I think it comes more from how boring he is as Clark Kent and when he is Superman he is always questioning his humanity and connection to humanity. HOnestly, he has had some very bad writing. Brian Azzarello was able to bring me in with his For Tomorrow arc that I thought humanized Superman without making him do something useless like walk across America moping.
Batman has a similar problem. As Bruce Wayne he is uninteresting. It makes sense to be that way when he is in public, but the reader is treated to boredom on a grand scale.
This happens with other characters too. Wolverine was boring for years before his origin finally came out. Spider-Man was so boring that he got out shined by his Ultimate counterpart.
Superman, under Grant Morrison, is cool again. He is cool, because his character is interesting. He is more human in his actions and demeanor than he has been in a while. I am a strong proponent of old characters dying off or being retired so that something new and fresh can be brought in, like Miles Morales (UCSPM) or Dick Grayson. It is a good move for the characters, the story and the readers.
Unfortunately, with someone like Superman you can't really replace him too easily or have him die as a permanent option. This isn't an impossible situation, it just requires dedicated story direction and intense character development with the supporting cast.
Superman has been around for over 60 years. It is easy to take the character for granted and not give the proper edge to writing him that is required. I'm glad he has Grant Morrison on as his writer again. He'll finally be given some thought and consideration beyond the quickie story arc.
Log in to comment