Emma Frost
  9. Invisible Woman
  10. War Machine
  11. Donna Troy
  12. Wally West
  13. Dr. Doom
  14. Hawkgirl
  15. Bart Allen
  16. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man
  18. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn
  20. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde
  22. Starfire
  23. X-23
  24. Judge Dredd
  25. Human Torch
  26. Pyro
  27. Roy Harper
  28. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson
  30. Duplicate Girl
  31. Martha Kent
  32. Archangel
Posted by haydenclaireheroes

1. Batman

2. Huntress

3. Bary Allen

4. Tim Drake

5. Scarlet Witch

6. Mole Man

7. Mary Marvel

8. Emma Frost

9. Invisible Woman

10. War Machine

11.Donna Troy

12.Wally West

13. Dr. Doom

14. Hawkgirl

15. Bart Allen

16. Lois Lane

17. Iron Man

18. Wonder girl

19. Norm Osborn

20.Perry White

21. Kitty Pryde

22. Carol Ferris

23. X-23

24. Guardian

25. Human Torch

26. General Ross

27. Roy Harper

28. Punisher

29. J. Jonah Jameson

30. Jarvis

31.Martha Kent

32. Archangel

Posted by Liberty

Tally so far
 
Batman Vs. Secret                           6-0
Huntress Vs. Bullseye                    4-2
Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo      5-1
Tim Drake Vs. Lobo                         5-1
Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima                4-2
Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man     3-4
Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel               2-4
Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang   3-3
Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain  4-2
War Machine Vs. Metamorpho        3-3
Donna Troy Vs. Demon                    5-1
Wally West Vs. Sinestro                   3-3
Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot                    3-3
Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino                            5-1
Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen                 2-4
Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger             2-4
Iron Man Vs. Ice                                   4-2
Wonder Girl Vs. Raven                       1-5
Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto               4-2
Perry White Vs. Fire                            2-4
Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen                           4-2
Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris                    4-2
Galacticus Vs. X-23                           3-3
Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian              2-4
Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku     6-0
General Ross Vs. Pyro                     5-1
Roy Harper Vs. Electro                     5-1
Punisher Vs. Michelangelo             1-5
J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite  3-3
Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl                  3-3
Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold        3-3
Archangel Vs. Abomination             5-1

Posted by Sheep-Kill
  1. Batman
  2. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen
  4. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch
  6. Mole Man
  7. Mary Marvel
  8. Captain Boomerang
  9. Invisible Woman
  10. War Machine
  11. Demon
  12. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom
  14. Rhino
  15. Bart Allen
  16. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man
  18. Raven
  19. Mephisto
  20. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde
  22. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus
  24. Guardian
  25. Human Torch
  26. Pyro
  27. Electro
  28. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson
  30. Duplicate Girl
  31. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel
Posted by Liberty

Tally so far
 
Batman Vs. Secret                           7-0
Huntress Vs. Bullseye                    4-3
Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo      6-1
Tim Drake Vs. Lobo                         6-1
Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima                5-2
Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man     3-5
Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel               2-5
Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang   3-4
Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain  5-2
War Machine Vs. Metamorpho        4-3
Donna Troy Vs. Demon                    5-2
Wally West Vs. Sinestro                   3-4
Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot                    4-3
Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino                            5-2
Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen                 2-5
Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger             2-5
Iron Man Vs. Ice                                   5-2
Wonder Girl Vs. Raven                       1-6
Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto               4-3
Perry White Vs. Fire                            2-5
Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen                           5-2
Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris                    4-3
Galacticus Vs. X-23                           4-3
Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian              2-5
Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku     7-0
General Ross Vs. Pyro                     5-2
Roy Harper Vs. Electro                     5-2
Punisher Vs. Michelangelo             1-6
J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite  4-3
Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl                  3-4
Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold        3-4
Archangel Vs. Abomination             6-1

