Judge Dredd Give A Point

Synopsis

Here is the fifteenth in a series of Give a point games. With nine of them done I still have four going plus this one. The games that are still going on are Captain America http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/captain-america-give-a-point-1514065/#1 Sergeant Franklin Rock http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/sergeant-franklin-rock-give-a-point-1513487/#150 Superboy: Kon-El/ Conner Kent http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/superboy-kon-el-conner-kent-give-a-point-1518429/#52 and, Black Panther: T'Challa http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/black-panther-t-challa-give-a-point-1514069/#809

Here are the completed lists that resulted from these games

  1. Daredevil: http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/the-quintessential-characters-in-the-daredevil-myt/47581
  2. Iron Man: http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/the-quintessential-characters-in-the-iron-man-myth/47613
  3. Batman: http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/the-quintessential-characters-in-the-batman-mythol/47899
  4. Spirit: http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/the-quintessential-characters-in-the-the-spirit-my/48011
  5. James Bond: http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/the-quintessential-characters-in-the-the-james-bon/48061
  6. Deadpool: http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/the-quintessential-characters-in-the-the-deadpool-/48409
  7. Ghost Rider (Johnny Blaze): http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/the-quintessential-characters-in-the-the-ghost-rid/48473
  8. Wolverine: http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/wolverine-give-a-point-1507128/#1460
  9. Hawkman: http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/the-quintessential-characters-in-the-hawkman-mytho/48738
  10. Turok: http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/the-quintessential-characters-in-the-turok-mytholo/48787

Some have expressed interest in what characters I will make games for. The list I have been working off of is not complete but if you want to take a peak at who might be in the next game you can check out the two lists below. Remember that this is not set in stone yet and is just a work in progress. I work hard on my list and try to make them a accurate as possible as well as put a lot of research in them. Once I have a solid definitive list I will post it but for right now here are the possible glimpses.

  1. http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/self-titled/19980
  2. http://www.comicvine.com/profile/liberty/lists/self-titled-international/47416

Scenario for game

Imagine you are the creator of a Judge Dredd television show (I'm guessing it would be on HBO.) Your task is to tell the history of Judge Dredd from beginning to the end, but....(here is the catch) you can only use ten currently existing characters to tell this story. So, I ask you who are the quintessential characters in the Judge Dredd mythology. You need to determine who he needs in the rouge's gallery, allies, friends and everything.

Rules for this game

Here is how the game works. It is kind of like the give a point take a point game. Only you don't take any points away.

  1. You can add a point to one character for each vote.
  2. You can add a new character any time you want as your vote.
  3. You can vote as much as you want but only once in a row.
  4. All you do is copy the tally above and add your vote or character to the list.
  5. Once we have ten characters with 100 votes each the game is done.
  6. Put a characters real name on this list. There are too many Robins and Batgirls for example to just put a Superhero name.
  7. If the character does not have a comic appearance they will not have a comic page on comicvine. That is OK as long as they meet the other criteria. They will not however make the list I post afterwards because they don't have a page.

I'll cast the first vote for...

  • Judge Anderson (+1)
1262 Comments
1265 Comments
Posted by Liberty
  1. Judge Anderson (+1)
Edited by MisterAnderson

Judge Death (+ 1)

Judge Anderson (+1)

Edited by Dark_Guyver

Judge Death (+ 1)

Judge Anderson (+1)

Judge Caligula (+1)

Posted by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+ 1)
  • Judge Anderson (+1)
  • Judge Caligula (+1)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
Posted by Dark_Guyver

Judge Death (+ 1)

Judge Anderson (+1)

Judge Caligula (+1)

Judge Schaefer (+1)

Chief Judge Fargo (+1)

Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+2)
  • Judge Anderson (+1)
  • Judge Caligula (+1)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (+1)
Posted by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+3)
  • Judge Anderson (+1)
  • Judge Caligula (+1)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (+1)
Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+4)
  • Judge Anderson (+1)
  • Judge Caligula (+1)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (+1)
Edited by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+5)
  • Judge Anderson (+1)
  • Judge Caligula (+1)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (+1)
Posted by Battle_Forum_Junkie

