Week 1

Great - best of the week: Detective Comics, Phantom Stranger, Swamp Thing

Good - solid issue: Action Comics, Earth 2, Green Arrow, Green Lantern

Okay - some complaints: Pandora

Top Pick: Swamp Thing

Bottom Pick: Pandora

Week 2

Great - best of the week: Batman, Green Lantern Corps, Justice League

Good - solid issue: Superman Unchained

Okay - some complaints: Nightwing

Top Pick: Justice League

Bottom Pick: Nightwing

Week 3

Great - best of the week: Justice League of America

Good - solid issue: Animal Man, Wonder Woman

Okay - some complaints: Batman and Catwoman, Green Lantern: New Guardians, Vibe

Top Pick: Justice League of America

Bottom Pick: Batman and Catwoman

Week 4

Great - best of the week: Aquaman, Batman: Dark Knight

Good - solid issue: Flash, Larfleeze, Superman, Talon

Dropping from list: Batman/Superman

Top Pick: Aquaman

Bottom Pick: Batman/Superman

Week 5

Great - best of the week: Animal Man Annual, Red Lanterns

Good - solid issue: Batman Annual, Detective Comics Annual, Flash Annual, Superman Annual

Okay - some complaints: Pandora

Top Pick: Animal Man Annual

Bottom Pick: Pandora