Posted by batmanbeyond234

1.Batman

2.Bullseye

3.Barry Allen

4.Lobo

5.Maxima

6.Dum Dum Dugan

7.Mary Marvel

8.Emma Frost

9.Invisible Woman

10.Metamorpho

11.Etrigan

12.Sinestro

13.Deadshot

14.Hawkgirl

15.Plastic Man

16.Lone Ranger

17.Ice

18.Raven

19.Mephisto

20.Fire

21.Vixen

22.Starfire

23.Galactus

24.Judge Dredd

25.SKIP

26.General Ross

27.Electro

28.Michelangelo

29.J. Jonah Jameson

30.Jarvis

31.Booster Gold

32.Archangel

Posted by Bearded Justice

2. Huntress

4. Tim Drake

5. Scarlet Witch

6. Dum Dum Dugan

7. Power Girl

8. Captain Boomerang

9. Cassandra Cain

10. War Machine

11. Donna Troy

12. Wally West

13. Dr. Doom

14. Hawkgirl

15. Plastic Man

16. Lone Ranger

17. Iron Man

18. Raven

19. Norman Osborn

20. Fire

21. Vixen

22. Starfire

26. Pyro

27. Roy Harper

28. Punisher

29. Dr. Midnite

31. Booster Gold

32. Archangel

Posted by Liberty

Tally so far
 
Batman Vs. Secret                           8-0
Huntress Vs. Bullseye                    5-4
Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo      7-1
Tim Drake Vs. Lobo                         6-2
Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima                6-3
Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man     6-3
Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel               3-6
Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang   4-5
Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain  7-2
War Machine Vs. Metamorpho        5-4
Donna Troy Vs. Demon                    6-3
Wally West Vs. Sinestro                   4-5
Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot                    5-4
Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino                            7-2
Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen                 4-5
Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger             2-7
Iron Man Vs. Ice                                   6-3
Wonder Girl Vs. Raven                       1-8
Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto               5-4
Perry White Vs. Fire                            2-7
Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen                           5-4
Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris                    6-3
Galacticus Vs. X-23                           5-3
Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian              3-5
Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku     7-0
General Ross Vs. Pyro                     6-3
Roy Harper Vs. Electro                     6-3
Punisher Vs. Michelangelo             2-7
J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite  5-4
Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl                  4-4
Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold        3-6
Archangel Vs. Abomination             8-1

Posted by _slim_
  1. Batman Vs. Secret
  2. Huntress Vs. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo
  4. Tim Drake Vs. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima
  6. Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man
  7. Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel
  8. Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang
  9. Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain
  10. War Machine Vs. Metamorpho
  11. Donna Troy Vs. Demon
  12. Wally West Vs. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot
  14. Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino
  15. Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen
  16. Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man Vs. Ice
  18. Wonder Girl Vs. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto
  20. Perry White Vs. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen
  22. Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus Vs. X-23
  24. Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian
  25. Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku
  26. General Ross Vs. Pyro
  27. Roy Harper Vs. Electro
  28. Punisher Vs. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite
  30. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl
  31. Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel Vs. Abomination
Posted by Liberty

Tally so far
 
Batman Vs. Secret                           9-0
Huntress Vs. Bullseye                    5-5
Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo      8-1
Tim Drake Vs. Lobo                         7-2
Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima                7-3
Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man     7-3
Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel               4-6
Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang   5-5
Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain  8-3
War Machine Vs. Metamorpho        6-4
Donna Troy Vs. Demon                    6-4
Wally West Vs. Sinestro                   4-6
Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot                    6-4
Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino                            7-3
Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen                 5-5
Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger             2-8
Iron Man Vs. Ice                                   7-3
Wonder Girl Vs. Raven                       1-9
Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto               6-4
Perry White Vs. Fire                            3-7
Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen                           6-4
Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris                    6-4
Galacticus Vs. X-23                           6-3
Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian              3-6
Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku     8-0
General Ross Vs. Pyro                     6-4
Roy Harper Vs. Electro                     6-4
Punisher Vs. Michelangelo             3-7
J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite  6-4
Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl                  5-4
Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold        3-7
Archangel Vs. Abomination             9-1

Posted by Liberty

Ten voters on the first day.  Not bad considering I was hoping for a minimum of fifteen.