  • Judge Death (+5)
  • Judge Anderson (+1)
  • Judge Caligula (+1)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (+1)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+6)
  • Judge Anderson (+1)
  • Judge Caligula (+1)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (+1)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
Posted by Liberty

  • Judge Death (+6)
  • Judge Anderson (+2)
  • Judge Caligula (+1)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (+1)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
Posted by Liberty

@dark_guyver: The characters have to have met at least once. Did Fargo ever meet Dredd. I know Dredd comes form his blood but I do not know if they actually met.

Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+7)
  • Judge Anderson (+2)
  • Judge Caligula (+1)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (+1)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
Posted by Liberty

  • Judge Death (+7)
  • Judge Anderson (+2)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (+1)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
Posted by Dark_Guyver

@liberty: oops, you're right. They never met.

Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+8)
  • Judge Anderson (+2)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (+1)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
Edited by Liberty

@dark_guyver: No problem. I hope you'll still keep voting for other characters.

Posted by Liberty

  • Judge Death (+8)
  • Judge Anderson (+2)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+9)
  • Judge Anderson (+2)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+10)
  • Judge Anderson (+2)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Dark_Guyver

Judge Death (+10)

Judge Anderson (+2)

Judge Caligula (+2)

Judge Schaefer (+2)

Walter Wobot (+1)

Pa Angel (+1)

Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)

Posted by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+11)
  • Judge Anderson (+2)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
  • Pa Angel (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+12)
  • Judge Anderson (+2)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
  • Pa Angel (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by Dark_Guyver

Judge Death (+12)

Judge Anderson (+3)

Judge Caligula (+2)

Judge Schaefer (+2)

Walter Wobot (+1)

Pa Angel (+1)

Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)

Posted by Fallen_Crippled

Judge Death (+13)

Judge Anderson (+3)

Judge Caligula (+2)

Judge Schaefer (+2)

Walter Wobot (+1)

Pa Angel (+1)

Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)

Edited by Dark_Guyver

Judge Death (+13)

Judge Anderson (+3)

Judge Caligula (+2)

Judge Schaefer (+2)

Walter Wobot (+1)

Pa Angel (+1)

Rico Dredd (+1)

Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)

Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+14)
  • Judge Anderson (+3)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+1)
  • Pa Angel (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by Liberty

  • Judge Death (+14)
  • Judge Anderson (+3)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+15)
  • Judge Anderson (+3)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+16)
  • Judge Anderson (+3)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+17)
  • Judge Anderson (+3)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by Liberty

  • Judge Death (+17)
  • Judge Anderson (+3)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+17)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+18)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+18)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+19)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+19)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+20)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+20)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Satanus (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+21)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Satanus (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+22)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Satanus (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+23)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Satanus (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+24)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Satanus (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+25)
  • Judge Anderson (+4)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Satanus (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+25)
  • Judge Anderson (+5)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Satanus (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Kairan1979

  • Judge Death (+26)
  • Judge Anderson (+5)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Satanus (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Edited by silent_bomber

Dredd has met Fargo, Fargo told him that the Judge system was only ever supposed to be temporary, then he died.

In fact, he's met him at least twice as he and Rico met him once when they were still in training.

Posted by Fallen_Crippled

  • Judge Death (+26)
  • Judge Anderson (+6)
  • Judge Caligula (+2)
  • Judge Schaefer (+2)
  • Walter Wobot (+2)
  • Pa Angel (+2)
  • Mean Machine (+1)
  • Satanus (+1)
  • Rico Dredd (+1)
  • Judge Fire (+1)
  • Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)
Posted by Dark_Guyver

Judge Death (+27)

Judge Anderson (+6)

Judge Caligula (+2)

Judge Schaefer (+2)

Walter Wobot (+2)

Pa Angel (+2)

Mean Machine (+1)

Satanus (+1)

Rico Dredd (+1)

Judge Fire (+1)

Chief Judge Fargo (Disqualified after one vote. Characters never met.)