If DC wanted to give everyone ugly costumes and not use some characters, they could of did that without doing some half-baked reboot. Also agree with the tip-toeing on the full reboot thing, ether go all the way or don't do it at all.
@John Valentine: Well, I'm over-exaggerating a little. I do that, lol.
Seriously though, all of my absolute favorite Batman work has been under Dini's pen. If you wanna get technical, yes, the Arkham Asylum game was based on Morrison's story, but Mask of the Phantasm, Arkham City, Heart of Ice, etc. were all his babies. As far as comic book runs go, I'm a huge fan of what Snyder's been doing, so I'll say him for right now (because he's still not done). Morrison's Arkham Asylum was probably my absolute favorite thing he ever wrote, so Batman one-shot's go to him. Batman stories in general, in my opinion, go to Dini.
Animated Series Batman to me is the definitive Batman. So for me Dini/Timm > Morrison > Snyder.
Snyder for me. I do not like Morrison as a writer or as a person. New X-Men, Cassandra Nova, changing Beast's appearance, publicity stated that Batman is gay, having Joker imply that there is a homosexual relationship, and because of the age difference you know what else this implies, between Batman and Robin in Arkham Asylum: Serious House/Serious Earth and the list goes on. All of this is from Morrison.
Morrison gave us Damian Wayne so he wins.
By taking an idea from an Elseworld story that he did not even read.
Point being he expanded on someone's else work and gave us Damian Wayne. Go Damian!