Posted by Gambit1024
  1. Batman Vs. Secret
  2. Huntress Vs. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo
  4. Tim Drake Vs. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima
  6. Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man
  7. Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel
  8. Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang
  9. Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain
  10. War Machine Vs. Metamorpho
  11. Donna Troy Vs. Demon
  12. Wally West Vs. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot
  14. Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino
  15. Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen
  16. Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man Vs. Ice
  18. Wonder Girl Vs. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto
  20. Perry White Vs. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen
  22. Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus Vs. X-23
  24. Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian
  25. Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku
  26. General Ross Vs. Pyro
  27. Roy Harper Vs. Electro
  28. Punisher Vs. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite
  30. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl
  31. Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel Vs. Abomination
Posted by Liberty

Tally so far
 
Batman Vs. Secret                           10-0
Huntress Vs. Bullseye                    5-6
Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo      9-1
Tim Drake Vs. Lobo                         8-2
Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima                8-3
Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man     7-4
Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel               5-6
Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang   6-5
Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain  9-3
War Machine Vs. Metamorpho        6-5
Donna Troy Vs. Demon                    7-4
Wally West Vs. Sinestro                   5-6
Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot                    7-4
Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino                            8-3
Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen                 6-5
Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger             3-8
Iron Man Vs. Ice                                   8-3
Wonder Girl Vs. Raven                       1-10
Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto               7-4
Perry White Vs. Fire                            4-7
Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen                           7-4
Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris                    7-4
Galacticus Vs. X-23                           7-3
Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian              3-7
Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku     9-0
General Ross Vs. Pyro                     6-5
Roy Harper Vs. Electro                     7-4
Punisher Vs. Michelangelo             4-7
J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite  7-4
Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl                  6-4
Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold        3-8
Archangel Vs. Abomination             10-1

Posted by Liberty

Archangel and Raven are the first to get double digits in voting.

Posted by The Poet

@Liberty said:

Archangel and Raven are the first to get double digits in voting.

Yay! heres to many more double digits!

Moderator
Posted by haydenclaireheroes

YAY can't wait to see who makes it to the next round

Posted by Liberty
@haydenclaireheroes: This blog is doing the best so far.  For what ever reason not everyone has been voting in all four blogs.  I am hoping to get at least ten more on this blog.
Posted by Hawkeye446
  1. Batman
  2. Huntress
  3. Mindee Cuckoo
  4. Tim Drake
  5. Scarlet Witch
  6. Mole Man
  7. Mary Marvel
  8. Emma Frost
  9. Cassandra Cain
  10. Metamorpho
  11. Donna Troy
  12. Wally West
  13. Dr. Doom
  14. Hawkgirl
  15. Plastic Man
  16. Lois Lane
  17. Ice
  18. Wonder Girl
  19. Mephisto
  20. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde
  22. Carol Ferris
  23. X-23
  24. Guardian
  25. Human Torch
  26. Pyro
  27. Electro
  28. Michelangelo (the first Turtle I have voted for)!
  29. Dr. Midnite
  30. Jarvis
  31. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel

@Liberty: This is my 4th. I love the idea and best of all it doesn't take to long!!! :)

Posted by Switchdoctor

Batman

Huntress

Barry Allen

Lobo

Maxima

Dum Dum Dugan

Power Girl

Captain Boomerang

Invisible Woman

War Machine

Donna Troy

Wally West

Deadshot

Hawkgirl

Plastic Man

Lois Lane

Ice

Wonder Girl

Mephisto

Fire

Vixen

Carol Ferris

Galactus

Guardian

Human Torch

General Ross

Electro

Michelangelo

Dr. Midnite

Duplicate Girl

Booster Gold

Archangel

Posted by RUKM

Batman
Bullseye
Barry Allen
Lobo
Scarlet Witch
Mole Man
Power Girl
Emma Frost
Invisible Woman
War machine
Wally West
Deadshot          
Rhino                           
Lone Ranger 
Iron man
Raven                      
Norm Osborn
Kitty Pryde
Starfire
X-23        
Judge Dredd
Human torch
Pyro                    
Electro                    
Punisher
J. Jonah Jameson
Jarvis
Booster Gold 
Archangel

