@Gentleman_of_the_Bedchamber said:
Similarity's help in a rivalry, certainly, but I would like to point out a rivalry that has more fame in video games and may serve as an exception.
The Player and Gary (Mother****ing) Oak in the original Pokemon Red and Blue games and remakes.
From beginning till end Gary is taunting, jeering, showing up with Pokemon that are either stronger then yours or difficult to counter at rather inappropriate times, talking down to you with an air of superiority that even Lex Luthor might deem a little excessive (he is 10 years old), being always one step ahead (he became Champion before you did) and generally being the smug, magnificent bastard he is.
He's the classic "bully" archetype. The kid who always steals your favorite swing, kick's sand in your face, make's smug observations and tell's you and the whole world that he is better then you.
Do you have much in common with him? Probably not. Does that stop you from wanting to knock him of his high-horse ass? HELL. ****ING. NO.
Actually, the player and Prof Oak are the real jerks. Gary is just a young orphan looking for his grandpa's attention. Sure, he is a bit aggressive but really not that bad and all along the journey, he keeps giving you advice.
The player is a jerk. He can clearly see Gary is this sad kid but he never tells him to stop trying to fight him and all he does is beating him, taking his money and Oak's attention.
The grandpa is even worse. He does not care about how his orphaned grandchild feels. He clearly shows over and over that the player is his favorite, no matter how it may be affecting his grandchild. And anyway, he just wants to have impressionable children doing his work for him. Come on: "Gary, I am disappointed. I came when I heard that you beat the Elite Four but when I got here, you had already lost!" to a kid who is already fragile. What a jerk!
Fair enough. A lot depends on how one interprets the characters and so forth. I'd say that the stuff you mentioned for the players feelings are somewhat moot as the player's feeling's are... the players. Since the main character is a silent one I say that the player is more of a jerk by plot rather then character. And of course a lot of people did feel sorry for Gary by the end of it.
Prof. Oak might be as big of a jerk as you say but some may say that he's at least somewhat concerned by his grandsons lack of respect, that he probably doesn't know how to deal with it right (like Reed Richards, etc. of course that raise's the question of how he dealt with his own son) and that his favoritism is a misguided attempt to teach Gary some humility though is unaware of his insecurity (something that to what degree exist's also depends on interpretation). All that said Gary likely only has his sister for emotional support (who is probably too sweet to point out his flaw's.)
...Now that you mention it their is some creepily Freudian subtext in how the player and Gary compete for Oak's affection's as a father figure... 0_o
Oh well, just goes to show their is more to your basic school bully rivalry then meet's the eye and that Pokemon is totally serious business. XD
Log in to comment