To be fair i wasn't surprised that it was cancelled. You have to remember that Jump decides cancellations based on a number of factors, the most important for series less than a year old being popularity (readers sending in replies indicating which series was in their top 3), coupled with genera-type and whether or not the series has a stable readership or not (for series which last longer it then incorporates whether or not the series has an anime/a successful franchise beyond the manga, and graphic novel sales). Samurai 8, unfortunatly, became a victim of the early 2000's success of the big-3. By that i mean, and i know this devolvs into a "my series is better than yours" fanboy argument, but Nauto, Bleach and One Piece (very much like Dragonball before them) changed how shonen action series were written and viewed. What was revolutionary back then is now a standard, so Samuai 8 wasn't going to revolutionise the way that shonen action series were written or percieved (no matter how good/bad it was).
In addition to that, it became a victim of the success of Naruto. So when Naruto stated back in 1999 it lucked out BIG TIME by having its first chapter debute in the same volume of JUMP that the final chapter of Kenshin was published in, so in addition to having readers checking out the new series first chapter it also became a escue-raft of sorts for fans of Kenshin which had just finished (jumping onto a new series). In addition to that, as far as action series were concerned, Naruto's notable competition were "One Piece (1997)", "Yu-Gi-Oh! (1996)", "Zombie Powder (1999)", "shaman king (1998)", and "Hunter X Hunter (1998)", and I'll be honest, those are just the action series which had wiki enteries as Jumps revolving door of manga titles leaves many in the wastes of obscurity (literally zombie powder would also have been a similaarly obscure title had Bleach not come along and popularised Kubo's works, as that series lasted a max of 4 volumes). When compared to its contemporaries Naruto was, yes, an action series like then BUT it was different enough not to get lost by Jump fans who would have thought "i like it... but its just way to similar to this other series". So Naruto survives and reaches its 700th chapter in 2014... and thats where the other nail in the coffin for Samurai 8 came.
Naruto Chapter 700 released in 2014. The mini arc "Naruto: The Seventh Hokage and the scarlet spring" is released and completes its run in 2015. Additional Naruto works are anime based, light novels and then the Boruto series which is a monthly series not released in WSJ. So Naruto fans (the oldest being readers who started with it in 1999) have either jumped over to Boruto, leaving WSJ behind, or now just purchase it in collected graphic novel form. Fans, mostly the younger ones, who still read WSJ have now turned their attentions to other series in WSJ which will scratch their Naruto itch, notably "world trigger (2013)", "My Hero Academia (2014)" and "black clover (2015)", so by the time samurai 8 came out in 2019 the WSJ fans had jumped over to these newer action titles, which had then been bolstered in rank by "demon slayer (2016)", and even "Jujutsu Kaisen (2018)". In short, the "action" fanbase of WSJ had, and still is, spread wide between a number of diffarent action series, with all but one having anime series, so series such as "Tokyo Shinobi Squad", "zipman" and even "samuri 8" didn't stand a chance unless they brought something completely new and original to the table and unfortunatlly Samurai 8 didn't. Notably, this is also why we're seeing a lot more Gag/gag-action series starting in Jump at the moment as there's no way a new action series will be able to gain a headway and survive given the current jump line-up of long running action series (unless a series comes to an end). Also, gag series don't need to have the same level of fan feedback to survive as they can happily hangout in the middle of the magazine and be stable.
But yeh, Samurai 8 was a victim of Naruto's success and couldn't compete with other action series which were now using the Naruto/Bleach/One Piece formula of writing an action manga. I mean, looking back at JUMP series this isn't the first time a successful mangaka's follow-up series has been cancelled after a shot run (just compare the 27 volumes of Kenshin vs the 4 volumes of "gun blaze western"), but if series are to similar to either their predecessor series, or they can't distinguish themsleves from their current competition they just don't succeed, and with JUMP recieving numerous drafts for new series on a weekly basis why keep a series with no support running while others with potential can take its place? In some weird logical way this also why i think "burn the witches" is getting a release as its following up on the the new Bleach anime arc finally being released, its a shorter series (the manuscript has been completed, so its not going to be a long running series) so it won't be competing with other long running series, but in addition to that the title alone "burn the withc" is similar to the new WSJ series "guardian of the witch" which, given the possible return of Kubo fans to WSJ (with their attentions not being divided with another monthly magazine) and you can possibly see the WSJ editorial trying to make a long shot bet of getting Kubo fans to become Sakano fans and help make series (which they deffinanlty took a long shot with, given how difficult it is for new action series to break their way into JUMP at the moment) break into the WSJ action line-up ina way that other series like samurai 8 couldn't. Would that be a bit of a gimmik? yes, but the benefits do outweigh the negatives (negative, they loose guardian of the witches, and replace it with another series).
Honeslty though, i remeber Kishmoto made a baseball one-shot once and i thought that it was great. I think, if he's sticking with shonen series and not just milking the naruto success, he should re-visit that and produce a shonen sports series. It would show that he's capable of doing other kinds of manga, and would open up his works to other fans.
Log in to comment