Posted by Liberty
@Hawkeye446: Thanks.  I am glad you are here.  Spread the word.
Posted by Liberty

Tally so far
 
Batman Vs. Secret                           13-0
Huntress Vs. Bullseye                    7-7
Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo      11-2
Tim Drake Vs. Lobo                         9-4
Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima                10-4
Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man     8-6
Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel               7-7
Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang   8-6
Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain  11-4
War Machine Vs. Metamorpho        8-6
Donna Troy Vs. Demon                    9-4
Wally West Vs. Sinestro                   8-6
Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot                    8-6
Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino                            10-4
Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen                 8-5
Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger             5-9
Iron Man Vs. Ice                                   9-5
Wonder Girl Vs. Raven                       3-11
Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto               8-6
Perry White Vs. Fire                            4-9
Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen                           9-5
Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris                    8-6
Galacticus Vs. X-23                           8-5
Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian              4-9
Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku     12-0
General Ross Vs. Pyro                     6-8
Roy Harper Vs. Electro                     7-7
Punisher Vs. Michelangelo             6-8
J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite  8-6
Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl                  7-6
Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold        3-11
Archangel Vs. Abomination             13-1

Posted by ReVamp
The Rules for voting
  1. You must be awesome.
  1. You can vote on each match-up of the tier. So, week one will have 32 match-up's for each bracket. You can vote on all of them or just one.
  1. You must know both characters in the match-up. Do not vote just because you like one character and yet have no idea who the other is.
  1. The only criteria for voting is your love of the character. It is not based on power of popularity just what character you like better.
  1. In order to vote you must have either a thousand posts or a thousand wiki points. I have to apologies for this rule up front. It is not my desire to leave anyone out but, there are too many users who make multiple accounts to slant the vote. This is an attempt to remedy that. It is unfortunate some people can ruin it for others. Note: I cannot and will not check every user who posts to see if they have a thousand wiki points but if the vote looks suspicious and you don't have either the wiki or post criteria I will just simply not count your vote.

Why is everyone else voting?

Edited by Adnan

Here are my incredibly biased choices

  1. Batman
  2. Huntress
  3. Barry Allen
  4. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch
  6. Dum Dum Dugan, what a badass name
  7. Mary Marvel
  8. Captain Boomerang, he has THE POWER TO THROW BOOMERANGS REALLY GOOD
  9. Invisible Woman
  10. Metamorpho
  11. Demon...Etrigan, right?
  12. Wally West
  13. Dr. Doom
  14. Hawkgirl
  15. Plastic Man
  16. Lois Lane
  17. Iron Man
  18. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn
  20. Fire
  21. Vixen
  22. Starfire, though I can't stand either of them
  23. Galacticus
  24. Judge Dredd
  25. Human Torch
  26. Pyro
  27. Electro
  28. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson
  30. Duplicate Girl
  31. Martha Kent
  32. Abomination
Posted by Liberty
@Adnan: Did you mean to leave both candidates for number 25...and boomerangs are awesome.
Posted by Adnan

@Liberty: ah, I didn't mean too. I edited it now.

Posted by Daveyo520
  1. Batman
  2. Huntress
  3. Barry Allen
  4. Tim Drake
  5. Scarlet Witch
  6. Mole Man
  7. Power Girl
  8. Emma Frost
  9. Invisible Woman
  10. War Machine
  11. Donna Troy
  12. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom
  14. Rhino
  15. Bart Allen
  16. Lois Lane
  17. Iron Man
  18. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn
  20. Perry White
  21. Kitty Pryde
  22. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus
  24. Judge Dredd
  25. Human Torch
  26. General Ross
  27. Electro
  28. Michelangelo (The Ninja Turtle right? if not Punisher)
  29. J. Jonah Jameson
  30. Jarvis
  31. Booster Gold (I never thought I would vote for Booster on something)
  32. Archangel
Posted by Kairan1979
  1. Batman Vs. Secret
  2. Huntress Vs. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo
  4. Tim Drake Vs. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima
  6. Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man
  7. Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel
  8. Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang
  9. Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain
  10. War Machine Vs. Metamorpho
  11. Donna Troy Vs. Demon
  12. Wally West Vs. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot
  14. Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino
  15. Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen
  16. Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man Vs. Ice
  18. Wonder Girl Vs. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto
  20. Perry White Vs. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen
  22. Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus Vs. X-23
  24. Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian
  25. Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku
  26. General Ross Vs. Pyro
  27. Roy Harper Vs. Electro
  28. Punisher Vs. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite
  30. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl
  31. Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel Vs. Abomination
Posted by papad1992

Here's my input!!!:

  1. Batman Vs. Secret
  2. Huntress Vs. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo
  4. Tim Drake Vs. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima
  6. Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man
  7. Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel
  8. Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang
  9. Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain
  10. War Machine Vs. Metamorpho
  11. Donna Troy Vs. Demon
  12. Wally West Vs. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot
  14. Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino
  15. Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen
  16. Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man Vs. Ice
  18. Wonder Girl Vs. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto
  20. Perry White Vs. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen - ooooohhh.... tough one!!!
  22. Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus Vs. X-23 - only because she was the character I played as to beat Galactus in MvC3
  24. Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian
  25. Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku
  26. General Ross Vs. Pyro - depends... is he in his Red Hulk appearance or his general appearance!? If he's in his general appearance I choose Pyro!!
  27. Roy Harper Vs. Electro
  28. Punisher Vs. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite
  30. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl
  31. Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel Vs. Abomination

DONE!!!

Posted by etragedy
  • Not voting on all pairings, just some because I copy pasted, if I delete a line it renumbers the list, so if I leave a matchup that's no vote/opinion on that match, if I leave only one name after a number, that's my vote in that matchup (request an unnumbered list in future that can be quoted - thanks!)
  1. Batman Vs. Secret
  2. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo
  4. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima
  6. Dum Dum Dugan
  7. Power Girl
  8. Emma Frost
  9. Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain
  10. Metamorpho
  11. Demon
  12. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot
  14. Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino
  15. Plastic Man
  16. Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man
  18. Wonder Girl Vs. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn
  20. Perry White
  21. Kitty Pryde
  22. Starfire
  23. Galacticus Vs. X-23
  24. Judge Dredd
  25. Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku
  26. General Ross Vs. Pyro
  27. Roy Harper Vs. Electro
  28. Punisher
  29. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite
  30. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl
  31. Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel Vs. Abomination
Edited by Bloodwolfassassin
  1. Batman
  2. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen
  4. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch
  6. Dum Dum Dugan
  7. Mary Marvel
  8. Captain Boomerang
  9. Cassandra Cain
  10. War Machine
  11. Demon
  12. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom
  14. Hawkgirl
  15. Bart Allen
  16. Lois Lane
  17. Iron Man
  18. Raven
  19. Mephisto
  20. Fire
  21. Vixen
  22. Starfire
  23. Galacticus
  24. Judge Dredd
  25. Human Torch
  26. General Ross
  27. Roy Harper
  28. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson
  30. Duplicate Girl
  31. Booster Gold
  32. Abomination
Posted by KINCART

1 Batman

2 Huntress

3

4 Lobo

5 Maxima

6

7 Mary Marvel

8 Emma Frost

9 Cassandra Cain

10 War Machine

11 Donna Troy

12 Wally West

13 Dr. Doom

14 Rhino

15 Plastic Man

16 Lois Lane

17 Iron Man

18 Raven

19

20 Fire

21 Vixen

22 Starfire

23

24

25 Human Torch

26 General Ross

27 Roy Harper

28 Michelangelo

29 J. Jonah Jameson

30

31 Martha Kent

32 Abomination

Posted by Liberty

Tally so far
 

  1. Batman Vs. Secret                           19-0
  2. Huntress Vs. Bullseye                    11-10
  3. Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo      15-3
  4. Tim Drake Vs. Lobo                         12-8
  5. Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima                14-6
  6. Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man     13-7
  7. Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel               11-10
  8. Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang   13-8
  9. Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain  14-7
  10. War Machine Vs. Metamorpho        11-10
  11. Donna Troy Vs. Demon                    13-7
  12. Wally West Vs. Sinestro                   11-10
  13. Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot                    13-7
  14. Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino                            14-6
  15. Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen                 12-8
  16. Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger             11-9
  17. Iron Man Vs. Ice                                   14-7
  18. Wonder Girl Vs. Raven                       3-17
  19. Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto               12-8
  20. Perry White Vs. Fire                            6-14
  21. Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen                           12-9
  22. Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris                    14-7
  23. Galacticus Vs. X-23                           11-7
  24. Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian              9-10
  25. Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku     18-0
  26. General Ross Vs. Pyro                     11-10
  27. Roy Harper Vs. Electro                     11-9
  28. Punisher Vs. Michelangelo             9-12
  29. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite  13-7
  30. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl                  9-9
  31. Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold        5-15
  32. Archangel Vs. Abomination             16-4
Posted by chalkshark
  1. Batman
  2. Bullseye
  3. Mindee Cuckoo ( I actually don't care for any of the "Stepford Cuckoos", but Barry Allen is the most boring character ever conceived)
  4. Lobo
  5. Scarlet Witch
  6. Dum Dum Dugan
  7. Power Girl
  8. Captain Boomerang
  9. Invisible Woman
  10. Metamorpho
  11. Demon
  12. Wally West
  13. Dr. Doom ( Although, Deadshot is a great character)
  14. Rhino
  15. Plastic Man
  16. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man
  18. Wonder Girl
  19. Mephisto
  20. Fire
  21. Vixen
  22. Starfire
  23. Galactus
  24. Judge Dredd
  25. Human Torch
  26. Pyro
  27. Electro
  28. Punisher
  29. Dr. Midnite
  30. Duplicate Girl
  31. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel
Posted by Liberty

Tally so far
 

  1. Batman Vs. Secret                           20-0
  2. Huntress Vs. Bullseye                    11-11
  3. Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo      15-4
  4. Tim Drake Vs. Lobo                         12-9
  5. Scarlet Witch Vs. Maxima                15-6
  6. Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man     14-7
  7. Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel               12-10
  8. Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang   13-9
  9. Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain  15-7
  10. War Machine Vs. Metamorpho        11-11
  11. Donna Troy Vs. Demon                    13-8
  12. Wally West Vs. Sinestro                   12-10
  13. Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot                    14-7
  14. Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino                            14-7
  15. Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen                 13-8
  16. Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger             11-10
  17. Iron Man Vs. Ice                                   15-7
  18. Wonder Girl Vs. Raven                       4-17
  19. Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto               12-9
  20. Perry White Vs. Fire                            6-15
  21. Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen                           12-10
  22. Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris                    15-7
  23. Galacticus Vs. X-23                           12-7
  24. Judge Dredd Vs. Guardian              10-10
  25. Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku     19-0
  26. General Ross Vs. Pyro                     11-11
  27. Roy Harper Vs. Electro                     11-10
  28. Punisher Vs. Michelangelo             10-12
  29. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite  13-8
  30. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl                  9-10
  31. Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold        5-16
  32. Archangel Vs. Abomination             17-4
Posted by Liberty
@ReVamp said:
The Rules for voting
  1. You must be awesome.
  1. You can vote on each match-up of the tier. So, week one will have 32 match-up's for each bracket. You can vote on all of them or just one.
  1. You must know both characters in the match-up. Do not vote just because you like one character and yet have no idea who the other is.
  1. The only criteria for voting is your love of the character. It is not based on power of popularity just what character you like better.
  1. In order to vote you must have either a thousand posts or a thousand wiki points. I have to apologies for this rule up front. It is not my desire to leave anyone out but, there are too many users who make multiple accounts to slant the vote. This is an attempt to remedy that. It is unfortunate some people can ruin it for others. Note: I cannot and will not check every user who posts to see if they have a thousand wiki points but if the vote looks suspicious and you don't have either the wiki or post criteria I will just simply not count your vote.

Why is everyone else voting?

You realize you haven't voted on this one right?
Posted by PikminMania
  1. Batman Vs. Secret
  2. Huntress Vs. Bullseye
  3. Barry Allen Vs. Mindee Cuckoo
  4. Tim Drake Vs. Lobo
  5. -
  6. Dum Dum Dugan Vs. Mole Man
  7. Power Girl Vs. Mary Marvel
  8. Emma Frost Vs. Captain Boomerang
  9. Invisible Woman Vs. Cassandra Cain
  10. War Machine Vs. Metamorpho
  11. Donna Troy Vs. Demon
  12. Wally West Vs. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom Vs. Deadshot
  14. Hawkgirl Vs. Rhino
  15. Plastic Man Vs. Bart Allen
  16. Lois Lane Vs. Lone Ranger
  17. Iron Man Vs. Ice
  18. Wonder Girl Vs. Raven
  19. Norm Osborn Vs. Mephisto
  20. Perry White Vs. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde Vs. Vixen
  22. Starfire Vs. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus Vs. X-23
  24. -
  25. Human Torch Vs. Tom Kalmaku
  26. General Ross Vs. Pyro
  27. Roy Harper Vs. Electro
  28. Punisher Vs. Michelangelo
  29. J. Jonah Jameson Vs. Dr. Midnite
  30. Jarvis Vs. Duplicate Girl
  31. Martha Kent Vs. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel Vs. Abomination
Posted by ReVamp

@Liberty said:

@ReVamp said:
The Rules for voting
  1. You must be awesome.
  1. You can vote on each match-up of the tier. So, week one will have 32 match-up's for each bracket. You can vote on all of them or just one.
  1. You must know both characters in the match-up. Do not vote just because you like one character and yet have no idea who the other is.
  1. The only criteria for voting is your love of the character. It is not based on power of popularity just what character you like better.
  1. In order to vote you must have either a thousand posts or a thousand wiki points. I have to apologies for this rule up front. It is not my desire to leave anyone out but, there are too many users who make multiple accounts to slant the vote. This is an attempt to remedy that. It is unfortunate some people can ruin it for others. Note: I cannot and will not check every user who posts to see if they have a thousand wiki points but if the vote looks suspicious and you don't have either the wiki or post criteria I will just simply not count your vote.

Why is everyone else voting?

You realize you haven't voted on this one right?

LOL. I can't tell whether that was just a really clever diss, but well done sir. On a sidenote I had a headache and forgot.

Posted by tbone1225
  1. Batman
  2. Huntress
  3. Barry Allen
  4. Tim Drake
  5. Scarlet Witch
  6. Dum Dum Dugan
  7. Power Girl
  8. Emma Frost
  9. Cassandra Cain
  10. War Machine
  11. Donna Troy
  12. Sinestro
  13. Dr. Doom
  14. Rhino
  15. Bart Allen
  16. Lois Lane
  17. Iron Man
  18. Wonder Girl
  19. Norm Osborn
  20. Fire
  21. Kitty Pryde
  22. Carol Ferris
  23. Galacticus
  24. Guardian
  25. Human Torch
  26. General Ross
  27. Electro
  28. Punisher
  29. J. Jonah Jameson
  30. Jarvis
  31. Booster Gold
  32. Archangel